Live data from Hacker News

I Made a Self-Quoting Tweet

oisinmoran.com

41–50 of 145 posts

Re: I Made a Self-Quoting Tweet

#41
post #29
post #24

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That's a common Twitter bug, just try again a few times.

Alternatively, replace twitter.com in the URL with nitter.net. It points to an alternative client.

sure, if you want to give your twitter credentials to some random company based in the caribbean.

Re: I Made a Self-Quoting Tweet

#42
post #28
post #23

Earlier quoted context omitted.

For traversing a DAG you probably still would to avoid exploring an exponential number of paths (consider a chain of diamonds [1]). 1: https://www.researchgate.net/figure/A-diamond-shaped-DAG_fig...

But a diamond cannot occur in a Twitter-reply graph, right? It would require a Tweet to be able to reply to more than one tweet.

It can because the assumption is that we are crawling embedded links as well as native parents.

Re: I Made a Self-Quoting Tweet

#43

Interesting, I wondered if the same can be done on hn. Likely easier since the IDs appear to be sequential. But one can simply edit their post to point to the URL too if they wanted, so it defeats the fun of the exercise.

On a related note, from 2012: “Show HN: This up votes itself” https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3742902

Unfortunately, I wasn't allowed to keep the karma :(

Re: I Made a Self-Quoting Tweet

#44

It seems like Twitter knows not to show the quoted tweet in this case, but I wonder if it would show it if it were a 2-cycle.

At first I thought a two-cycle would be incredibly hard. But I suppose you really only have to adjust the timestamp to forward-guess the next ID. You would know the ID of the first one. It would definitely help narrow down the algorithm used for preventing the recursion.

Re: I Made a Self-Quoting Tweet

#46

It seems like Twitter knows not to show the quoted tweet in this case, but I wonder if it would show it if it were a 2-cycle.

Higher up someone posted an example of that and it seems like no: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25259046

Only one of the two shows, as expected it only shows if the ID of the quoted tweet is smaller than that of the tweet itself.

This also means that in general, you can't quote a non-existing future tweet hoping it'll be something cool in the future. Well you can but the preview won't work.

Re: I Made a Self-Quoting Tweet

#47
post #20
post #16

A bit annoying that Twitter's quote tweet UI sort of breaks. Maybe two mutually recursive tweets would show up better :)

They also break https://twitter.com/mauritscorneIis/status/12668346972560875...

Specifically, it seems like it only shows if the ID of the quoted tweet is stricted lower than that of the tweet itself, which basically solves any sort of recursion and acyclic issue, as well as trying to quote non-existing future tweets.

Re: I Made a Self-Quoting Tweet

#48
post #29

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Alternatively, replace twitter.com in the URL with nitter.net. It points to an alternative client.

sure, if you want to give your twitter credentials to some random company based in the caribbean.

What? https://nitter.net/quinetweet/status/1309951041321013248 doesn’t ask for credentials and AFAIK there’s no place to enter them on the whole site, unless you type them into the search bar.

Re: I Made a Self-Quoting Tweet

#49
post #33
post #27

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Or the software just doesn't handle it.

Why the speculation from you and the parent? You can literally click on the Tweet and see that it works fine.

When I click on the tweet, it shows the URL in the text and where the quoted inset should be it instead reads "This Tweet is unavailable."

The parent and grandparent are speculating because it works for them but not for others here.

Post reply on HN