Live data from Hacker News

A woman with a rare genetic mutation that has protected her from dementia

nytimes.com

41–42 of 42 posts

Re: A woman with a rare genetic mutation that has protected her from dementia

#41
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Thats absurd. She neither created nor detected the mutation. I agree that dna patents should not exist though. We share so much of it.

She, or her parents, literally created the mutation they're researching. "Accidentally" as part of a natural process for sure. But that doesn't take away the validity of them being the creators of it.

Understood- what if, after developing the drug you find these mutations occur spontaneously elsewhere in the world population- do all those people also get a cut?

Figuring how to do this is non-trivial.

Re: A woman with a rare genetic mutation that has protected her from dementia

#42
post #41

Earlier quoted context omitted.

She, or her parents, literally created the mutation they're researching. "Accidentally" as part of a natural process for sure. But that doesn't take away the validity of them being the creators of it.

Understood- what if, after developing the drug you find these mutations occur spontaneously elsewhere in the world population- do all those people also get a cut? Figuring how to do this is non-trivial.

Agreed. Doesn't mean "too hard, thus ignore" is the right approach though. ;)
Post reply on HN