Live data from Hacker News

Let’s all go back to Tumblr

theoutline.com

41–50 of 138 posts

Re: Let’s all go back to Tumblr

#41

Tumblr is guaranteed one-upmanship. The reblogging feature causes escalation. We need to look at the brain, and figure out how neurons work together in networks to produce truth. Then use that model for our social networks.

What makes you think that neurons produce truth? Neurons mostly produce actionable thoughts.

> Neurons mostly produce actionable thoughts.

I suppose you think this is true.

Re: Let’s all go back to Tumblr

#42
This walled garden isn't working! Quick, let's get back to the last one!

Seriously though, blogs and RSS - communication on the internet has been solved. It just doesn't seem to be easily monetizable, so a big commercial entity isn't pushing it.

This is quite interesting though:

"Everyone I knew aged out of it, lost interest in chronicling their personal lives or got jobs writing the kinds of blogs they used to write for free."

So does this mean there is money out there for the kind of tumblr/blog weirdness people like to read?

Re: Let’s all go back to Tumblr

#43
post #42

This walled garden isn't working! Quick, let's get back to the last one! Seriously though, blogs and RSS - communication on the internet has been solved. It just doesn't seem to be easily monetizable, so a big commercial entity isn't pushing it. This is quite interesting though: "Everyone I knew aged out of it, lost interest in chronicling their personal lives or got jobs writing the kinds of blogs they used to write…

[deleted]

Re: Let’s all go back to Tumblr

#44
Only if tumblr promises to close down account/blogs promoting pedophilia/zoofilia/similar degenerate stuff. The moderation after the Yahoo buyout got quite stale, they don't even block nazi, or anti-zionist stuff which is a red flag in liberal media.

Re: Let’s all go back to Tumblr

#45
post #39

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I agree that individual blogs that emit an RSS feed to follow are a great thing. However, most bloggers don’t really have the skills to host their own blog on a dedicated server. So, even if they did avoid Tumblr, they would be relying on another such hosting service like Blogspot or Wordpress.com.

It isn't that hard to install a blog on a shared hosting plan or VPS somewhere. Just find something with CPanel and some sort of auto installer (I think it was called Fantastico or something) and Bob's your uncle. Don't even need to know how FTP works or how to code anything to do that...

And who maintains that when something inevitably goes wrong?

Re: Let’s all go back to Tumblr

#46

Tumblr is guaranteed one-upmanship. The reblogging feature causes escalation. We need to look at the brain, and figure out how neurons work together in networks to produce truth. Then use that model for our social networks.

What makes you think that neurons produce truth? Neurons mostly produce actionable thoughts.

Collectively neurons moderate their individual binary responses and together respond with more nuance to outside stimuli. Maybe that's the parallel she/he is trying to present?

Re: Let’s all go back to Tumblr

#47

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What makes you think that neurons produce truth? Neurons mostly produce actionable thoughts.

> Neurons mostly produce actionable thoughts. I suppose you think this is true.

Well, no. I thought about editing this after the fact, but couldn't come up with a succinct summary of what neurons do on a high level. So I let this first impulse stand.

Re: Let’s all go back to Tumblr

#48
post #38
post #3

A radical idea, lets all go back to blogs, hosted and owned by ourselves, on our own sites, which will enrich only us, and where you can write as long and as short as you want, and link to whatever you want.

Yeah. The only way things will really move forward (in terms of privacy, freedom of speech and general quality of discourse) is if people host their own stuff rather than relying on a bunch of large corporations aiming only to improve their own metrics and save their own sorry reputations.

Freedom of speech, sure. I don't know about privacy, though. Anything you post on your blog, or in the comments section of someone else's, will also end up getting scraped by robots and then aggregated and fed into the great Moloch idol of surveillance capitalism.

Savvy individuals could manage it themselves, by creating their own servers and encrypting the traffic and only granting access to trusted individuals. Most people, though, would have a hard time navigating that. A centralized (or perhaps semi-centralized, a la Mastodon) could help a lot on that front.

Perhaps something comparable to Google+'s Circles concept. I always thought that was a great idea which was unfortunately rendered completely unworkable by the unfortunate accident that it was implemented by Google.

Re: Let’s all go back to Tumblr

#49

Politics aside, tumblr is impossible to have long-form conversation on. Sure, it has longer posts than say, twitter, but replying to a chain makes makes things almost impossible to read. [0] Furthermore, instead of following content per se, you follow blogs that are likely going to be insular. Tumblr is just as much of an echo-chamber as Twitter is, if not even moreso. This is quite different from reddit or hn where…

For what it's worth, the Mastodon instance I'm on (and several others) bump the 5kchar limit to 65kchar and even 1Mchar.

I have legitimately seen 2MChar toots. They were automated, but gigantic Megachar toots.

Re: Let’s all go back to Tumblr

#50
I'm still shocked nobody has figured out how to turnkey self hosting. I mean I understand how complicated it is, given the range of options, but it seems like it's tractable.

Maybe if AWS/Azure etc... had some kind of sign up API that would make it possible.

Post reply on HN