Live data from Hacker News

Listening to music 'significantly impairs' creativity

sciencesources.eurekalert.org

41–50 of 60 posts

Re: Listening to music 'significantly impairs' creativity

#41
I listen to lofi hip hop or a rain aimbient [0] while programming often. According to "Is Noise Always Bad? Exploring the Effects of Noise on Cognition" [1], this is actually fine. I think the rain ambient is fine, and perhaps even helpful, because it is steady and consistent, like the submission suggests.

[0] https://asoftmurmur.com/ [1] https://www.jstor.org/stable/10.1086/665048?seq=1#metadata_i...

Re: Listening to music 'significantly impairs' creativity

#42
post #36

So what is the solution to drown out ambient noise for example a noisy work place?

I can't recall where I got this, but I find the generated noise really good at reducing the distraction from co-workers' conversations, and it's not as boring as straight noise

  play -n synth  brownnoise synth pinknoise mix synth sine amod 0.2 60
'play' is from the SoX package

Re: Listening to music 'significantly impairs' creativity

#43

I'm a classical singer and just all around lover of music.. I'm also a software developer. Listening to music while I program is an absolute disaster. It either has to be a video or an audiobook.

I listen to music because I find conversations very distracting so an audiobook is disastrous for me.

Re: Listening to music 'significantly impairs' creativity

#44
post #31

From years ago, I remember reading about a study involving punch-card batch processing, where two teams were given a stack of input data and an algorithm to implement. One team listened to music, the other not. Both teams completed the task in about the same time, but the team not listening to music saw that after the complex algorithm, the output was the same as the input.

Consistent with the study... Creativity (as insight in thought) is a form of blending from concept to output. You're saying that access to this insight was not achieved by members of the music-listening group.

Re: Listening to music 'significantly impairs' creativity

#45

Interesting. Does programming use this creative language part of the brain or more mathematical? I have found that some songs with English lyrics as being distracting but not as much as people talking on the telephone in an office space

Why are we assuming that language = creative, and mathematics = not creative?

Well the article dealt with language, lyrics in music.

Re: Listening to music 'significantly impairs' creativity

#46
Indeed, music probably helps only when used as a tool to cut off distractions or to tune our mood. I used to work in an office where junk music (local popular radio) played aloud all day long so I listened to a nicer kind of music in headphones (although what I actually wanted was perfect silence).

Re: Listening to music 'significantly impairs' creativity

#47
The social sciences need to learn that some of the simplest words have the largest meaning. If your study is about one of those, you'd better be writing the General Relativity of your field.

This study is absolutely not about creativity. What -if anything at all- it is, about, I see was left as an exercise to the reader.

Post reply on HN