Live data from Hacker News

OnePlus Is Again Sending User Data to a Chinese Company Without User Consent

twitter.com

41–47 of 47 posts

Re: OnePlus Is Again Sending User Data to a Chinese Company Without User Consent

#41
post #22
post #11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

*EU, the UK won't be part of the GDPR for long enough that it'd have relevant effects.

The UK is implementing GDPR in full in UK law.

This whole Brexit thing is sure working out well, isn't it?

Re: OnePlus Is Again Sending User Data to a Chinese Company Without User Consent

#43
post #17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The GDPR applies extraterritorially. If a company even stores a record of a single EU citizen, the GDPR applies to it, and the EU has the right to seize the assets of the company for the purpose of enforcing it.

I am curious about something. If you were to only offer your service in North America, but someone from the EU comes over to North America on vacation, and somehow becomes recorded in your service. Does the GDPR still apply in this case?

As long as that someone is still in the US, no. But if the service is used from the EU, the GDPR applies.

Article 3 defines the territorial scope:

http://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/HTML/?uri=CELE...

Re: OnePlus Is Again Sending User Data to a Chinese Company Without User Consent

#45
post #17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The GDPR applies extraterritorially. If a company even stores a record of a single EU citizen, the GDPR applies to it, and the EU has the right to seize the assets of the company for the purpose of enforcing it.

>The GDPR applies extraterritorially. Yeah. Good luck with that. It'll work for the big, entrenched companies like Facebook who couldn't bear to be without its UK customers, for example. But I don't see the EU successfully going after every little dot-com startup from Alabama to Angola, many of them in jurisdictions that barely have a functioning legal system, let alone respect for EU law. If such extraterritorial en…

You can try that, but every major bank will cooperate and simply freeze your accounts if ordered to do so.

Re: OnePlus Is Again Sending User Data to a Chinese Company Without User Consent

#46
post #22
post #11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

*EU, the UK won't be part of the GDPR for long enough that it'd have relevant effects.

The UK is implementing GDPR in full in UK law.

For now that is certainly true, but as is obvious, we don't know yet which laws will be retained after Brexit, and with even such major things as the ECHR still undecided, I wouldn't put it past them to repeal this as well in the future.

Re: OnePlus Is Again Sending User Data to a Chinese Company Without User Consent

#47
Seems to me like this might be a requirement for Asian markets or for selling phones in those regions. Author has tweeted that it's specific to Chinese regional locale/headset. Can't it be chalked up to the costs of doing business if sales plummet? OP5s owner here.
Post reply on HN