Live data from Hacker News

PHP will switch to git

news.php.net

41–50 of 108 posts

Re: PHP will switch to git

#41
post #24
post #22

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Haha. You beat me to it!

I went from 999 to 992. I guess I should have kept my mouth shut, but it was worth it. But tbh, I have nothing against PHP; it was just a joke.

Wow, I went from 999 to 964.. that's 35 down-votes! This is insane, but not surprising coming from PHP folks. (Too serious to laugh, too stupid to switch, too stubborn to think, too old to learn, amen.)

Re: PHP will switch to git

#42
post #33
post #2

Rasmus gave a talk yesterday and I asked if they were switching to github. He said they'd likely switch to git (it's now happening, apparently), but not github because it can't do ACLs and the PHP project has thousands of people who need commit access to various places.

Was there any official statement stating that they would switch to GitHub? All I see is that they're switching to git.

no; they aren't moving to github at least right now

Re: PHP will switch to git

#44
post #2

Rasmus gave a talk yesterday and I asked if they were switching to github. He said they'd likely switch to git (it's now happening, apparently), but not github because it can't do ACLs and the PHP project has thousands of people who need commit access to various places.

Wonder if they knew about GitHub Organizations?

https://github.com/blog/674-introducing-organizations

Re: PHP will switch to git

#45
post #40

Git appears to be fast becoming the standard DVCS. Is there any reason that all reasonably well-run projects should not be using git? GitHub seems vastly superior to BitBucket, and git itself seems pretty much isomorphic to hg (albeit with worse syntax). (This ignores darcs, bzr, etc., but those never seemed terribly competitive for mindshare.) Furthermore, the network effects (with pull requests on Github, not havin…

I'm a pious hg user - even gave git a good run (mostly because of Github). I can't get over how amazing mercurial patch-queues are. Big win. I love mercurial's easy plugin development and hooks (thank you Python); I love how many awesome plugins exist for mercurial. On and on and on.

I keep seeing people talk about all the good of hg over git, but I haven't seen anything that really sets it apart.

If you were doing a sales pitch, what would you show that hg has over git? What are some specific plugins that ease your development or release process? What are some real-world advantages of the hg patch-queue over how git handles pulls?

I'm honestly curious. I just haven't seen anything to sell me on why hg is so much better than git (or even the other way around).

Re: PHP will switch to git

#46
post #2

Rasmus gave a talk yesterday and I asked if they were switching to github. He said they'd likely switch to git (it's now happening, apparently), but not github because it can't do ACLs and the PHP project has thousands of people who need commit access to various places.

Wonder if they knew about GitHub Organizations? https://github.com/blog/674-introducing-organizations

This only provides repo level access control. They want ACL's to control down to the branch level.

Re: PHP will switch to git

#47
post #40

Git appears to be fast becoming the standard DVCS. Is there any reason that all reasonably well-run projects should not be using git? GitHub seems vastly superior to BitBucket, and git itself seems pretty much isomorphic to hg (albeit with worse syntax). (This ignores darcs, bzr, etc., but those never seemed terribly competitive for mindshare.) Furthermore, the network effects (with pull requests on Github, not havin…

I'm a pious hg user - even gave git a good run (mostly because of Github). I can't get over how amazing mercurial patch-queues are. Big win. I love mercurial's easy plugin development and hooks (thank you Python); I love how many awesome plugins exist for mercurial. On and on and on.

Next time you have to use git: Remember, there are also patch-queues for git.

Re: PHP will switch to git

#48
post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What treffer said. It'll be like the old days of sourceforge, just better and simpler. I love how easy it is to commit to projects on github. Also love the idea of a centralized place to follow all your favorite projects. If linux can be on github i would think php could as well.

>I love how easy it is to commit to projects on github It's as simple to commit projects to github as it is to sf, bitbucket, google code, etc. Wait... you need to set up ssh credentials on github... sorry, it's more difficult to commit a project to github than it is to most of the alternatives. >Also love the idea of a centralized place to follow all your favorite projects. It's good that we like different things. I…

> It's as simple to commit projects to github as it is to sf, bitbucket, google code, etc. Wait... you need to set up ssh credentials on github... sorry, it's more difficult to commit a project to github than it is to most of the alternatives.

You can just as easily use it over HTTPS and use your github login (which is how a lot of SVN repos are setup).

SF, BitBucket, Google Code, et. all are no easier or harder than GitHub for getting access. You have to register for all of them and setup your credentials for the repo on all of them.

:)

Re: PHP will switch to git

#49

Git appears to be fast becoming the standard DVCS. Is there any reason that all reasonably well-run projects should not be using git? GitHub seems vastly superior to BitBucket, and git itself seems pretty much isomorphic to hg (albeit with worse syntax). (This ignores darcs, bzr, etc., but those never seemed terribly competitive for mindshare.) Furthermore, the network effects (with pull requests on Github, not havin…

As someone who choose hg over git w/o reviewing bitbucket vs github, I'm curious what makes github superior. Can you elaborate?

Re: PHP will switch to git

#50

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>I love how easy it is to commit to projects on github It's as simple to commit projects to github as it is to sf, bitbucket, google code, etc. Wait... you need to set up ssh credentials on github... sorry, it's more difficult to commit a project to github than it is to most of the alternatives. >Also love the idea of a centralized place to follow all your favorite projects. It's good that we like different things. I…

> It's as simple to commit projects to github as it is to sf, bitbucket, google code, etc. Wait... you need to set up ssh credentials on github... sorry, it's more difficult to commit a project to github than it is to most of the alternatives. You can just as easily use it over HTTPS and use your github login (which is how a lot of SVN repos are setup). SF, BitBucket, Google Code, et. all are no easier or harder than…

To be fair, it's easier to commit to a project on Github. There's an 'edit' button, which lets you make changes inline on the website.
Post reply on HN