Live data from Hacker News

Significant JavaScript projects from 2006 to 2020

bestofjs.org

41–50 of 60 posts

Re: Significant JavaScript projects from 2006 to 2020

#41

For those that are disappointed at the omissions in the timeline: > Disclaimer > We could have mentioned a lot of other projects: > [lines omitted] > ...but we had to make choices to keep this timeline compact. > The 2 main constraints were: > We wanted 20 projects because we are in 2020 > We wanted at least one project for every year between 2010 and 2020. Reasoning kind of dumb, since this could have been a much mo…

I think Backbone is a really big omission, specially because it credits Angular for the popularity of the SPA and in doing so practically erases Jeremy Ashkenas and his awesome contributions from Javascript history. I would argue you can trace modern JS to Backbone, Underscore and CoffeeScript.

I had the exact same reaction. Sticking Angular in there with no mention of Backbone is revisionist history. Backbone was everywhere. ES6 doesn't coalesce without Coffeescript either. Firebug is another glaring omission. What about npm? Chromium? MDN? ECMA2015? querySelector/modern DOM APIs?

As someone who has been writing javascript for over a decade, I find this list to be really disingenuous. Putting projects like Rome, Snowpack, and Deno alongside jQuery is almost laughable. They certainly have large potential upside, but they have yet to have any significant tangible impact on the Javascript community. I'm all for them and will continue to support their development, but why not mention the projects that had genuine historic impact. Does angular really belong here twice? I'm not sure it belongs even once.

I suppose it shouldn't bug me this much.. it's just a list. But given everything the developers of these projects have given me, I'd like to see them get the credit they deserve.

Re: Significant JavaScript projects from 2006 to 2020

#42
post #39

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah. Im surprised that both of these left out Prototype.js which, to me, seems to be the father of these client-side libs

i'll cop to the fact that its mainly bc i wasnt around for that time so i'm just reconstructing things from how they look to me today

Maybe an old dude like me should make an attempt

Re: Significant JavaScript projects from 2006 to 2020

#44

A low key ad for Rome imo. I thought the title was a metaphor for the JavaScript empire into its current state not the name of a new library. Nonetheless seems worth checking out

I'm not so sure that's a bad thing. I've never heard of it until now and just by looking at the Getting Started guide, I'm kind of excited about it: https://romefrontend.dev/#getting-started

Re: Significant JavaScript projects from 2006 to 2020

#46
The article omits some major influential JS projects over the years that folks have already pointed out (Backbone, Coffeescript, Underscore -- and I'd add Require.js, as a commonplace early AMD loader before ES modules were a thing).

And then it also lists 2 projects that, frankly, I've never heard of (and I try to keep pace) and speaks of them in suspiciously-glowing terms, speculating about them being significant in the future.

Fine, you can't always know today what will have had the biggest impact in 5 years, but the result is that this reads like a really bad "puff piece" ad for those two projects.

It's like when you see blog posts from some SaaS company about "best practices for ", and the first few tips are either obvious or wrong, and the last few tips are "buy our product!"

Re: Significant JavaScript projects from 2006 to 2020

#49
Not a web dev. Don't know much about Javascript itself.

MathJax might be the most significant JS project ever. It enabled something that couldn't really be done before it came along, displaying complicated equations in a readable manner.

Ace deserves at least an honorable mention. I was able to add a full-blown text editor to a CGI app with little effort. I'm pretty sure it's been around longer than VS Code and it's been used in more major projects.

Re: Significant JavaScript projects from 2006 to 2020

#50
post #25

Ugh. Was the author of this article in the field since 2006? From the look of this list, I'd wager not. Almost resembles a cherry pick of Google results. Listing VSCode without listing it's precursor and source of inspiration (Atom) nor the platform which enabled VSCode to be a thing (Electron) is mind-bottling¹. We're going to list Snowpack (new last year) but omit Rollup (hey, Webpack made it and it drives three ot…

It’s automated I think via the GitHub API
Post reply on HN