Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: New way to search for used cars (my weekend project)

olegkikin.com

41–50 of 71 posts

Re: Show HN: New way to search for used cars (my weekend project)

#41
This is fantastic. I'm working on something similar for other product categories. One rule of thumb I'm going by is to show as few results to the user as possible. Shopping sites often offer so much choice that the user is too paralysed to make a decision.

I'd change the default setting from showing all brands to 2-3 at most. Simple sliders to narrow down the price and mileage range would improve the usability a lot. Plus, if you're presenting any information as shape, colour or size, you need to show a key which explains what it means.

You've done remarkably well to put this up in a weekend. I need to pull my socks up and release my v1 asap.

Good luck!

Re: Show HN: New way to search for used cars (my weekend project)

#43
I have to be honest here, whilst technically this is very good, from a customer's perspective and from a "person what works in the industry" perspective, I feel this isn't the best. It's certainly new, but that doesn't mean the user experience is any good.

I agree that the standard "pick a make and model and hope for the best" kind of search is in dire need of an update, but I don't have the UX design experience or even the creativity to invent a new way of doing it, but what I do know, is what currently works, and what doesn't.

Instant feedback on the search as you are performing it is cool, and I've recently worked on a system that feeds back to the user the amount of cars that are going to be returned by their selected criteria as they select them, and it works pretty well and looks great, degrades nicely and allows someone to make a quick judgement about how broad or narrow their search is on the fly.

I'd like to see a new way to search for used cars that merges this level of visual detail with the standard selection criteria based way of searching, and hopefully something great can grow out of that, but until then, mixing up the interface like this will just confuse people.

Apart from my qualms, I do think this is pretty excellent and daring, but not really practical at the current time.

Re: Show HN: New way to search for used cars (my weekend project)

#45
post #27

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is what I got when I tried in Safari 5.05 under Snow Leopard. Not sure if it helps since you can't test but here ya go. Also shows the errors I got in the error log console. http://img4.imageshack.us/img4/3154/screenshot20110815at134....

I think it didn't like the gzipped JS file with the data. Not sure why, pretty much all modern browsers should support it.

Try naming the gzip file something else, like .js.jgz. Safari automatically opens many archive types, including, I believe, gzip.

Re: Show HN: New way to search for used cars (my weekend project)

#46
post #23

There's a 2005 Bentley Continental GT for $29,800. Seems like a good buy. I think someone forgot a zero? http://www.cars.com/go/search/detail.jsp?tracktype=usedcc&#3... Your app made it easy enough to find an exception like this.

There's also several cars for $299, but in the description are $2990 down...

It's a deceptive listing, but in the description on cars.com you can see that these are $299 per month for 72 months

Re: Show HN: New way to search for used cars (my weekend project)

#47
post #36

Is the idea to separate the wheat from the chaff? For a good deal, my eye tends to look away from the cluster and find outliers, but these $399 or leases not the asking price.

This same thing comes up in eBay, Craigslist...

Some court should declare that a headline is a real offer, and if someone calls to accept, then it's a binding contract.

Re: Show HN: New way to search for used cars (my weekend project)

#49

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Where did you find the used car data?

Downloaded 20 search results pages from cars.com. I wish I had direct access to their DB. Craigslist has a ton of car postings, but it's not structured in any way, will be very hard to parse.

I wonder if Carmax has an API...
Post reply on HN