Live data from Hacker News

Oops: Microsoft accidentally reveals secret social project

venturebeat.com

41–50 of 69 posts

Re: Oops: Microsoft accidentally reveals secret social project

#41
post #38

Earlier quoted context omitted.

very true...its all Mktng gimmick....this strategy offers free publicity. See what happend to iphone4...huge hit after " Being left at a bar Accidently :D "

[deleted]

I didn't bother to downvote, but do you honestly think that the Gizmodo iPhone 4 incident was a carefully orchestrated PR stunt? Seriously?

Re: Oops: Microsoft accidentally reveals secret social project

#42
post #30

I'm not too familiar with ASP.Net, but if you view source on socl.com that is some jacked-up output.

I thought the same, I use .net all the time and a majority of it is generated by .net itself but the rest looks like its been copied and pasted from word or something with the extra stuff in there.

It makes me wonder if this really was an internal project as would they let people loose on such a big project that are copying and pasting stuff from word?

Or again, is this part of the conspiracy??

Microsoft's lack of innovation in general recently upsets me, I used to be a massive Microsoft fan but the more Apple do recently the more I want to follow them instead. I hope they do pull something out of the bag

Re: Oops: Microsoft accidentally reveals secret social project

#43

looking at the screenshot, and actually reading the content of the small tiles, this does not look like G+/facebook/twitter, but more like a wikia/knol/stack*/quora. I mean, there isn't anything in this single screenshot suggesting this as a new "generalistic" social network , so why are so many comments to this submission trying to frame it so?

Why? Most likely laziness and convenience. It gives people something to rant about. Apparently HN has a hard time conducting a respectable discussion about Microsoft.

Re: Oops: Microsoft accidentally reveals secret social project

#44
post #3

I have trouble believing all these "accidental leakages" are actually accidents. The new trendy marketing gimmick?

Well it does provide them with a sort of "market viability" test. Leak some information to see how the world reacts, and then decide if it's worth proceeding or not (obviously not, in this case).

They didn't do a great job at analyzing the feedback towards the courier project then.

Re: Oops: Microsoft accidentally reveals secret social project

#45

looking at the screenshot, and actually reading the content of the small tiles, this does not look like G+/facebook/twitter, but more like a wikia/knol/stack*/quora. I mean, there isn't anything in this single screenshot suggesting this as a new "generalistic" social network , so why are so many comments to this submission trying to frame it so?

Hmm everyone's all riled up about a product they know nothing about. And I thought logic was central to a computer science degree. Guess I was wrong.

Re: Oops: Microsoft accidentally reveals secret social project

#46

looking at the screenshot, and actually reading the content of the small tiles, this does not look like G+/facebook/twitter, but more like a wikia/knol/stack*/quora. I mean, there isn't anything in this single screenshot suggesting this as a new "generalistic" social network , so why are so many comments to this submission trying to frame it so?

Hmm everyone's all riled up about a product they know nothing about. And I thought logic was central to a computer science degree. Guess I was wrong.

The vast majority of HN readers do not have CS degrees. In fact a very large portion of HN readers do not even identify themselves as programmers or "hackers." That said, I don't believe people with CS degrees are particularly better commenters than people without them. Microsoft is just a touchy subject for many geeks. Much like Facebook and the meme that our privacy is in danger, or advertising -- it generates nerd rage.

Re: Oops: Microsoft accidentally reveals secret social project

#47
post #6

I wonder if socl.com was available or bought for $s!!! Mostly bought, because thats too cliche a name to be left lurking.

Almost every pronounceable 4 character domain was taken by 2006 or so. This happens to be similar to 'SoCal', as well. Take a guess.

Re: Oops: Microsoft accidentally reveals secret social project

#48

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Hmm everyone's all riled up about a product they know nothing about. And I thought logic was central to a computer science degree. Guess I was wrong.

The vast majority of HN readers do not have CS degrees. In fact a very large portion of HN readers do not even identify themselves as programmers or "hackers." That said, I don't believe people with CS degrees are particularly better commenters than people without them. Microsoft is just a touchy subject for many geeks. Much like Facebook and the meme that our privacy is in danger, or advertising -- it generates nerd…

In the 21st century, it is hip to claim you're being oppressed. That said, nerd-rage makes for very interesting material. Basically everyone concludes everything and the entire tech crowd explores the search space of the future of an org and the final conclusion is "time will tell".

[Disclaimer : MS intern. Opinions are mine]

Re: Oops: Microsoft accidentally reveals secret social project

#49

Last month Microsoft likely acquired Social.com for $2.6 million[1], then this domain Socl.com through the same company. Suddenly this domain has a social site on it (still in Google Cache) and they claim it's just a MSR project? Not a chance. 1: http://fusible.com/2011/07/rumor-microsoft-to-launch-its-own...

having the header domain like social won't do anything for them. They've got live.com, and look how little they've been able to do with that.

at least live.com was a distinct brand. Having the domain social.com is like inventing a new vacuum cleaner and calling it "Vacuum".
Post reply on HN