Live data from Hacker News

Return YouTube dislike count

returnyoutubedislike.com

41–50 of 96 posts

Re: Return YouTube dislike count

#41
post #15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I am interested to know what your day to day experience is and what quantifies wasting ones time? What if that is the persons hobby and passion was it really time wasted or was it rewarding to the author?

Their hobby and passion is to restore Youtube's dislike button?

Their hobby and passion is to build something they could be used by thousands of people and put it out for free

Re: Return YouTube dislike count

#42
post #24

This is a weirdly polarizing topic. I don't think I've ever clicked on the dislike button, personally (but I do click on the like button, occasionally). It would seem like people use the dislike button to signal that "I don't agree with the premise of the video" as much as it's to signal that "this video is actually crap". Same as with Reddit downvotes - it shouldn't be used for downvoting legit content that you don'…

> you have no idea if it's really a crap video or if it was just brigaded by people who live by "alternative facts" and don't like the specific video due to it having _actual_ facts

I feel like this would only apply to a few areas that are highly polarized (COVID stuff, political, etc.). But the vast majority of content I (and most people) watch does not fall into heavily polarized topics like that and the risk of brigading is zero.

Re: Return YouTube dislike count

#43

Currently we're using youtube API to get dislikes count ...so they just hid it from the user, and the actual number is still there if you know where to look? That's surprising.

The public dislike count will be removed from the API next month unless the api call is authed with an account associated with the channel.

God. Even if you buy the "social experience" argument (which I don't really), removing it from the API for non-owners is just malicious.

Re: Return YouTube dislike count

#44

I think the removal of the Dislike shows one of the key problems of Social Media. They want to act as old school broadcasters in the information age. The Dislike button made companies immediately aware of the success of a campaign, something that terrified the heads of marketing. The idea is that once you remove the risk of executives to be exposed to bad publicity will go away. I don't think it will work but it show…

The button will still be there but only the creators will be able to see the numbers, so it won't affect companies' ability to be aware whether their campaign was successful or not.

Re: Return YouTube dislike count

#45
post #24

This is a weirdly polarizing topic. I don't think I've ever clicked on the dislike button, personally (but I do click on the like button, occasionally). It would seem like people use the dislike button to signal that "I don't agree with the premise of the video" as much as it's to signal that "this video is actually crap". Same as with Reddit downvotes - it shouldn't be used for downvoting legit content that you don'…

Biggest miss is tutorials etc. Dislike ratio really useful to judge which ones are not worth the time.

yea, or product reviews (especially for more esoteric things). you can immediately tell if its real or a bot generated slideshow with a TTS of amazon reviews

Re: Return YouTube dislike count

#46
post #20

I think the removal of the Dislike shows one of the key problems of Social Media. They want to act as old school broadcasters in the information age. The Dislike button made companies immediately aware of the success of a campaign, something that terrified the heads of marketing. The idea is that once you remove the risk of executives to be exposed to bad publicity will go away. I don't think it will work but it show…

Democracy dies in darkness. This is another step towards the shade...

How much closer toward the shade did society move when reddit removed dislike counts? Did we move away from the shade when YouTube introduced them in the first place? Is adding and then removing net neutral? So many questions about this hyperbole...

Re: Return YouTube dislike count

#47
post #24

This is a weirdly polarizing topic. I don't think I've ever clicked on the dislike button, personally (but I do click on the like button, occasionally). It would seem like people use the dislike button to signal that "I don't agree with the premise of the video" as much as it's to signal that "this video is actually crap". Same as with Reddit downvotes - it shouldn't be used for downvoting legit content that you don'…

Outside of politics and other controversial topics, the dislike button is immensely useful in determining the quality of a video. If one has several thousand likes and just a few dislikes, you can be relatively certain that the video meets or surpasses expectations. If, on the other hand, it has a high number of dislikes, there's a good chance that the video will not meet the average user's expectations. If you play those videos, usually the issue will surface for you as well and you can save yourself the remaining time on the video looking for better content.

Re: Return YouTube dislike count

#48
post #24

This is a weirdly polarizing topic. I don't think I've ever clicked on the dislike button, personally (but I do click on the like button, occasionally). It would seem like people use the dislike button to signal that "I don't agree with the premise of the video" as much as it's to signal that "this video is actually crap". Same as with Reddit downvotes - it shouldn't be used for downvoting legit content that you don'…

> IMO the dislike count is useless for filtering out "bad" content

I don't know what kind of content you consume on youtube, but this does not reflect my experience at all. I'm regularly researching repair/modding manuals or enthusiast videos and the dislike count is a very, very good way of telling how good a video will be. Sometimes things are done in a really bad or even dangerous way, or the whole video is just someone describing the problem and then skipping the actual fix.

The only other place I've seen dislikes is at pr videos that went viral for their outright offensive hypocrisy or otherwise badly formulated message, which I wouldn't call a bad use either.

Post reply on HN