Live data from Hacker News

Calibre – E-Book Management

calibre-ebook.com

41–50 of 175 posts

Re: Calibre – E-Book Management

#41
post #37

Kovid only makes $1,800/m from/for development.[0] More people should support him; Calibre has been extremely high quality for years. https://www.patreon.com/kovidgoyal

Is he the sole creator? That is a sadly small sum for this work.

I think there are other contributors, but he rubs lots of people the wrong way, so probably not as many as there could be.

Re: Calibre – E-Book Management

#42

Calibre is great. There’s a real lack of good quality ebook software and Calibre is an essential do-everything toolkit. The interface, however, is like some incredible piece of outsider art, gloriously free of best practice, convention or accepted wisdom. As a UX designer it gave me some trouble at first, but now I’ve genuinely come to appreciate it. There’s no way the interface could be ‘improved’ by conventional st…

I agree the UI is confusing. However, I'm glad Calibre exists, solves my needs, and is so versatile. And in the end, I decided the confusing UI didn't matter all that much. I'd rather they* spent their efforts in improving stability and features rather than making a fancy intuitive UI -- assuming of course you can't have both. If you can have both, all the better!

*I'm never sure if Calibre is a one-person effort. If it is, more kudos to the author.

Re: Calibre – E-Book Management

#43

The one thing I really don't like about Calibre is how it will copy all of my ebooks into its own file organization. There is probably a way to disable this, but that is the default. Kind of irritating when you have Calibre in a cloud-storage folder and your books are also in the cloud storage, and it uses up your space with duplicates.

I was surprised by this on my first use too. I just decided to give up and store my ebooks in the format that it wants, rather than just the media/books folder I already had.

Re: Calibre – E-Book Management

#44

Calibre is great. There’s a real lack of good quality ebook software and Calibre is an essential do-everything toolkit. The interface, however, is like some incredible piece of outsider art, gloriously free of best practice, convention or accepted wisdom. As a UX designer it gave me some trouble at first, but now I’ve genuinely come to appreciate it. There’s no way the interface could be ‘improved’ by conventional st…

This is how I feel about the Libby app for iPhone. What is it with book apps? https://twitter.com/bendansby/status/1334717731925417986?s=2...

I'm genuinely curious to hear any specific changes you might make. I'm a librarian and I can say that Libby was a huge improvement in usability over the Overdrive app and we spend much less time on basic user support now. There are weird quirks for me as well, but I'm always hard pressed to say exactly what I would change.

Re: Calibre – E-Book Management

#45

Calibre is one of those rare examples of software where the kitchen-sink approach is absolutely warranted. It's a one-stop shop for pretty much everything related to e-book management, conversion, or creation. I spend most of my time in Calibre just managing my library or converting ebooks between formats (particularly if I'm pulling ebooks off my Kindle or Kobo to strip their DRM). When I want to test whether the co…

>one of those rare examples of software where the kitchen-sink approach is absolutely warranted

I actually like this approach in general and I often wonder why there's so much animosity towards it. There's something about platform-like software like Calibre, or Emacs or WeChat where it becomes more than the sum of its parts that you just don't get with just a collection of disjointed, individual tools.

Re: Calibre – E-Book Management

#47

Calibre is great, but if you just want to throw a directory at an ebook server and be done, Ubooquity is GREAT! https://vaemendis.net/ubooquity/

I prefer calibre-web[1] and it is under active development. [1]: https://github.com/janeczku/calibre-web

Seconding calibre-web; I rarely interact with calibre itself anymore since calibre-web handles the bulk of the tasks I’m trying to accomplish.

Re: Calibre – E-Book Management

#48

Calibre is great. There’s a real lack of good quality ebook software and Calibre is an essential do-everything toolkit. The interface, however, is like some incredible piece of outsider art, gloriously free of best practice, convention or accepted wisdom. As a UX designer it gave me some trouble at first, but now I’ve genuinely come to appreciate it. There’s no way the interface could be ‘improved’ by conventional st…

Calibre's UI is an artifact from a superior and more civilized time, IMHO

Extremely functional and just a little bit incomprehensible. Compared to modern UI/UX which just slaps me with how stupid it thinks I am

Re: Calibre – E-Book Management

#49

Calibre just works and is great, but the user interface needs some work to modernize how it looks and to be less confusing in general. I'd love a fork that follows the Gnome Human Interface guidelines.

I disagree and I hope no effort is wasted on this. Calibre is great and any confusion is solved by googling.

If and only if the author(s) feel they have time and energy to spend on this, then that's ok. But no forks and no wasted energy, please!

I'd rather they spent time solving bugs and improving/adding features.

Re: Calibre – E-Book Management

#50
post #27

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> the user interface needs some work to modernize No, it doesn't. Eventually people learn to use it, and everyone is happy that way.

I don’t know. I’ve bounced off it multiple times and just given up.

What do you use instead of Calibre? I haven't found a similar tool that is as useful, is free, runs on Linux, etc.

I find Calibre is not a tool to "enjoy" spending time on, but simply a tool to solve something specific so that I can then spend time on my Kindle.

There are other tools where I want to enjoy the time I spend using them (say, text editors, paint programs, IDEs) but Calibre is not one of them.

Post reply on HN