Live data from Hacker News

Improving support for adult content on Mastodon

blog.joinmastodon.org

41–50 of 89 posts

Re: Improving support for adult content on Mastodon

#41

Earlier quoted context omitted.

As a modestly funded project, Mastodon is never going to achieve "hockey stick" growth, and it would probably be overwhelmed if this happened. It's better for them to pursue a strategy of gradual, steady growth. Mastodon is continuing to grow steadily, and it does so in the face of established players who can outspend and outrun them. 2 million users is pretty damn good for an open source project that doesn't have a…

The terminology is still going to seriously hinder uptake. All of what you said can be true and better terminology would still be better for them.

I guess I'm a cynic, but:

> Breaking news. In a series of explosive toots...

> The foreign minister was forced to resign after a number of offensive toots...

> Everyone's talking about what J K Rowling tooted today...

If the age of tweet-reporting ends because of "toots" then I am all for it. As for your other examples, you have a decent point.

> OMG, your toots are so funny!...

> I can't believe you tooted that!...

I can see how this might feel weird for some people, at least in the English-speaking world. But people thought "tweeting" was ridiculous, and they made fun of it relentlessly. In the end it doesn't matter all that much.

Re: Improving support for adult content on Mastodon

#42

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The terminology is still going to seriously hinder uptake. All of what you said can be true and better terminology would still be better for them.

I guess I'm a cynic, but: > Breaking news. In a series of explosive toots... > The foreign minister was forced to resign after a number of offensive toots... > Everyone's talking about what J K Rowling tooted today... If the age of tweet-reporting ends because of "toots" then I am all for it. As for your other examples, you have a decent point. > OMG, your toots are so funny!... > I can't believe you tooted that!...…

> But people thought "tweeting" was ridiculous, and they made fun of it relentlessly.

I don't think the terms "tweeting" and "tooting" are in the same ballpark in terms of how ridiculous they sound to people.

> In the end it doesn't matter all that much.

But naming does matter, which is why companies spend huge sums on it each year.

(Btw I removed those examples from my earlier comment as I felt they weren't relevant to the topic we were originally discussing, which was the name Madstodon)

Re: Improving support for adult content on Mastodon

#43
post #13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

mastodon's tooting...

Exactly, it's really gross. This isn't going to catch on in the mainstream. Mastodon seriously needs a rebrand.

Interestingly it is relatively popular in Japan (to the point where someone non-technical asked me if I used it the other day!) It's really only an issue for English speakers (though in the context of HN that seems like the whole world ;-) ).

I think it would be pretty darn easy to maintain a rebranded fork, though.

Re: Improving support for adult content on Mastodon

#45

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I guess I'm a cynic, but: > Breaking news. In a series of explosive toots... > The foreign minister was forced to resign after a number of offensive toots... > Everyone's talking about what J K Rowling tooted today... If the age of tweet-reporting ends because of "toots" then I am all for it. As for your other examples, you have a decent point. > OMG, your toots are so funny!... > I can't believe you tooted that!...…

> But people thought "tweeting" was ridiculous, and they made fun of it relentlessly. I don't think the terms "tweeting" and "tooting" are in the same ballpark in terms of how ridiculous they sound to people. > In the end it doesn't matter all that much. But naming does matter, which is why companies spend huge sums on it each year. (Btw I removed those examples from my earlier comment as I felt they weren't relevant…

Honestly, the name doesn't matter once the network effect kicks in.

Re: Improving support for adult content on Mastodon

#46
post #5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

And the language of "toot" is extremely hokey and will never be taken seriously. It implies farting for most Americans. "Tweet" reminds people of birds. As in "a little bird told me". Which is appropriate for a gossip style network.

[Edit: people downvoting this, care to explain what you disagree with in it?] Breaking news. In a series of explosive toots... The foreign minister was forced to resign after a number of offensive toots... OMG, your toots are so funny!... Everyone's talking about what J K Rowling tooted today... I can't believe you tooted that!... ...and so on If you think I'm joking then that shows how bad a name "toot" is. Because…

That honestly all sounded ridiculous a decade ago with "tweet", too. The success of the platform has normalised the nomenclature.

Re: Improving support for adult content on Mastodon

#47

There is a Ruby port [1] publicly available. From the encoding routine [2], it seems to be an sRGB correction followed by a two-dimensional DCT. The first two bytes encode parameters---the size of the output matrix n x m and the quantization scale used for ACs; next 4 bytes encode the DC, then (nm-1) quantized ACs (2 bytes per AC) follow. The comparison to Facebook's similar solution [3] would be interesting (but I r…

I created the algorithm, and there is a proper release of it with documentation and implementations in a few languages coming... "soon". It's a work project, so trying to find time to work on it is always tricky. If you have any questions, feel free to ask. The main goal of it is to be a placeholder while images load, but it also has a nice secondary use for hiding sensitive images here. Other aims of the algorithm i…

Off topic but I did a double take when I scrolled past your name. Are you the same guy who did some kind of imageboard related stuff years ago? I know that's vague, but my brain is fried and I can't remember why I remember you.

Re: Improving support for adult content on Mastodon

#48
post #20

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What's not cute about elephants? Especially fluffy ones?

"Extinct" is not really a good idea to associate your brand with.

In the world of outdoor equipment alone, two of the brands I like the most were named after extinct animals; Arc’teryx (referring to the Archaeopteryx) and Mammut (mammoth). Both of whom you will find a lot of products from in any decent sports store.

And it’s not just the names — look at their logos.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:ARC%27TERYX_logo.svg

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Mammut_logo.jpg

The first one is straight up the fossil skeleton of the animal they based their name on! If that doesn’t spell extinction I don’t know what does.

These two companies make jackets, climbing harnesses, trekking shoes, backpacks and more.

I doubt that either of these two that I mentioned have been negatively impacted by the fact the animals they have based their names and logos on are extinct.

(My personal opinion is that it makes them cooler even — the prehistoric times and the animals that used to roam the earth are very fascinating to me. And I think a lot of people agree. Look for example at how popular the Jurrasic Park movies were. People love this stuff, don’t they?)

Re: Improving support for adult content on Mastodon

#49

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"Extinct" is not really a good idea to associate your brand with.

In the world of outdoor equipment alone, two of the brands I like the most were named after extinct animals; Arc’teryx (referring to the Archaeopteryx) and Mammut (mammoth). Both of whom you will find a lot of products from in any decent sports store. And it’s not just the names — look at their logos. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:ARC%27TERYX_logo.svg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Mammut_logo.jpg The first…

The kind of sentiment that is successful in mountaineering is not the kind of sentiment that is successful in social media.

Re: Improving support for adult content on Mastodon

#50
post #4

I really like the idea of Mastodon, but i can't shake this feeling that their name is kind of awful. I get that they're not trying to be exactly like twitter but by comparison, twitter is a much bubblier and friendlier word.

Mastodon is fine, I always get the song by Cake playing in my head, but "toots," that's tough. I can think of tooting a horn, but it's hard not to also think of passing gas.
Post reply on HN