Live data from Hacker News

An update on uBlock

ublock.org

41–50 of 89 posts

Re: An update on uBlock

#41
Anyone who wants a low overhead and trusted ad blocker should use uBlock Origin. The developer even refuses to take any donations (for some good reasons).

For those who want a lot more control and a content blocker, uMatrix would help.

Anything named as “Adblock” or “Adblock Plus” or similar is just a way for advertisers to decide what ads users see and don’t see, depending on how much they’re willing to pay and be held hostage to such extensions.

Re: An update on uBlock

#42
post #25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Pi-hole has made some pretty poor blocking choices in the past, so use at your own risk. For instance, they randomly decided to block *.microsoft.com - you can imagine the chaos that caused.

Only chaos if you run Windows. I wouldn't even notice if it was blocked.

> Only chaos if you run Windows

Or develop for Windows, or have a client who uses Windows, or neer to access any of the documentation on MSDN, or...

Re: An update on uBlock

#44

https://github.com/gorhill/uBlock/wiki/uBlock-Origin-is-comp...

Why doesn't ublock origin change its name to something else to avoid this confusion?

uBlock Origin shouldn’t change its name just because someone made a scammy website off its name. The issue is the website, not uBlock Origin.

Re: An update on uBlock

#45

Anyone who wants a low overhead and trusted ad blocker should use uBlock Origin. The developer even refuses to take any donations (for some good reasons). For those who want a lot more control and a content blocker, uMatrix would help. Anything named as “Adblock” or “Adblock Plus” or similar is just a way for advertisers to decide what ads users see and don’t see, depending on how much they’re willing to pay and be h…

+1 to uBlock Origin

Amusingly, trying to load the uBlock website was initially blocked by uBlock Origin!

Re: An update on uBlock

#46
post #35
post #21

Self-hosted DNS solution with an easy setup and a nice web GUI to manage it. https://pi-hole.net/ https://github.com/pi-hole/pi-hole

pi-hole is worse at adblocking than browser based adblockers (ublock origin, abp, etc.) because they can only block on domains. so it can't block ads such as somesite.example/ads/banner1.jpg or somecdn.example/adcompany/ads.js it also can't block inline ads such as those in google search results.

Exactly. DNS-based blocking is basically using an oversize hammer to drive nails. It works in some cases, but eventually you're going to run in to either false positives or false negatives depending on how it's configured.

It's basically only actually useful for locked down platforms like certain fruit-flavored mobile devices that don't allow their users to install a proper ad blocker. If you use platforms that respect their users' choices of software you don't need it.

Re: An update on uBlock

#47
> If you’ve noticed recent updates to the product, that’s because uBlock has been acquired by the team responsible for AdBlock. We will be investing heavily into uBlock to help it deliver on the promise of being one of the best ad blockers available.

Why would they invest "heavily into uBlock" instead of improving AdBlock? It doesn’t make sense to maintain two different ad blockers.

Re: An update on uBlock

#48
post #38
post #25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Pi-hole has made some pretty poor blocking choices in the past, so use at your own risk. For instance, they randomly decided to block *.microsoft.com - you can imagine the chaos that caused.

Sure, it would be chaos if you expect everything to just work out OK. But if you defang Windows 10 properly, it doesn't need to reach Microsoft servers. That is, blocking is a supplementary measure. When I last used Windows, you could host updates locally. And I believe that Microsoft actually recommended that for large firms.

> But if you defang Windows 10 properly, it doesn't need to reach Microsoft servers.

Something has to get the updates in the first place, even with the local P2P sharing.

If you're one of those "I never update my Windows install" people at this point you're beyond hope..

Post reply on HN