Live data from Hacker News

Mmhmm

mmhmm.app

41–50 of 174 posts

Re: Mmhmm

#41
Installed to tryout it out. I dislike it requires yet another user account just to try it out[1][2].

Overall it is pretty simple to use with a decent UI and worked fine for my quick test of a Signal desktop app video call by selecting the mmhmm virtual camera in Signal.

It did not work in FaceTime as there is no way to change the camera from the built in one (however I was able to change the audio source to mmhmm audio fwiw). Not sure if this is a FaceTime limitation or mmhmm?

For £20 I would probably buy it but £10 a month (or £100 a year)?! No. Sorry.

I fail to see why this type of application needs to be a subscription service and a rather expensive one at that. Unless I am missing something it doesn't rely on a backend service the mmhmm developers would need to maintain and outside of adding new features it isn't likely the OS APIs used to access the camera will change much, if at all, on a desktop OS these days so on going development costs to the core camera functionality already present is likely to be minimal.

A nice product but not worth an indefinite £10 a month to me personally.

[1] Also there does not appear to be a delete account option anywhere on the website. I hate this when forced to sign up just to try the software. I have emailed using the address on their website to request deletion but it should be a clear option on the account management page.

[2] Also accepting an 8 character minimum (requiring upper, lower and special character) password while rejecting a 4 word (27 character) passphrase is laughable.

Re: Mmhmm

#42
post #35

I've used this and it's a great idea, and works well in some contexts. One downside to be aware of is that it routes your slides/screenshare through your webcam video feed. In some apps (e.g. Teams) this can dramatically reduce the quality of the slides, relative to a 'normal' screenshare. There's a setting in Teams to increase video bandwidth, which mitigates this a bit. But the slides will still look less good (at…

I've tested it as well (seeing it on the latest Apple keynote) and have been having quality issues even when sharing slides via share screen, which is what they recommend if there's quality issues. Submitted a ticket around a week ago and haven't heard back yet.

Really excited at the possibility here. Staying tuned...

Re: Mmhmm

#44
post #4

Anyone know how it works? Does it create a virtual camera source that Zoom can source from?

So many basic questions the website could address but seems to prefer generic or unrelated marketing copy for some reason.

There's a good simple product idea hidden somewhere in this website.

You basically have to watch the video to figure out the product.

Re: Mmhmm

#45
I absolutely loved this, and I will show it to my boss in a couple of hours, who I already know will like it more than me.

This is a game changer for online workshops and conferences, if not anything else for the ability to prepare several "shared screens" and switch between them as if switching between presentation slides.

The only feature I was surprised is not included is the ability to "save" the video size and position for each slide, so it automatically appears in the right place, out of the way.

Re: Mmhmm

#46
If the people who develop this app are here, it took me quite a while to figure out that it uses a "virtual camera" to work, and therefore potentially works with most videoconferencing software. That should be front and centre - for a while I wasn't sure whether it was a separate videoconferencing app because the screenshots are just the app, rather than it being used in Zoom or whatever. The only reference is "Funner Zooming", but for some reason that wasn't explicit enough for me without an example Zoom screenshot.

Re: Mmhmm

#47
I tried this during the beta. Unfortunately, as others experienced, the resolution is severely limited in certain applications (I used Zoom). Zoom compresses the stream as if it’s video, when it’s in fact a slide.

I discovered this when I was setting up for a very important presentation and had about 5 minutes to go to a fallback plan. I was pretty upset that there was no warning about this, since they were totally aware of it, and it completely undermined the value of using it in a live presentation.

Later, I had to record a presentation to submit for a conference. I used it there and it worked fine in terms of quality. But even though I had bought a green screen, there were difficulties that resulted in subpar edge detection. I had to change my shirt multiple times to create enough contrast, and I had to use a background image that was ‘busy’ enough to mask the static that was visible.

Maybe things have improved in the last couple months, but I was pretty let down when I tried this out.

Re: Mmhmm

#48
post #41

Installed to tryout it out. I dislike it requires yet another user account just to try it out[1][2]. Overall it is pretty simple to use with a decent UI and worked fine for my quick test of a Signal desktop app video call by selecting the mmhmm virtual camera in Signal. It did not work in FaceTime as there is no way to change the camera from the built in one (however I was able to change the audio source to mmhmm aud…

They have a recording functionality that generates interactive videos (as a person watching, you can still move the presenter around and jump to specific slides and images). So they might offer online hosting for your productions, à la YouTube or SlideShare?

Re: Mmhmm

#49

Is there a open source that will let me replace the backdrop of videos? Something for ffmpeg maybe?

OBS Studio. It's very powerful, classic open source, with a not amazing UI, but, it does everything mmhmm does and a lot more. I use both every day.

I tried OBS studio, but could not figure out how to use it properly. Ended up using Xsplit Vcam instead, which is really good.

I think I managed to remove the background in a really, really crud way with OBS studio. Like using a chroma key (green screen). But Xplit does it with any noisy apartment background.

Post reply on HN