Live data from Hacker News

Windows Subsystem for Linux is out of beta

blogs.msdn.microsoft.com

41–50 of 231 posts

Re: Windows Subsystem for Linux is out of beta

#41

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Would you mind elaborating a bit? What's the exact functionality that's required? Is it like notification support for file modification or something?

Yep, but they fixed it already, fix rolled out with the last major Windows 10 update.

Ah okay, awesome.

Re: Windows Subsystem for Linux is out of beta

#42
post #2

In my experience, emulators are never quite the same as the real deal. Has anyone used this, and if so how was it?

It's not an emulator

Depends on your definition of "emulator". Since it is a thing that emulates Linux kernel calls on top of the NT kernel...it is definitely "emulating".

Re: Windows Subsystem for Linux is out of beta

#43
post #21
post #19

Can someone point to a decent X server for windows?

From the article: > NO current plans to support X/GUI apps, desktops, servers, etc. at this time

It still works. X is a protocol, install a server and point at it.

It's unsupported, which means it doesn't necessarily work well and they won't help you out.

Re: Windows Subsystem for Linux is out of beta

#44
post #3

finally I can remove the win32 specific code from all the open source software I maintain not sure that was what Microsoft was going for though...

Unless you're going to force your users to install WSL up front(which is a pretty poor first contact) I think you might be better served by keeping it around.

Why? The Linux sub-system is the best part of Windows. He's doing them a favor.

Re: Windows Subsystem for Linux is out of beta

#45
post #6
post #2

In my experience, emulators are never quite the same as the real deal. Has anyone used this, and if so how was it?

It is not an emulator and the experience is pretty great for anything involving Linux as a workstation. Even though they say "NO current plans to support X/GUI apps, desktops, servers, etc. at this time", this is achievable by installing VcXsrv.

A Linux workstation at the very least involves X and full user's control over the computer, neither of which are provided by this piece of software.

Re: Windows Subsystem for Linux is out of beta

#46
post #2

In my experience, emulators are never quite the same as the real deal. Has anyone used this, and if so how was it?

I had it break on me a while ago because there was no inode support and that's needed for hot-reloading of code when developing with web frameworks. I'd rather just use Linux and not be surprised by anything.

Wasn't that the first beta release of insider? I thought they fixed inode support

https://blogs.msdn.microsoft.com/commandline/2016/10/07/wsl-...

Re: Windows Subsystem for Linux is out of beta

#47

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I've been using it every single day since it was announced. It's pretty nice. There are compatibility issues with some programs (mainly networking and a couple weird syscalls), but for 90+% of things, I've had no issues.

Why not just run Linux? Or use a Mac?

My main project is Ruby, but have a small (mission critical) app that is WinForms .Net. Developing with VisualStudio (not VS Code) inside a VM on a Mac is terrible.

This is way better.

Re: Windows Subsystem for Linux is out of beta

#49
Great news, this will hopefully allow our developers to make code on Linux since they've been forbidden from running VMs and it's extra overhead.

I hope Visual Studio gets good integration here because it truly is a first class IDE and it's hard for me to tempt our windows developers away based on that fact combined with the "We don't support linux on desktops" and "No VMS" attitude of my company.

Re: Windows Subsystem for Linux is out of beta

#50

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I've been using it every single day since it was announced. It's pretty nice. There are compatibility issues with some programs (mainly networking and a couple weird syscalls), but for 90+% of things, I've had no issues.

Why not just run Linux? Or use a Mac?

My main project is Ruby, but have a small (mission critical) app that is WinForms .Net. Developing with VisualStudio (not VS Code) inside a VM on a Mac is terrible.

This is way better.

Post reply on HN