Live data from Hacker News

Kiwi Browser - Android Chrome based browser with extensions support

github.com

41–50 of 76 posts

Re: Kiwi Browser - Android Chrome based browser with extensions support

#41
post #21

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That sounds shady. Thank you for the warning. How does one determine that? Also not found on F-droid. Hard pass.

F-Droid has the same potential tampering issue: apps there are signed by the F-Droid key, not the developer’s key. An F-Droid compromise could backdoor every app.

Any history of this?

For anyone: Why don't they cross-sign with their key+dev key?

Re: Kiwi Browser - Android Chrome based browser with extensions support

#42

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Only way to make it suck less https://blog.mozilla.org/futurereleases/2019/06/27/reinventi...

It sucks? I switched from Chrome last year and am nothing but happy. Who decided it sucks?

Single process for all tabs/sites, no sandboxing, for a start.

I personally won't touch Gecko anymore, and I've been a FF advocate since it was called Mozilla, ha

Re: Kiwi Browser - Android Chrome based browser with extensions support

#43

I've been using this specifically for its extension support, and I'm just waiting until Firefox Preview can get extension support fully as I use Firefox on the desktop and I'd like for them to sync. I looked at other browsers like Brave but I just cannot trust them.

Why can’t you trust Brave?

Brave seems well-intentioned but really dodgy to me. In addition to the other issues that have already been raised, they were initially collecting money on people's behalf without their consent or knowledge [0]. The problem has since been resolved but their handling of it at the time put me off them for good.

[0]: https://finance.yahoo.com/news/prominent-youtuber-claims-bra...

Re: Kiwi Browser - Android Chrome based browser with extensions support

#44
post #40

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That sounds shady. Thank you for the warning. How does one determine that? Also not found on F-droid. Hard pass.

Check out Bromite, they have an F-Droid repo that you can add to F-Droid! Not affiliated with Bromite, just cycling accounts, can point toward my last one if anyone's concerned about this acct's greenness.

You got my hopes up but Bromite doesn't support extensions according to their FAQ https://github.com/bromite/bromite/blob/master/FAQ.md

Re: Kiwi Browser - Android Chrome based browser with extensions support

#45

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's gonna be replaced during this year with a complete rewrite. Extension support is coming, but at the moment only uBlock Origin is available.

So to be clear, the existing Firefox on Android which has broad extension support is going to be replaced with a version with less extension support? Why? One of the biggest value adds of Firefox on Android is broad extension support.

I suppose that is why the replacement is called Firefox Preview, for the time being.

Re: Kiwi Browser - Android Chrome based browser with extensions support

#46

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yandex mobile does chrome extensions.

If you trust yandex enough to allow them to possibly gather all your browsing activity, passwords, ... It's like trusting tencent.

Do you have proof for this.?

Re: Kiwi Browser - Android Chrome based browser with extensions support

#47
post #44
post #40

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Check out Bromite, they have an F-Droid repo that you can add to F-Droid! Not affiliated with Bromite, just cycling accounts, can point toward my last one if anyone's concerned about this acct's greenness.

You got my hopes up but Bromite doesn't support extensions according to their FAQ https://github.com/bromite/bromite/blob/master/FAQ.md

My chosen threat model does not allow for significantly less security in exchange for extensions.

Also, they may very well take PRs for extension support (haven't looked through their Issues/roadmap), but, I'm sure it's not on the top of a security-first project's to-do list.

Re: Kiwi Browser - Android Chrome based browser with extensions support

#48

Beware, the binary .apk's have unreleased patches you can't get from compiling yourself.

On their Github page they say > This code is up-to-date and is matching the build on the Play Store. which seems to be in conflict with your statement.

How did they check and verify that?

Re: Kiwi Browser - Android Chrome based browser with extensions support

#49
post #32

A very important project because it is one of the two browsers on Android that support extensions (the other one is Firefox Mobile). I didn't know it was closed source.

It had a GitHub repo (https://github.com/kiwibrowser/android) described as "source code used in Kiwi", but it was just a Chromium codebase thrown there without the actual patches.

Glad to see it's open source now however there is no commit history (thus no individual patches) and it's not possible to see which version of Chromium this was forked from.

Re: Kiwi Browser - Android Chrome based browser with extensions support

#50

Earlier quoted context omitted.

On their Github page they say > This code is up-to-date and is matching the build on the Play Store. which seems to be in conflict with your statement.

How did they check and verify that?

Since there is no commit history I would also like to know which Chromium version this is based on, so that a diff can be made.
Post reply on HN