Live data from Hacker News

Radio users reminded not to use radios in crimes

arrl.org

41–50 of 312 posts

Re: Radio users reminded not to use radios in crimes

#41
>WARNING: AMATEUR AND PERSONAL RADIO SERVICES LICENSEES AND OPERATORS MAY NOT USE RADIO EQUIPMENT TO COMMIT OR FACILITATE CRIMINAL ACTS

But if one licenses spectrum, then it is not an offense, in its own right, to facilitate criminal acts? (Though the acts themselves of course still are...)

Re: Radio users reminded not to use radios in crimes

#42
post #27

> The Bureau has become aware of discussions on social media platforms suggesting that certain radio services regulated by the Commission may be an alternative to social media platforms for groups to communicate and coordinate future activities. “Stop discussing plans for a revolution on amateur radio bands like if we aren’t listening to them, we are, stop believing everything they say on Facebook. I mean, we do enco…

"Go commit crimes elsewhere," is such a /r/WhitePeopleTwitter answer.

How about you stop committing High Crimes instead? It's almost as if there are sympathizers/collaborators participating in creating those statements.

Re: Radio users reminded not to use radios in crimes

#46

tl;dr : How to turn a local or state crime into a federal one. It isn't particularly shocking that this is a statute. I wonder if ham radio was used in the capitol riot.

Even if amateur radio bands weren't, the announcement also includes FRS and GMRS which are very common and almost certainly used in the attack on the Capitol

Re: Radio users reminded not to use radios in crimes

#47

>WARNING: AMATEUR AND PERSONAL RADIO SERVICES LICENSEES AND OPERATORS MAY NOT USE RADIO EQUIPMENT TO COMMIT OR FACILITATE CRIMINAL ACTS But if one licenses spectrum, then it is not an offense, in its own right, to facilitate criminal acts? (Though the acts themselves of course still are...)

This reminds me of those "trespassing prohibited" signs.

Yes, that's why we call it "trespassing" instead of "taking a shortcut".

Re: Radio users reminded not to use radios in crimes

#48
post #15

I can already hear the cries of censorship. "What do you mean crimes aren't protected speech?"

I think more interesting is how to decide in advance if a particular use is use in crime. Before a judge will decide there is a crime.

I think it's a bit like felony murder. Nobody wants you committing felonies, but, if you do commit a felony, you're incentivized to avoid causing potentially deadly situations. (setting aside the actual efficacy of such incentives, that's just how the law currently is)

To put it another way, you probably won't be charged just for selling drugs over a radio frequency. You'll be charged for the regular crime of selling drugs and an additional charge of using radio to commit that crime.

Re: Radio users reminded not to use radios in crimes

#49

Baofeng's, Baofengs everywhere. Of all the images I have seen of the attempted coup, I have only seen baofeng radios. These are very cheap ($20'ish) radios that work very poorly (they splatter all over the bands) even when equipped with decent antennas. They barely work when equipped with the stock rubber-duck antennas. It's easy to be a snob about the type of radios that they are using, but that's not even the point…

As a pinch of salt...

If you can get a baofeng to last out of the box longer than a week, and manage to DX a handheld or a repeater further than a parking space away, you should at least win a QRP award and a discount on your technicians test before you get sent to the klink.

Re: Radio users reminded not to use radios in crimes

#50

Baofeng's, Baofengs everywhere. Of all the images I have seen of the attempted coup, I have only seen baofeng radios. These are very cheap ($20'ish) radios that work very poorly (they splatter all over the bands) even when equipped with decent antennas. They barely work when equipped with the stock rubber-duck antennas. It's easy to be a snob about the type of radios that they are using, but that's not even the point…

Baofeng's website has a banner suggesting a surge in demand.

> Due to overwhelming demand, we are not able to process any additional orders at this time

https://baofengtech.com/

Post reply on HN