Live data from Hacker News

Watchy: Hackable $50 Smartwatch

spectrum.ieee.org

41–50 of 163 posts

Re: Watchy: Hackable $50 Smartwatch

#42

Maybe I'm a curmudgeon, but I have subzero interest in smartwatches, even hackable or open source models. I want my watch to tell me the time, and I want it to do so 10, 20, and 30 years from now without having to fiddle with software. I love Linux. I cut my teeth on it in high school after one too many viruses on Windows XP made me bite the bullet and try debian. I love my Raspberry Pi. It went from retro-gaming con…

I feel the same about my Casio Tough Solar. I've had it around 6 years and it feels like it'll never get old. For the last year or so I've been wearing a Pebble Time Steel and while I appreciate the extra features I know that one day it will stop working, and I'm sure my Casio will be there waiting.

About the Pebble -- I am definitely a fan, and haven't yet seen another smartwatch with its particular appeal. After playing around with a lot of watchfaces I ended up almost always sticking with an analog face which I'm finding helps me visualize the passage of time a lot better than a digital readout.

Re: Watchy: Hackable $50 Smartwatch

#43
post #24

Funny the picture shows a subway exit. One of the apps I want from a smart watch is a compass. I work(d) in NYC and I’m always turned around when I exit the subway at an unfamiliar stop.

I found compasses don't work well in NYC either. My phone's compass is always wrong in NYC. I really wish NYC would paint or engrave a N/S/E/W indicator on the sidewalk at every subway exit.

How strange. Why is that? They use a magnetometer.

Re: Watchy: Hackable $50 Smartwatch

#44

Maybe I'm a curmudgeon, but I have subzero interest in smartwatches, even hackable or open source models. I want my watch to tell me the time, and I want it to do so 10, 20, and 30 years from now without having to fiddle with software. I love Linux. I cut my teeth on it in high school after one too many viruses on Windows XP made me bite the bullet and try debian. I love my Raspberry Pi. It went from retro-gaming con…

> Apple Watch, Android Wear, Pebble, and now Watchy... All these devices will be e-waste in 30 years (most in less than 10).

It is interesting, given the amount of environmental concerns people have over cow flatulates, plastic bags, straws, etc... that nobody seems concerned about these obviously short-lifetime hunks of non-biodegradable/non-recyclable plastics, rubber, silicone, rare earth metals, and worse.

All the environmentalists that scream at others for putting a can in the wrong bin, yet buy a new Apple Watch every release cycle...

Re: Watchy: Hackable $50 Smartwatch

#45

Maybe I'm a curmudgeon, but I have subzero interest in smartwatches, even hackable or open source models. I want my watch to tell me the time, and I want it to do so 10, 20, and 30 years from now without having to fiddle with software. I love Linux. I cut my teeth on it in high school after one too many viruses on Windows XP made me bite the bullet and try debian. I love my Raspberry Pi. It went from retro-gaming con…

The problem starts with calling a wrist-worn computer a "watch" of any kind. What parent wants is a "watch", a wrist-worn device whose primary or even sole purpose is to tell time. The Apple product I have on my wrist right now is not a "watch", though it will tell you the time. But that's like saying my car is a clock because time is displayed on the dashboard. And if all it did was tell the time, I wouldn't wear it as I don't need to know the time badly enough to wear a single-purpose device all of the time. Unfortunately, it looks like we're stuck with "smartwatch".

If we could get the terminology straightened out, maybe every discussion on the topic of smartwatches need not require the presence of "that guy" telling us how in addition to not owning a TV, they just need a mechanical time-keeping device they can pass to their kids who are just going to sell it at the estate sale.

Re: Watchy: Hackable $50 Smartwatch

#46

Cool device. A bit short on the sensors, but I understand why for a first iteration. Hope it's successful enough that later revisions will include a few things I'm keen on: * Pulse ox * Continuous heartrate * GPS+Compass But it's a cool device anyway.

The pulse ox is pretty cool to have around given that lots of people develop asymptomatic covid and are hospitalized much later with very low o2 sat.

Re: Watchy: Hackable $50 Smartwatch

#47

Maybe I'm a curmudgeon, but I have subzero interest in smartwatches, even hackable or open source models. I want my watch to tell me the time, and I want it to do so 10, 20, and 30 years from now without having to fiddle with software. I love Linux. I cut my teeth on it in high school after one too many viruses on Windows XP made me bite the bullet and try debian. I love my Raspberry Pi. It went from retro-gaming con…

Mechanical watches need to be serviced every few years, though.

Re: Watchy: Hackable $50 Smartwatch

#49
post #44

Maybe I'm a curmudgeon, but I have subzero interest in smartwatches, even hackable or open source models. I want my watch to tell me the time, and I want it to do so 10, 20, and 30 years from now without having to fiddle with software. I love Linux. I cut my teeth on it in high school after one too many viruses on Windows XP made me bite the bullet and try debian. I love my Raspberry Pi. It went from retro-gaming con…

> Apple Watch, Android Wear, Pebble, and now Watchy... All these devices will be e-waste in 30 years (most in less than 10). It is interesting, given the amount of environmental concerns people have over cow flatulates, plastic bags, straws, etc... that nobody seems concerned about these obviously short-lifetime hunks of non-biodegradable/non-recyclable plastics, rubber, silicone, rare earth metals, and worse. All th…

Yeah, I recently realized this and am now on a much more streamlined technology (and most products) diet. It definitely sucks because I feel like I'm always missing out on stuff, but it no longer feels right.

Re: Watchy: Hackable $50 Smartwatch

#50

Maybe I'm a curmudgeon, but I have subzero interest in smartwatches, even hackable or open source models. I want my watch to tell me the time, and I want it to do so 10, 20, and 30 years from now without having to fiddle with software. I love Linux. I cut my teeth on it in high school after one too many viruses on Windows XP made me bite the bullet and try debian. I love my Raspberry Pi. It went from retro-gaming con…

>> My Seiko automatic

Bah, a real curmudgeon would have said a £10 Casio quartz :-)

I flick back and forth on this. The features i actually use on my Apple Watch:

    1. it extends phone battery life[1]
    2. I'm UK based but i work with colleagues across APAC & NA - in 3 of the corners of the "infograph" watch face i have NYC, Mumbai & HK times, it shows the city, the 24hr time & handily the offset - i use this all the time because outlook is poor for this simple use case
    3. The 4th corner has a timer - i use it for everything from "the dog's out the back garden, i should remember to let her back in, in 5 mins" to brewing a cuppa to reminding me to do something - the UI here is really good, i'm a mixture of "hey siri, set a timer for 25 minutes" vs. just tapping one of the pre-set timers
    4. Up next calendar entry - coupled with calendar notifications, the only notifications i still use today
    5. Day date complication
    6. Temperature - but it's not the current temp i find useful, it's the daily range display - every night "can i let the cat stay out overnight or will it get too cold?"
    7. it's super convenient for driving directions in a rental car when abroad, not so much in my own car though
    8. Music / audiobook / podcast volume & skipping
    9. The vo2 max readout has caused me to change exercise habits and the HRV thing has caused me to pay more attention to my sleep schedule - he says at 11:26pm
   10. But my favourite is Apple Pay, personal account, joint account, corporate card & flight tickets back when we used to do that, super handy
Features i don't use but pretend i do:

    1. Every other thing on there - from sleep trackers to camera viewfinder remote view thingy (cool, but useless)
A £19 "Casio Royale" would do most of the essentials though.

[1] in 2017 when i got my 2nd gen apple watch, my iPhone 7 would be almost dead when i got home from work. When i started using the apple watch, my phone battery would have ~20% left when i got home. I was no longer wakening the phone screen to deal with notifications or fiddling with podcast / music controls. Shortly after that i disabled all notifications but that's another story.

Post reply on HN