Live data from Hacker News

Yes, Amazon Is Tracking People

cato.org

41–50 of 210 posts

Re: Yes, Amazon Is Tracking People

#41

Intel is also tracking everyone through the use of a very low level instruction shipped inside of every intel CPU. Details of this trust busting instruction can be found here: https://c9x.me/x86/html/file_module_x86_id_5.html It has also been discovered that many common languages such as C and PHP also implement abstractions to make this low level instruction much easier to use to track people with. The common use ca…

What

Re: Yes, Amazon Is Tracking People

#42

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The facial recognition cat is out of the bag. If AWS is "enabling dystopia", so are Linux and Ethernet.

Linux and Ethernet do not "Easily add intelligent image and video analysis to your applications."

Any image recognition API is likely to heavily rely on them.

You can do positive things with Rekognition. You can do dystopian things with it, too. Get AWS to stop doing it and folks will just use GCP and Azure's similar offerings.

This is a problem that fundamentally needs government regulation to be successfully addressed.

Re: Yes, Amazon Is Tracking People

#44
post #5

Rekognition is a public service and not specific to law enforcement use[1]. [1]: https://aws.amazon.com/rekognition/ Disclaimer: I work for AWS.

>Rekognition is a public service When this is used to track/recognize my face in a crowd what service is it that I'm receiving?

You could make a drone that will follow your friends/enemies around and spray them with a super soaker. Use your imagination, the first person to figure out a good answer to your question will probably make a lot of money.

Re: Yes, Amazon Is Tracking People

#45

Kind of confused why Rekognition continues to be made into the 'bad guy' here. Even if stronger protections are rolled out for this it's become far too easy to make these types of systems to do a great job of keeping them at bay at this point. Most people with programming experience could roll out a reasonably accurate facial comparison/recognition model like Rekognition and deploy it to a Raspberry Pi without expell…

Your argument is that because other people can do it, that makes it OK for Amazon to do it.

If you ever have children, wait for them to make this same argument. It should happen around the age of five.

Re: Yes, Amazon Is Tracking People

#47

> Amazon’s facial recognition service, Rekognition, is designed to identify and track people going about their daily business. This isn’t hyperbole - a Rekognition spokesperson explicitly mentioned real-time tracking and identification at an Amazon Web Services summit earlier this year. The same spokesperson went on to call Orlando a “smart city,” with cameras everywhere that allow authorities to track persons of int…

Are people surprised that real-time image analysis has been commodified or that local governments are already applying this technology ahead of policy discussions?

Clarifying edit: I'm not being disingenuous. I may be too close to the technology to grok why this thread is a down-vote minefield. Running OpenCV on an Arduino board is years-old proof-of-concept stuff and now I have an AWS DeepLens sitting on my desk that can name which of my neighbors walked their dog past my house.

Re: Yes, Amazon Is Tracking People

#48
As long as I or you can use it to track the coming and going of your Congressman and Senators, at the same price that Amazon charges others, I guess it is okay. That nice townhouse he visited with the attractive blonde who lives there, while his wife was out of town? It's ok for me to track and then publish the info, right?

We're all equal when we are in public view, right?

Re: Yes, Amazon Is Tracking People

#49

As long as I or you can use it to track the coming and going of your Congressman and Senators, at the same price that Amazon charges others, I guess it is okay. That nice townhouse he visited with the attractive blonde who lives there, while his wife was out of town? It's ok for me to track and then publish the info, right? We're all equal when we are in public view, right?

Some are more transparent then others, in fact some are outright opaque.

Re: Yes, Amazon Is Tracking People

#50

> Amazon’s facial recognition service, Rekognition, is designed to identify and track people going about their daily business. This isn’t hyperbole - a Rekognition spokesperson explicitly mentioned real-time tracking and identification at an Amazon Web Services summit earlier this year. The same spokesperson went on to call Orlando a “smart city,” with cameras everywhere that allow authorities to track persons of int…

[deleted]
Post reply on HN