Live data from Hacker News

WikiHow’s art is made by a network of freelancers, mostly in the Philippines

onezero.medium.com

41–50 of 101 posts

Re: WikiHow’s art is made by a network of freelancers, mostly in the Philippines

#41
post #17
post #7

Please don’t editorialize titles, four out of five times the editorialized title is strictly worse, and often it’s straight up wrong , like in this case. If you don’t like the original title due to omission of info, you can at least use the HTML title: > wikiHow’s art is made by a global network of freelancers, primarily in the Philippines. (Emphasis mine.)

OP's headline saves you a click, versus the original title: "We Finally Figured Out Who Makes wikiHow’s Bizarre Art"

Saving a click is probably an anti-goal of HN article titles.

Re: WikiHow’s art is made by a network of freelancers, mostly in the Philippines

#42
post #35

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't see how the current title isn't factual

I guess isn’t doing its job, so let me temporarily break the guidelines: “GLOBAL network of freelancers, PRIMARILY in the Philippines” != “an army of freelancers in the Philippines”.

Let me save you a click, & the authors future banal efforts: utilitarian work is a global effort of freelancers. Some just have different obligations as part of their freelance work than others.

Shock. Awe.

Re: WikiHow’s art is made by a network of freelancers, mostly in the Philippines

#43

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why is it always Medium that's blamed for this but not mainstream news websites? I'm pretty sure I've been paywalled by sites like NYT yet people keep posting links to them.

Because Medium doesn’t author anything. It’s as if NYT consisted of nothing but “letters to the editor” (without an editor and not in response to anything that was previously published, because they would be publishing nothing in the equivalent scenario) and then decided to put up a paywall. There are countless free (and even ad-free) text-only hosting options available. Medium provides nothing of value to me as a co…

> Medium provides nothing of value to me as a consumer.

The value is that it's providing a platform to authors who want a platform where they know they'll get readers. I personally don't choose to use Medium anymore, but it's very easy to get people to read your content on there. In the past I've used places like Wordpress, Blogger, my own webpages, etc., and it took a lot more effort to get people to see your content. Whereas on Medium, it didn't take long to get people to look at my content. Few things I wrote went into a black hole.

> I say this as someone that pays for about a dozen online newspaper/magazine subscriptions but will never pay a penny to access a site like Medium or Scribd or Quora or any other site that does nothing but make money off being the middle man.

They make money by being a platform to voices you might not otherwise hear because newspapers and magazines pick and choose a small set of authors to write most of their content. If that's not your cup of tea, then it's not your cup of tea.

I choose not to use Medium as an author, but I understand why people choose to publish on it and why some people would choose to pay for it.

> Anyway, it’s all moot as Medium will inevitably shutter or pivot.

Like every other business conceivably?

> If those views are killed off by requiring a paywall, then Medium itself becomes defunct.

Is that actually happening?

Re: WikiHow’s art is made by a network of freelancers, mostly in the Philippines

#44
post #17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

OP's headline saves you a click, versus the original title: "We Finally Figured Out Who Makes wikiHow’s Bizarre Art"

Saves more than a click because it requires you to sign in to read the article.

This isn't paywalled Medium content so you can simply find the close button and click it, be it on the sliding banner or the modal.

That being said, that action does require an extra click.

Re: WikiHow’s art is made by a network of freelancers, mostly in the Philippines

#45
post #15

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why is it always Medium that's blamed for this but not mainstream news websites? I'm pretty sure I've been paywalled by sites like NYT yet people keep posting links to them.

Because Medium used to promise it would never do this. https://www.niemanlab.org/2019/03/the-long-complicated-and-e...

That's what people get when they take promises of any kind seriously. I'm not excusing Medium, but at the same time I'm not going to hold some kind of false expectation over their head.

Re: WikiHow’s art is made by a network of freelancers, mostly in the Philippines

#47
post #23

> wikiHow instructed these freelancers on how “to create the most instructive visuals for every step of every article.” Hopefully written and illustrated in genuine wikihow style

Talk about dogfooding!

Re: WikiHow’s art is made by a network of freelancers, mostly in the Philippines

#48
wikihow is a cancer on the internet, clogging google and google image results with inane how-to guides .for the purpose of generating ad revenue. It is not just that the guides are bad but they are engaging in keyword spamming by creating guides for things that don't even make sense

Re: WikiHow’s art is made by a network of freelancers, mostly in the Philippines

#49
post #41
post #17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

OP's headline saves you a click, versus the original title: "We Finally Figured Out Who Makes wikiHow’s Bizarre Art"

Saving a click is probably an anti-goal of HN article titles.

in this case, I say it's OK

Re: WikiHow’s art is made by a network of freelancers, mostly in the Philippines

#50
Thank you very much OP for the clear title that save me a lot of time not wasted figuring out the reply to the clickbait title of the original article. If only the guys that are posting New York times articles and co could do the same...
Post reply on HN