Live data from Hacker News

HSBC bans customers from buying Bitcoin-backer MicroStrategy shares

reuters.com

41–50 of 103 posts

Re: HSBC bans customers from buying Bitcoin-backer MicroStrategy shares

#41
post #37

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Tesla has a market cap of 673.80B at the moment. Their BTC holdings are barely a rounding error.

Which is a problem in itself. Tesla with a 2% market share in the US, is valued more than Toyota, Volkswagen, Daimler, General Motors, and BMW combined (40% of the domestic market). Toyota makes about $2,500 profit for every car sold. Tesla would need to make $50,000 per unit sold on average, or basically 100% profit on a Model 3, to justify the market cap.

Personally, I'm with you, I just don't see how Tesla's valuation is justified. Their cars have QC issues and they have very formidable competitors. If I had to buy a car, I'd pick the Porsche Taycan over any Tesla any time of the day (except maybe the Roadster, but it's not out yet).

That said, I have a few friends who bought it's shares and their rationale is that it's a "clean energy play", far bigger than cars and that their brand is going to be as valuable as Apple. Only time will tell I guess, everyone can put their money where their mouth is and shorting Tesla has been a pretty bad proposition so far.

Re: HSBC bans customers from buying Bitcoin-backer MicroStrategy shares

#42
post #40

> “HSBC has no appetite for direct exposure to virtual currencies and limited appetite to facilitate products or securities that derive their value from VCs (virtual currencies),” HSBC said in a statement. But you wouldn't be? This is a product literally called "InvestDirect" where private individuals are buying stocks and assuming all the risk. If you don't want to offer margin on virtual currency products, more pow…

They already have a version of Net Neutrality for brokers: reg NMS. HSBC are well within their rights to refuse to accept bad orders. HSBC are exposed to specific regulatory risk not shared by US banks. Having a ton of customers go bust because a regulatory change nuked some meme stocks seems undesirable to me. If you don't like it you can always find another broker.

[deleted]

Re: HSBC bans customers from buying Bitcoin-backer MicroStrategy shares

#43
post #6

>The bank said its policy towards cryptocurrencies had been in place since 2018 and is kept under review. It could not immediately say which countries the ban applied to. My guess is that it's just some middle manager blindly following directives from 2018 that haven't been updated. I can't think of any other reason why they'd ban it when everyone else is moving in the opposite direction.

They're one of the most bureaucratic and inefficiently ran banks in existence, an absolute nightmare to deal with on every level. Not sure how they're still around, I wish they had been fined into oblivion after they were caught money laundering for narco traffickers.

Re: HSBC bans customers from buying Bitcoin-backer MicroStrategy shares

#44

Next up, they'll have to ban Tesla, Square, Coinbase, Riot, etc. Where will they draw the line? Pretty much the whole market has exposure to Bitcoin through SP500->Tesla at this point.

Tesla has a market cap of 673.80B at the moment. Their BTC holdings are barely a rounding error.

Sure, compared to their market cap, it's small. But it's 1.5B$, a very significant percentage of the cash they have on hand.

Re: HSBC bans customers from buying Bitcoin-backer MicroStrategy shares

#45

> “HSBC has no appetite for direct exposure to virtual currencies and limited appetite to facilitate products or securities that derive their value from VCs (virtual currencies),” HSBC said in a statement. But you wouldn't be? This is a product literally called "InvestDirect" where private individuals are buying stocks and assuming all the risk. If you don't want to offer margin on virtual currency products, more pow…

Knowing absolutely nothing about this particular situation I’d be willing to bet this decision is a lingering side effect of HSBC’s most recent (and seemingly perpetual) AML issues. I suspect they’re trying to appear squeaky clean and an action like this is quick, easy to implement operationally, and looks good to regulators who are uneasy about cryptocurrency’s reputation for facilitating criminal activity online.

I don't see how kyc/aml applies to this particular stock over every single other ticker they will happily sell you? There's no difference, they aren't selling cryptocurrency here.

Re: HSBC bans customers from buying Bitcoin-backer MicroStrategy shares

#46
post #40

> “HSBC has no appetite for direct exposure to virtual currencies and limited appetite to facilitate products or securities that derive their value from VCs (virtual currencies),” HSBC said in a statement. But you wouldn't be? This is a product literally called "InvestDirect" where private individuals are buying stocks and assuming all the risk. If you don't want to offer margin on virtual currency products, more pow…

They already have a version of Net Neutrality for brokers: reg NMS. HSBC are well within their rights to refuse to accept bad orders. HSBC are exposed to specific regulatory risk not shared by US banks. Having a ton of customers go bust because a regulatory change nuked some meme stocks seems undesirable to me. If you don't like it you can always find another broker.

[deleted]

Re: HSBC bans customers from buying Bitcoin-backer MicroStrategy shares

#47
post #6

>The bank said its policy towards cryptocurrencies had been in place since 2018 and is kept under review. It could not immediately say which countries the ban applied to. My guess is that it's just some middle manager blindly following directives from 2018 that haven't been updated. I can't think of any other reason why they'd ban it when everyone else is moving in the opposite direction.

They're one of the most bureaucratic and inefficiently ran banks in existence, an absolute nightmare to deal with on every level. Not sure how they're still around, I wish they had been fined into oblivion after they were caught money laundering for narco traffickers.

Tried to open a bank account with them for a promo. So. Much. Paper.

And I still didn't manage to open my bank account despite filling stuff out online and visiting a branch.

Re: HSBC bans customers from buying Bitcoin-backer MicroStrategy shares

#49
post #10

Is there a good up-to-date resource for understanding the current premium that MSTR has over its BTC holdings? The article says: "MicroStrategy said last week it owns around 91,579 bitcoins. Its holdings, worth around $5.5 billion according to a Reuters calculation, are equal to around 80% of its $6.8 billion market capitalisation." Naively, this would imply a fairly low premium. But among other things, this doesn't…

https://twitter.com/SBF_Alameda/status/1380284657820782595

Re: HSBC bans customers from buying Bitcoin-backer MicroStrategy shares

#50
post #13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not impossible, but IMO highly unlikely: stocks, especially smaller ones can be way more volatile than any currency with over 1T market value. And you can still buy those on margin.

>you can still buy those on margin That is absolutely not the case in a categorical sense. Brokers can and do apply different margin requirements on a stock by stock or customer by customer basis. There's nothing out of the ordinary about a security not being marginable or having increased requirements due to risk assessment. For example, here is a list of stocks at one broker with particular margin requirements, and…

Note, the page you linked to requires login.
Post reply on HN