Live data from Hacker News

HN Poll: What is your personality type?

news.ycombinator.com

41–50 of 80 posts

Re: HN Poll: What is your personality type?

#41
post #23

I couldn't let this pass without bringing up the Forer Effect [1]: basically, that people will believe just about any vague generalization as long as they think it's been tailored to them. For all of the "science" that goes into building the models for these tests (not just MBTI), any that rely completely on self-evaluation (especially multiple choice questions), should be taken with a huge grain of salt. They're fin…

I'm glad that there is at least one person who is bringing up the issues with the MBTI.

The assumption that you can judge personalities from a Myers-Briggs test is rather silly. The test was constructed by non-experts based on Carl Jung's theories of psychological types. The "Criticism" section of the test's Wikipedia article [1] is rich in citations of how the test by and large doesn't test anything, except perhaps the I–E scale.

I admittedly kind of have an axe to grind on this test. I think it's a waste of time if you're trying to actually learn something, and especially dangerous when people use it for any actual purposes other than just personal fun.

1: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Myers-Briggs_Type_Indicator#Cri...

Re: HN Poll: What is your personality type?

#42
post #25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

He didn't. It's right there. ENFP.

I didn't know what you are talking about, until I solved the quiz and it turned out ENFP - and then I read about it. Seems to me that it's misrepresented as an idealizing champion of sorts. Maybe it looks like that to people on the surface, but it's more of a struggle to express oneself with a strong potent more than anything, from my experience at least.

I just read somewhere that President Obama was an ENFP. He seems to have a certain aura of cool about him.

Re: HN Poll: What is your personality type?

#43
post #23

I couldn't let this pass without bringing up the Forer Effect [1]: basically, that people will believe just about any vague generalization as long as they think it's been tailored to them. For all of the "science" that goes into building the models for these tests (not just MBTI), any that rely completely on self-evaluation (especially multiple choice questions), should be taken with a huge grain of salt. They're fin…

You're a Saggitarius, aren't you? Yeah, you must be.

Nope—Leo. But I just read the description of Sagittarius and, wow, it sounds a lot like me. ;-)

(I'm also a Phlegmatic, and we're a naturally skeptical bunch.)

Re: HN Poll: What is your personality type?

#44
I'm always surprised by how prevalent this personality test seems to be in the US. I had never heard of it before arriving here and it seems that almost everybody took it at some point in their lives.

A friend of mine said he had heard of it in France (where I'm from), but it's clearly not common.

Is it an American thing?

Re: HN Poll: What is your personality type?

#47

INTJ on this test, ILIE on the Lipson-Shiu. http://www.andrewlipson.com/lstest.html

I'm an ICIE- sadist. Go figure.

I'm also a dom who enjoys pain, both ways. But yeah, these personality tests are worth near 0$ (they're funny, and my time is not free).

Re: HN Poll: What is your personality type?

#48
Our team did Insights [1] training, which is like the Meyers-Briggs test but with different pivots (it's sort of hard to explain). One of the great things that came out of it was a team graph showing where each person was, so when you interacted with each other you could be mindful of the personality of your coworker (do they appreciate public praise or do they want a quiet personal thanks? do they prefer a get-to-they-point approach or a larger backstory and context to a task? etc.).

[1] http://www.insights.com/index.aspx

Re: HN Poll: What is your personality type?

#49
I just read a book called "The Millionaire Code" http://www.amazon.com/Millionaire-Code-Paths-Wealth-Building...

that talked about these personality types as well. The premise of the book is that by understanding your type and choosing a career that is a good fit you are more likely to achieve financial independence. One thing that occurred to me while reading it was that so many of the holy wars in software might be rooted in the fundamentally different perspectives that the different types have. The big one that comes to mind is the difference between the Perceiver and the Judger. Here I'm thinking about programmers who want to prescribe rules of style on the team, or even things like late versus early binding.

For what its worth the book listed historical examples of INTJ as people like Edison and Ben Franklin while INTP were Einstein and Carl Jung.

Re: HN Poll: What is your personality type?

#50

My I traded out for an E during high school. I'm now ENTJ. Perhaps a P would make me a better programmer. I have to admit, I'm not really a fan of Myers-Briggs. It makes loose, mutable categories, and doesn't make any helpful, testable predictions other than sweeping generalizations (such as INTP = programmer). The enneagram, however, that I like. Its proponents attempt to attach mystical garbage to it, which is unfo…

I totally agree. Even without taking the test, I found that only one or two of the enneagram types describe me and many of my family members to the T. Not all of the types. And even though I've changed Myers-Briggs types over time (which MBTI does not model), my primary enneatype has not changed. The changes that I've gone through, however, were modeled by the enneagram in a predictable way, with (in my opinion) an accurate reason for why those changes occurred.

It won't work 100%; you can't pigeon-hole everyone. It's just a model. But in the end, I found my research of the enneagram to be extremely helpful for personal growth by allowing me to be more aware of my own patterns. Patterns for reacting to problems, patterns for trying to get what I want, etc.

Post reply on HN