Andrew, I think mixergy is one of the coolest things on the web. You've done great work bringing so much content to inspire us. So I'm surprised and a little disappointed to see you interview the likes of Tim Ferriss. Don't get me wrong; I understand that you're a journalist and want to keep an open mind. No question about the popularity of this person and his subject. I just don't think that he or his message are ve…
You're the reason I'm on HN, so your feedback is always more than "just another comment" to me. WHY I INTERVIEW TIM: 1) Eric Ries once told me how a tiny change to a marketing page is worth hours of recoding. I believe there are little changes that have big significance and Tim is good at identifying and explaining them. 2) There are loads of books about health, but his is going to be a top seller. I'm curious about…
The 4-Hour Body: (Quickly) Hacking The Human Body
41–50 of 107 posts
Re: The 4-Hour Body: (Quickly) Hacking The Human Body
#42Andrew, I think mixergy is one of the coolest things on the web. You've done great work bringing so much content to inspire us. So I'm surprised and a little disappointed to see you interview the likes of Tim Ferriss. Don't get me wrong; I understand that you're a journalist and want to keep an open mind. No question about the popularity of this person and his subject. I just don't think that he or his message are ve…
Re: The 4-Hour Body: (Quickly) Hacking The Human Body
#43Earlier quoted context omitted.
I appreciate my life choices for not having such a fellow on my radar (spelling is Ferriss - I discover by searching on Amz). Yet I wonder how I could have become so cynical as to doubt the "socially redeeming value" of an ~author~ who gets a book published by including claims such as: > YOU WILL LEARN (in less than 30 minutes each): > How to lose those last 5-10 pounds (or 100+ pounds) with odd combinations of food…
Ok, I though you were satirizing his content. I just want to confirm to other readers that the list of points you mentioned are verbatim from his web site.
Re: The 4-Hour Body: (Quickly) Hacking The Human Body
#44The reviews on Amazon look really suspicious. http://www.amazon.com/4-Hour-Body-Uncommon-Incredible-Superh... In the past few hours since the book was put on sale, there have been 90+ five star reviews. Either this is one of the best book every published, of the publisher/author has been organizing or paying for reviews.
This is always the case with movies and videogames, so I think the same applies: the people who are interested in the product go to see/watch/read it first. Eventually, "everyone else" gets around to try it out, and the score drops accordingly.
The original edition didn't do quite as well, but it still has a huge quantity of great reviews: http://www.amazon.com/4-Hour-Workweek-Escape-Live-Anywhere/p...
Re: The 4-Hour Body: (Quickly) Hacking The Human Body
#45What I tried to capture in this interview is Tim's belief that you can get 80% results with 5% effort. And that the other 95% effort (or whatever the %) is either the facetime that we feel we must put in to feel we earned our result, or an attempt at perfection. I'm not sure I agree with him completely, but my goal in the interviews is to learn, not to argue for "my side." My other goal here was to find out how he id…
I found that to be true with school. 5% effort usually gets you a B, while the closer you wanted to get to "perfection" (100%/A+), exponentially more effort is required.
Re: The 4-Hour Body: (Quickly) Hacking The Human Body
#46Every Tim Ferris thread I see on HN, has nigh 10 - 20 posts that all essentially say: "Tim Ferris is a charlatan. He's relies on spin and marketing to sell his products. His methods encourage people to be lazy and not make a genuine effort to reach their goals. His advice is counterproductive." But while Tim makes every effort to support his claims using facts, anecdotes and citations these sorts of comments are rare…
And when he's talking about winning the martial arts fights, he goal was to "WIN", not to play the game. And like gursikh says, either put up or shut up. We need concrete examples!
Overall, I think Tim has done a lot for a lot of people with the ideas that he shares in his books.
Re: The 4-Hour Body: (Quickly) Hacking The Human Body
#47Andrew, I think mixergy is one of the coolest things on the web. You've done great work bringing so much content to inspire us. So I'm surprised and a little disappointed to see you interview the likes of Tim Ferriss. Don't get me wrong; I understand that you're a journalist and want to keep an open mind. No question about the popularity of this person and his subject. I just don't think that he or his message are ve…
I appreciate my life choices for not having such a fellow on my radar (spelling is Ferriss - I discover by searching on Amz). Yet I wonder how I could have become so cynical as to doubt the "socially redeeming value" of an ~author~ who gets a book published by including claims such as: > YOU WILL LEARN (in less than 30 minutes each): > How to lose those last 5-10 pounds (or 100+ pounds) with odd combinations of food…
I enjoy fitness. I've worked out four to five days a week for the past seven years, first at a climbing gym, and then with Crossfit. I've competed in fitness competitions. I've know a number of well-respected high-level Crossfitters. I would call myself, at the very least, a fitness enthusiast.
I think some of these claims are at best, laughable, and, at worst, will give false hope to people who might truly be interested in fitness. Fitness is hard work!
> * How Tim gained 34 pounds of muscle in 28 days, without steroids, and in four hours of total gym time
Muscle memory will allow people to gain significant amounts of muscle in short periods of time, if that muscle has been trained before.
It's why athletes who take rest periods or have injuries are able to come back just as strong in only a few weeks.
It's the source of many of the before/after pictures for "health foods" and supplements.
If you're actually interested in gaining muscle and weight, the easiest way is to eat tons of food and do heavy, compound exercises three to four times a week.
> * How to sleep 2 hours per day and feel fully rested
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polyphasic_sleep
Anecdotally, a friend of mine ended up in the emergency room for severe dehydration after trying the Uberman's Sleep Cycle for three weeks.
> * How to triple testosterone and double sperm count
I imagine he's be talking about various supplements here. Supplement science is sketchy, and should always be taken with a grain of salt.
The best way to take supplements is to not take them, but rather, eat more fruits and vegetables.
> * How to go from running 5 kilometers to 50 kilometers in 12 weeks
Pretty simple, actually. There are progressive running plans in almost any running book.
Also, the difference between five and 50 km, at least to your muscles, is much less than the difference between 400M and 5K. It's just training your aerobic system and converting more of your muscle tissue to slow-twitch muscle fibers.
> * How to reverse “permanent” injuries
Eat right and exercise correctly.
If you read the forums for crossfit, or stronglifts, or a number of other fitness websites, or diet websites, you'll see people who miraculously cure their bad back, bad knees or diabetes, just by eating right and exercising correctly.
> * How to add 150+ pounds to your lifts in 6 months
This is almost guaranteed to happen when someone goes from an untrained state to the beginning of a trained state. It has to do with muscles learning to be used, rather than significant strength gains.
When I started Crossfit three years ago, I could barely deadlift 135#. Three years later, my last 1RM deadlift was 455#. Going from 135# to 300# was _so_ much easier and faster than going from 300# to 455#, because my body had always been able to do it, it just didn't know it.
Re: The 4-Hour Body: (Quickly) Hacking The Human Body
#48Andrew, I think mixergy is one of the coolest things on the web. You've done great work bringing so much content to inspire us. So I'm surprised and a little disappointed to see you interview the likes of Tim Ferriss. Don't get me wrong; I understand that you're a journalist and want to keep an open mind. No question about the popularity of this person and his subject. I just don't think that he or his message are ve…
Ed, I respectfully disagree. Tim Ferriss is a hacker. All of those things are _exactly_ the kind of "creative playfulness" that embodies the hacker spirit. I find Tim way more inspiring than "yet another discussion on how $TECHNOLOGY_X is {dead,the hottest thing since sliced bread}." YMMV.
So are the Chinese dudes who put melamine in the milk and formula they sold, poisoning untold numbers of children while increasing their profits by selling watered-down milk. (The melamine tested as protein, covering up the dilution.)
That was a hack. Same with 'hackers' who use shoddy building materials resulting in buildings that collapse.
Hackers like that are a dime a dozen. It's not anything I'd want to emulate. And I certainly wouldn't want to hire someone who thought along such lines.
Re: The 4-Hour Body: (Quickly) Hacking The Human Body
#49Andrew, I think mixergy is one of the coolest things on the web. You've done great work bringing so much content to inspire us. So I'm surprised and a little disappointed to see you interview the likes of Tim Ferriss. Don't get me wrong; I understand that you're a journalist and want to keep an open mind. No question about the popularity of this person and his subject. I just don't think that he or his message are ve…
One line from the 4HWW "Ask for forgiveness, not permission," can change the way you address challenges for the rest of your life. I'm really looking forward to seeing what insights he's put into the new book.
Re: The 4-Hour Body: (Quickly) Hacking The Human Body
#50Earlier quoted context omitted.
I appreciate my life choices for not having such a fellow on my radar (spelling is Ferriss - I discover by searching on Amz). Yet I wonder how I could have become so cynical as to doubt the "socially redeeming value" of an ~author~ who gets a book published by including claims such as: > YOU WILL LEARN (in less than 30 minutes each): > How to lose those last 5-10 pounds (or 100+ pounds) with odd combinations of food…
I'm apprehensive about Tim Ferriss. I've read 4HWW, and found it to have some good advice, as well a a significant amount of fluff. The announcement of "The 4-Hour Body", with lists like this on the book, have only increased my skepticism and apprehension. I enjoy fitness. I've worked out four to five days a week for the past seven years, first at a climbing gym, and then with Crossfit. I've competed in fitness compe…
Then the book isn't telling how to "gain 35 pounds of muscle". It's telling how to restore 35 pounds of muscle you recently had.
Which is significantly different from "add 35 new pounds of muscle".