Live data from Hacker News

Megadesk

tindie.com

41–50 of 141 posts

Re: Megadesk

#41

Hah! I am in the market for a standing desk and am 95% sold on the IKEA Bekant. Just waiting to move to commit to the purchase. I wasn't keen on the crank but I figured I could live with it. This is a nice and fun addition :)

While researching for standing desks to buy, I came across this [1] listing the problems with the Bekant. The stability issue is a design problem and hard to fix.

[1] https://www.btod.com/blog/problems-ikea-bekant-desk/

Re: Megadesk

#43

Hah! I am in the market for a standing desk and am 95% sold on the IKEA Bekant. Just waiting to move to commit to the purchase. I wasn't keen on the crank but I figured I could live with it. This is a nice and fun addition :)

I had the ikea one and this one: https://smile.amazon.com/VIVO-Ergonomic-Adjustable-Controlle... The vivo one has been far better in features and reliability. I had to replace the ikea one because it started only going down and not up.

I have this one with an ikea kitchen counter top and it is an amazing combo, Highly recommend https://smile.amazon.com/gp/product/B073K1JSW7/ref=ppx_yo_dt...

Re: Megadesk

#44
post #2

I just realized that I have a problem, where I think "why would I pay $50 for a PCB that I can design and make myself?" and then conclude "therefore nobody would pay". Maybe I should start selling some of the PCBs I made.

a) You can design and make it; I can't. I have basic electronics knowledge and that is definitely more advanced than anything I'd get done in a reasonable time.

b) Speaking of reasonable time, it'd probably take even you more than $50 in time, material and parts (mostly time) to make this. This doesn't look like the kind of PCB that you'd hand-solder either, bringing us to...

c) Making 1000 of something tends to be cheaper per item than making 1 of something, and I'll gladly take an option that's not only cheaper than anything I could make myself, but also ready to use.

You definitely should share your PCBs by producing them at scale if you're willing to do that.

Re: Megadesk

#45
post #40

This is plainly not safe. A desk with memory needs to require a continuous button press to keep advancing the desk, so that if the operator or someone gets caught in the desk and can’t push the stop button, it stops as soon as pressure is released.

Fall-safe buttons would probably be ideal too - recessed/covered to minimise accidental contact. You don't want to collapse against your desk and have it crush your legs (though the motor/gearbox probably isn't that strong).

Re: Megadesk

#46
post #2

I just realized that I have a problem, where I think "why would I pay $50 for a PCB that I can design and make myself?" and then conclude "therefore nobody would pay". Maybe I should start selling some of the PCBs I made.

a) You can design and make it; I can't. I have basic electronics knowledge and that is definitely more advanced than anything I'd get done in a reasonable time. b) Speaking of reasonable time, it'd probably take even you more than $50 in time, material and parts (mostly time) to make this. This doesn't look like the kind of PCB that you'd hand-solder either, bringing us to... c) Making 1000 of something tends to be c…

Making a PCB is pretty cheap, even making 10 PCBs costs around $15 nowadays. I usually panel my PCBs so I fit 40-100 in a batch, depending on size (and then only use one).

I usually share my designs, the ones I've uploaded have links to the manufacturer where you can order them, though I haven't really done assembly on any, yet. I might, if any design has people interested, though.

Re: Megadesk

#47
post #11
post #2

I just realized that I have a problem, where I think "why would I pay $50 for a PCB that I can design and make myself?" and then conclude "therefore nobody would pay". Maybe I should start selling some of the PCBs I made.

The seller provides all the Gerber files, BOM, etc. https://github.com/gcormier/megadesk But it's pretty clear many are buying the pre-assembled kit. Hand soldering SMD components is pretty tedious.

Low temp solder paste, a laser cut stencil, and a hotplate makes it pretty easy.

Re: Megadesk

#48

Hah! I am in the market for a standing desk and am 95% sold on the IKEA Bekant. Just waiting to move to commit to the purchase. I wasn't keen on the crank but I figured I could live with it. This is a nice and fun addition :)

I had the ikea one and this one: https://smile.amazon.com/VIVO-Ergonomic-Adjustable-Controlle... The vivo one has been far better in features and reliability. I had to replace the ikea one because it started only going down and not up.

I've never owned an IKEA desk, but can vouch for VIVO's frames - I'm typing this comment using a mechanical keyboard on an IKEA Karlby countertop mounted to a set of VIVO V120EB legs and am experiencing minimal wobble (minimal desktop wobble, no monitor wobble thanks to the gas-spring monitor arm I have).

I also have my desktop at ~49" off the ground, including castors and a 1.5" thick countertop, and I've read that no standing desk has 0 wobble at this close to maximum height.

Re: Megadesk

#49
Crazy that this is here, this is the product of a friend of mine!

I will admit, my reaction to the price was that its not cheap either, but i also really did want my ikea desk to have this functionality and its pretty easy to justify given how much use my desk at home gets now. The solution he's made is very solid, never let me down, and was easy enough to install (Although Ikea make it hard by plastic welding the box shut).

Re: Megadesk

#50

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Time is golden, just because I could do something myself doesn't mean spending all that time on it is worth it.

Ah, but I enjoy building.

Personally, there's many things I enjoy but I try to focus on the ones I enjoy most. Which for me is generally things I haven't done before. Spending money rather than time is one means to enable that.
Post reply on HN