Live data from Hacker News

Apple Maps vs. Google Maps

forbes.com

41–50 of 247 posts

Re: Apple Maps vs. Google Maps

#41
post #27

What a tight rope this author has to walk. You want commute suggestions but you don’t want google to know where you live or work? I’ll bat for google on this one, the value I get from Gmaps vs the value they get from my data seems like a fair exchange. Also PSA, if you use Bluetooth with your car, your city transport department is tracking you. Best of luck opting out of that or even finding who to contact.

> Also PSA, if you use Bluetooth with your car, your city transport department is tracking you. Best of luck opting out of that or even finding who to contact. Can you say more about this? I've never heard of it.

Houston does it. They have bluetooth trackers on all the highways. They use it for determining congestion based on how often you can ping the same address. Keeps pinging? Gridlock. Pings once, traffic moving.

Re: Apple Maps vs. Google Maps

#42
post #26

Earlier quoted context omitted.

But the point is that Apple Maps also has the commute suggestions without the privacy cost

As long as you're using a cellular network, you're trackable, no? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VFns39RXPrU

Maybe, I don’t know, but it doesn’t mean we should just give up on protecting our data everywhere else.

A GPS or Bluetooth signal would be far more precise as a mass surveillance tool, so let’s not give that up

Re: Apple Maps vs. Google Maps

#44

We were already using Apple Maps pre-iOS15 because its turn-by-turn directions were far superior. With Google Maps, we were often surprised by the directions: it would be like keep left... keep left...TURN AROUND NOW. Apple Maps often shows the next two directions, and more clearly dictates what we should do next. ... with iOS15, Apple maps are just gorgeous, and I've completely deleted Google maps (I now have no dep…

It's been years and Google maps still recommends an illegal/suicidal/likely impossible u-turn near my parent's place in NYC. Might be time to switch to Apple Maps for driving directions.

Re: Apple Maps vs. Google Maps

#45
post #18

Google maps >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> apple maps here in Europe especially for medium sized cities (in big cities apple works fine but still a lot worse then google). For me it seems like fair exchange to give some data, for free and very good service that have no real competition :)

Yeah, the data on Apple Maps is just not good enough here. The opening hours are frequently just wrong and can’t be trusted.

Part of the reason for that is they use Yelp as a data source which is pretty much non-existent here. If I look at a popular local restaurant on Apple Maps (one which has thousands of reviews on both Google and TripAdvisor) then the opening hours are just wrong and seemingly pulled from Yelp where the restaurant is unclaimed and has just 9 reviews, all in English rather than the native language.

Re: Apple Maps vs. Google Maps

#46

We were already using Apple Maps pre-iOS15 because its turn-by-turn directions were far superior. With Google Maps, we were often surprised by the directions: it would be like keep left... keep left...TURN AROUND NOW. Apple Maps often shows the next two directions, and more clearly dictates what we should do next. ... with iOS15, Apple maps are just gorgeous, and I've completely deleted Google maps (I now have no dep…

> Google has sat on its hands the last couple years with Google Maps: it has hardly improved at all, and outside of their move to jack up prices for API users, I haven't heard of any real changes.

It's a pretty mature product, so you'd expect the pace of signjificant change to be much slower. And large, noticeable change (like a redesign) is a poor metric, as it often feels like a PM getting their wings at the expense of user experience, including muscle memory in an app as useful as Maps.

Despite these caveats, I can think of a new feature off the top of my head: a heatmap of all photos I've ever taken appearing on Google maps. I just moved to New York and it's been both useful and delightful to rediscover where I've been from a new perspective, driven by the serendipitous photos I took over the last decade of sporadic visits.

Yet another new feature I just remembered is Live View compass calibration. Anybody who lives in a big city can relate to how irritating compass quality is around large buildings. The ability to calibrate my compass in two seconds via camera recognition of the street scene is a huge quality of life improvement.

Im usually hesitant to disagree with other people's opinions, but it really sounds like you either have no familiarity with Google Maps or are stuck in a 2010 Apple vs Google fanboy-war view of the world. The reason Maps is so wildly popular is because it consistently pushes out user experience both improvements that are straightforwardly (if incrementally) useful and occasional larger "cool" (and also useful) features. To get as wildly wrong an interpretation as yours (of Maps as somehow stagnant) reeks of willful ignorance.

Re: Apple Maps vs. Google Maps

#47

I’m curious - does anyone reading this agree with the notion that Apple maps is becoming comparable to Google maps? I haven’t given it a fair shot in almost a decade I guess, and it was almost unusable then. Does anyone here use it as a daily driver? What are the strong and weak points?

Depends on your location. Apple maps is almost unusable here in Russia.

Then again - even Google Maps have hard time competing with Yandex and 2Gis

Re: Apple Maps vs. Google Maps

#48

I've tried to use Apple Maps but it just straight up cant find normal places that have existed for ages. I don't know what the deal is.

Outside of niche cases, every user I've ever talked to, here or in-person, has only ever used brand loyalty as their reason for using it. With a userbase like that, why bother making a good service, particularly when you don't have the institutional competency to do so?

Re: Apple Maps vs. Google Maps

#49
post #12

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I use Apple Maps as my primary GPS in my vehicle. I have spent the last few years on the road driving across North America and Google Maps repeatedly made objectively incorrect decisions in rural areas that would take me in quasi-off road situations. After I got frustrated being led astray I started comparing routes on both and found that it seems to be a logic issue for Google Maps, where it would save 5 km of dista…

I think that's probably because Apple doesn't even know that backroads existed so Apple Maps couldn't optimize the route. If Apple Maps had knew those backroards, they would probably output the same routes! :-D

I thought that might be the case but when I zoom in I can see the back roads in Apple Maps. I am pretty sure it is a algorithm issue. Google doesn’t have enough data about how slow those back roads are and maybe relies on that data more than Apple does.

Re: Apple Maps vs. Google Maps

#50
post #29

I opened up my settings to allow Google maps to have access to my location all the time, even when not using the app. I have found the Timeline feature in Google maps to be a huge game changer in terms of 'where ive been' and 'what Ive done'. I can look back months, see exactly what routes I went down, where I was at a given time. It will even match pictures with the locations. Especially for journaling vacations (so…

> I can look back months, see exactly what routes I went down, where I was at a given time.

So can Google.

I'd love to have these features but the price is just too high. The price would be too high even if I trusted Google (which I don't), because every company that collects personal information will be hacked because no company is properly incentivised to protect users' data.

Post reply on HN