Live data from Hacker News

Run old games in DOSBox in the browser

naclbox.com

41–44 of 44 posts

Re: Run old games in DOSBox in the browser

#41

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I was less referring to the security issues, as I'm familiar with Google's efforts on those fronts, and more referring the lack of cross browser support. ActiveX sucked for a number of reasons, but one reason in particular was because it forced people to use IE even after IE 6 became the most inferior browser on the market by a long shot in terms of both security and performance. If NaCl becomes popular enough, eithe…

I don't see lock-in issues as a concern. It's an open spec, if it becomes popular enough then even if other browsers don't want to support it developers can make plugins for those browsers (some of the papers even mention this, I believe). In any case, if websites require you to use NaCl it is only stupid unless they are doing something that otherwise wouldn't be feasible e.g. running a performance hungry emulator. I…

What about architecture lock-in? Good luck running x86 NaCl apps on your iphone.

Re: Run old games in DOSBox in the browser

#42

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I was less referring to the security issues, as I'm familiar with Google's efforts on those fronts, and more referring the lack of cross browser support. ActiveX sucked for a number of reasons, but one reason in particular was because it forced people to use IE even after IE 6 became the most inferior browser on the market by a long shot in terms of both security and performance. If NaCl becomes popular enough, eithe…

I don't see lock-in issues as a concern. It's an open spec, if it becomes popular enough then even if other browsers don't want to support it developers can make plugins for those browsers (some of the papers even mention this, I believe). In any case, if websites require you to use NaCl it is only stupid unless they are doing something that otherwise wouldn't be feasible e.g. running a performance hungry emulator. I…

> I don't see lock-in issues as a concern. It's an open spec

There isn't any open spec here. NaCl is a research project, not a spec or a proposal.

Re: Run old games in DOSBox in the browser

#43
post #38
post #25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Actually it is better for security.

Because it runs userspace code on x86, instead of running kernel-level code on the GPU?

Because we know, those days, to sandbox raw x86 code, and not let them access the system and the drivers... However, running shaders directly on the GPU exposes directly graphic drivers, that are not conceived to block unfriendly code.

Re: Run old games in DOSBox in the browser

#44
post #37
post #25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Actually it is better for security.

Proof please? Whenever I visit a WebGL demo inside Linux w/ NVidia drivers, if there are any complicated shaders, my system hard-freezes, forcing me to reboot. Until the X developers fix Xorg's security model (like that will happen), and until NVidia fixes their Linux drivers (like that will happen), WebGL will always be one massive gaping security and stability problem for me as a Linux user.

So, you are saying the same thing that I am :D
Post reply on HN