Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

Check if your data was shared with Cambridge analytica FB check tool

facebook.com

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

41–50 of 62 posts

Re: Check if your data was shared with Cambridge analytica FB check tool

#41

Post by StavrosK »

panarky wrote: post #38
forkerenok wrote: post #13

The cynic in me keeps wondering whether this is a genuine attempt at getting some transparency points or FB wants to more precisely analyze how many people actually care...

This only applies to the leak of 84 million profiles to Cambridge Analytica. This leak was less than 4% of a much larger leak that's not getting much attention. Why doesn't Facebook alert users if their profile was leaked to "malicious actors" who collected profiles of "most of its 2 billion users worldwide". https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-switch/wp/2018/04/04...

My question is, why do people think it's okay if Facebook has that data, but not Cambridge Analytica? Why does Facebook get a pass storing all the calls you made and all the profiles and webpages you looked at?

Re: Check if your data was shared with Cambridge analytica FB check tool

#42

Post by inlined »

slackoverflower wrote: post #12
lostlogin wrote: post #11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Similarly, some of those that never signed up have got Facebook storing data on them. Facebook knows what I look like, my email, birthdate and that’s just what I know. Would be interesting to see what’s there.

I can understand Facebook knowing what you look like from pictures of you other people upload and your email from others connecting their Gmail address books. How will they know your birth date though? (FYI, they probably know your phone number and who you made phone calls to, when, and the durations for the last 5 years)

Am I the only one who puts friends' birthdays in their contact card? I assume birthdays come from the same phone number slurping.

Re: Check if your data was shared with Cambridge analytica FB check tool

#43

Post by aylmao »

panarky wrote: post #38
forkerenok wrote: post #13

The cynic in me keeps wondering whether this is a genuine attempt at getting some transparency points or FB wants to more precisely analyze how many people actually care...

This only applies to the leak of 84 million profiles to Cambridge Analytica. This leak was less than 4% of a much larger leak that's not getting much attention. Why doesn't Facebook alert users if their profile was leaked to "malicious actors" who collected profiles of "most of its 2 billion users worldwide". https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-switch/wp/2018/04/04...

I think the reason this isn't being reported much on is because it wasn't a leak. It sounds like it was just a scrape of data from the site.

Scraping websites to collect public information is nothing new. Malicious actors do it all the time, as do non-malicious actors too. Google literally does it.

EDIT: I'm all for facebook messed up and we need more guarantees but lets be objective though. The CA issue is an issue, this 2 billion thing is just a web-crawler.

Re: Check if your data was shared with Cambridge analytica FB check tool

#44

Post by aylmao »

menocchio wrote: post #4
Tycho wrote: post #2

What’s funny about this whole thing is that nobody really cares that their own data may have been accessed by CA, they are just angry that other people, meaning gullible Trump supporters, may have been affected.

I care! And I would care even more if they had my real phone number, birthday, or home town. They still have my real name, college email address, actual friends and family. And photos. I'm actually pretty skeptical that Trump supporters were triggered to vote against their interests because of some crap they saw on Facebook.

Name, email, friend list sounds reasonable, but how do you know they've got your photos? Curious; has it been revealed what information they collected?

Re: Check if your data was shared with Cambridge analytica FB check tool

#45

Post by aylmao »

cstrat wrote: post #10
devilmoon wrote: post #8

What about those of us that actually deleted Facebook after the scandal? How are we supposed to check if our data was shared with CA if Facebook requires you to be logged in to check?

Yeah I am interested, but deleted my account a few weeks ago :(

My info wasn't leaked-- if it had been, I'm not sure if it would tell you how it was leaked (wether it was you who gave access to "This Is Your Digital Life" or a friend).

If you're actually very curious, all I can think of is you could ask your friends if any of them had their info leaked, and if it was through themselves or a common friend. If you're friends with anyone who gave access to the app, you're part of the bunch.

Re: Check if your data was shared with Cambridge analytica FB check tool

#47

Post by laythea »

StavrosK wrote: post #41
panarky wrote: post #38

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This only applies to the leak of 84 million profiles to Cambridge Analytica. This leak was less than 4% of a much larger leak that's not getting much attention. Why doesn't Facebook alert users if their profile was leaked to "malicious actors" who collected profiles of "most of its 2 billion users worldwide". https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-switch/wp/2018/04/04...

My question is, why do people think it's okay if Facebook has that data, but not Cambridge Analytica? Why does Facebook get a pass storing all the calls you made and all the profiles and webpages you looked at?

I agree with your premise, but it is a bit different though. The user directly engages with Facebook (off course, having read terms and conditions etc), but not any of the companies that used to get data. This level of indirection is what is causing the outrage here. There is a distinction, although I would give none of them my data.

Re: Check if your data was shared with Cambridge analytica FB check tool

#48

Post by nevi-me »

tudorw wrote: post #46

"you must log in first", er no, I deleted my account, I'd still like to know what they shared, is that possible ?

I think there's no incentive to do that.

- "I deleted my account 3 months ago, so how come my records still exist on your servers"?

- If a class-action or some other litigation takes place, proof that n+1 people's into was shared is worse than n people's info. If an account is deleted, perhaps less risk.

- If the only non-creepy way of verifying who I am is logging in, and I can't log in anymore, any other option is bad PR for FB, and is subject to abuse.

Re: Check if your data was shared with Cambridge analytica FB check tool

#49

Post by StavrosK »

laythea wrote: post #47
StavrosK wrote: post #41

Earlier quoted context omitted.

My question is, why do people think it's okay if Facebook has that data, but not Cambridge Analytica? Why does Facebook get a pass storing all the calls you made and all the profiles and webpages you looked at?

I agree with your premise, but it is a bit different though. The user directly engages with Facebook (off course, having read terms and conditions etc), but not any of the companies that used to get data. This level of indirection is what is causing the outrage here. There is a distinction, although I would give none of them my data.

Yes, that's one consideration, but Facebook also has much more data on you than you gave informed consent for. I guess people just haven't realized yet.

Re: Check if your data was shared with Cambridge analytica FB check tool

#50

Post by gjm11 »

One thing I find interesting about this is the very cautious wording of the message you get in the "good" case.

'As a result, it doesn't appear your Facebook information was shared with Cambridge Analytica by "This is Your Digital Life".'

They don't say your information wasn't shared with Cambridge Analytica. They don't even say your information "doesn't appear" to have been shared with Cambridge Analytica. They say it doesn't appear to have been shared by this particular route.

Mere caution on general principles? Or do they know or suspect that there may be other means by which Facebook users' data have been shared with Cambridge Analytica?

Post reply on HN