I wish I came across the so called proof-based math before calculus and trigonometry. It would have grabbed me instantly. High school math (and especially physics) classes would leave me with very uneasy feeling that something crucial is left unmentioned, something important is swept under the rug and something important is hidden for whatever reason. Turns out I was wanting for proofs, but couldn't articulate it - I…
Lessons I Wish I Had Learned Before Teaching Differential Equations (1997) [pdf]
41–50 of 112 posts
Re: Lessons I Wish I Had Learned Before Teaching Differential Equations (1997) [pdf]
#42Earlier quoted context omitted.
Your high school didn't teach geometry?
My kids are in high school right now. I was getting my daughter psyched up for geometry, by promising her that she'd get to do proofs. The geometry class completely glossed over proofs. It was much more oriented towards solving problems. I don't know if it was because of standardized testing, but I have my suspicions. Fortunately, my daughter worked on the proofs herself, outside of class. I was saddened for many rea…
Re: Lessons I Wish I Had Learned Before Teaching Differential Equations (1997) [pdf]
#43Going to drink a beer now for Oliver Heaviside. The invention of the Laplace transform is one of the greatest contributions to engineering.
Re: Lessons I Wish I Had Learned Before Teaching Differential Equations (1997) [pdf]
#44Earlier quoted context omitted.
Funnily enough, from a mathematical point of view, it's the opposite: integration is a really nice operation that can be applied to basically anything, whereas differentiation is really finicky, sometimes derivatives don't exist and you can't even be too sure when, so you need to be extra careful. This carries over to doing numerical computing: integrating an arbitrary function is easy, for smooth 1d functions it's a…
More like `from a computational point of view.' Analytically, integration is much more difficult and richer than differentiation!
Re: Lessons I Wish I Had Learned Before Teaching Differential Equations (1997) [pdf]
#45Re: Lessons I Wish I Had Learned Before Teaching Differential Equations (1997) [pdf]
#46It's sad one needs to reinforce the teaching of concepts rather tricks. Even worse is when you have all the proof based and concept oriented course and are tested on trickeries on exams.
It gave me a good "visual" grasp of the concepts and made most of my higher math classes much easier.
I do agree diff eq instruction sucks. I got an A in that class and didn't understand a thing. "This equation has this form; this is the canned solution."
Re: Lessons I Wish I Had Learned Before Teaching Differential Equations (1997) [pdf]
#47Earlier quoted context omitted.
Your high school didn't teach geometry?
Geometry proofs aren't real proofs.
Re: Lessons I Wish I Had Learned Before Teaching Differential Equations (1997) [pdf]
#48Earlier quoted context omitted.
Funnily enough, from a mathematical point of view, it's the opposite: integration is a really nice operation that can be applied to basically anything, whereas differentiation is really finicky, sometimes derivatives don't exist and you can't even be too sure when, so you need to be extra careful. This carries over to doing numerical computing: integrating an arbitrary function is easy, for smooth 1d functions it's a…
Only numerically? Analytically, differentiation is much easier and integrals are tough or impossible, unless I'm missing something.
Re: Lessons I Wish I Had Learned Before Teaching Differential Equations (1997) [pdf]
#49Please teach calculus before teaching trigonometry. There's no prerequisite to learn trig first, and forcing people to learn trig-calc excites many mathophiles but is a major turn off to other students. Calculus can be taught using just basic algebra, and most students will benefit from already understanding calculus, when they are learning trigonometry.
Re: Lessons I Wish I Had Learned Before Teaching Differential Equations (1997) [pdf]
#50What is the point of that?
Edit: Everyone should be aware of this amazing Gian-Carlo Rota quote, the entirety of a book review on contemporary philosophers: "When pygmies cast such long shadows, it must be very late in the day."