Live data from Hacker News

Google Engineer Builds Facebook Disconnect

techcrunch.com

41–50 of 51 posts

Re: Google Engineer Builds Facebook Disconnect

#41
post #36
post #34

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Installing this extension is as easy as clicking the big Install button on its page and then click Install when Chrome asks you whether you really want to install the extension.

You still need to go to Chrome extension website right? It's not that when you go to a website that has FB connect, the Chrome asks if you want to block it or not. That would be effective though.

I'd imagine that facebook would not be pleased ;)

Re: Google Engineer Builds Facebook Disconnect

#42
post #22
post #7

Come on, we already have a perfectly good protocol for this, OpenID. It's unfortunate how big companies try to lock users in their own authentication services rather than educate them about OpenID (although I think the new JanRain widgets turn OpenID into a "Connect with X" service, which is great).

OpenID is not a perfectly good protocol. It is a total mess. Implementing it is an exercise in pulling teeth. Every major implementation was vulnerable to a timing attack until recently, which severely compromised the security of both sites which actually accept OpenID. The user experience is an abomination which requires users understand concepts which strike them like ancient Aramaic. Half of the spec, which you ha…

Delegation is of great interest to anyone who runs their own web site but prefers to not run their own openid server.

(Won't touch the other trolling.)

Re: Google Engineer Builds Facebook Disconnect

#43
What's interesting to me is that this is done in Chrome, which has given eg, Adblock some trouble since it does not really allow extensions to change the page content, only hide parts of it. Would be interested in a technical look at how it's managing to filter out the facebook bugs given that limitation -- or has Chrome been updated to give extensions more power?

Re: Google Engineer Builds Facebook Disconnect

#44
post #36

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You still need to go to Chrome extension website right? It's not that when you go to a website that has FB connect, the Chrome asks if you want to block it or not. That would be effective though.

FWIW, you do not need to go the Chrome extension website to install an extension. It can be hosted by a 3rd party via a simple link on any website.

Yes, I get your point, but if you take an example of CNN, they are not going to have a link to disable FB Connect.

Re: Google Engineer Builds Facebook Disconnect

#45
post #43

What's interesting to me is that this is done in Chrome, which has given eg, Adblock some trouble since it does not really allow extensions to change the page content, only hide parts of it. Would be interested in a technical look at how it's managing to filter out the facebook bugs given that limitation -- or has Chrome been updated to give extensions more power?

knowing nothing else about chrome extension development:

Rapportive appears to modify page content in chrome

Re: Google Engineer Builds Facebook Disconnect

#47
post #29
post #26

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The browser extension is useful, even more so for non-technical people: you click a button and it's installed.

How many non-technical people do you know that use Chrome as their primary browser? I ask this because while I know plenty of tech savvy people that use Firefox, I'm in the minority on the Chrome/Chromium front amongst them, and I don't know a single non-technical person who uses Chrome.

I imagine there's plenty, since they've been running ads on Hulu, and possibly TV as well. They also have ads for it on the google homepage and youtube ('watch in a better browser' or something like that)

Re: Google Engineer Builds Facebook Disconnect

#50
post #44

Earlier quoted context omitted.

FWIW, you do not need to go the Chrome extension website to install an extension. It can be hosted by a 3rd party via a simple link on any website.

Yes, I get your point, but if you take an example of CNN, they are not going to have a link to disable FB Connect.

Right. But they aren't going to have an explanation on how to block FB connect with your firewall, so it's not really a disadvantage of an extension.
Post reply on HN