Live data from Hacker News

Flooding of US Coast, Caused by Global Warming, Has Begun

nytimes.com

41–50 of 73 posts

Re: Flooding of US Coast, Caused by Global Warming, Has Begun

#41
post #3

As I wrote in HN's dialog about a New York Magazine article on global warming https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12471815 : As usual, nothing about prevention. Global temperatures and the sea level are rising because of human behavior. If we want different results, we have to behave differently. Engineers and scientists know engineering and science but not so much leading people to change their behavior. It's easy…

"Engineers and scientists know engineering and science but not so much leading people to change their behavior." Yes, I'd rather think that's by design. The climatologists and scientists who have spent decades warning people of the dangers, constantly, spending their lives wandering the corners of the earth collecting evidence, getting ignored and ostracized by private industry, by backwards-looking governments at lo…

[deleted]

Re: Flooding of US Coast, Caused by Global Warming, Has Begun

#43
NY Times: "Caused by Global Warming"

USGS: "More than half caused by land subsidence"

"Land subsidence causes more than half the relative sea level rise in Norfolk, largely explained by groundwater extraction." http://pubs.usgs.gov/circ/1392/pdf/circ1392.pdf

The article at least mentions the subsidence issue by saying it will be "worse than average" in areas where the land is "sinking at a brisk clip", but gives a distorted view of the relative contribution.

Re: Flooding of US Coast, Caused by Global Warming, Has Begun

#44
post #34
post #3

As I wrote in HN's dialog about a New York Magazine article on global warming https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12471815 : As usual, nothing about prevention. Global temperatures and the sea level are rising because of human behavior. If we want different results, we have to behave differently. Engineers and scientists know engineering and science but not so much leading people to change their behavior. It's easy…

How many scientists and engineers live in a suburban McMansion and drive an SUV? Individual behavior changes aren't going to fix this problem. Nothing will. It's a forest fire that will just run its course.

In other words, it's a collective action problem. It's not as if those never get solved.

Re: Flooding of US Coast, Caused by Global Warming, Has Begun

#45

We all know by now CO2 and CH4 leads to a warmer planet. We also know what's driving greenhouse gas levels to rise across Earth. Contributors are deforestation, intensive animal farming, and primarily the combustion of carbon fossil fuels like coal, tar sands, oil, natural gas etc. But here is the underlying problem, despite us knowing how bad things are, (97+% of scientists who study this field agree we are causing…

Deforestation is so serious, I visited Indonesia last year and all I could see from the plane was smoke from illegal burning of forests for palm oil plantations and cheap mass animal agriculture. It was the worst fire in known history and a really, really sad thing to witness, the baron charred fields left behind are really a terrible thing to see. I wonder why on earth more wealthy Governments don't send in the "def…

> I wonder why on earth more wealthy Governments don't send in the "defense forces" to help stop this illegal activity, instead of going to Syria, it's such a no brainier. Countries like Brazil and Indonesia shouldn't be required to protect everything on their own, nor should activists, murders of activists are a reality because they're just getting in the way of business.

Pardon me, but why the hell do you think that sending in the military, especially foreign military, would effect any changes on the ground? The problem is corruption, a purely political problem, and as the Iraqi surge very well demonstrated, a military solution cannot solve a political problem.

Re: Flooding of US Coast, Caused by Global Warming, Has Begun

#46
post #25
post #3

As I wrote in HN's dialog about a New York Magazine article on global warming https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12471815 : As usual, nothing about prevention. Global temperatures and the sea level are rising because of human behavior. If we want different results, we have to behave differently. Engineers and scientists know engineering and science but not so much leading people to change their behavior. It's easy…

I don't understand the emphasis on air travel I frequently see in these discussions. Passenger planes are much more fuel efficient per passenger-mile than single-occupancy cars. Most people drive far more miles alone each year than they travel by plane. It makes no sense to me to criticize someone for flying a couple thousand miles at ~100MPG when the average American drives 12,000 miles per year at ~25MPG. Beyond th…

Same thing happens when people see a city bus spewing black smoke from it's exhaust pipe, without realizing that that bus is currently taking the place of 20 or more cars.

Re: Flooding of US Coast, Caused by Global Warming, Has Begun

#47

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I know this sounds a bit Ayn Rand, but almost all scientists, engineers, and computer scientists know that global warming is real and is happening. Can we not just all go on strike until the dumb or greedy people get shoved aside? Like, granted, there was some pretty effective misinformation back in 2008, but the science is completely settled now. The public benefits from our medicines and software and infrastructure…

There's already some evidence of friction between military and the (in)corporate Congress. Military folks are made up of people who live in and grew up in economically difficult situations, and as the US civilian gov and their intelligence orgs continue their strengthening of alignment with corporate interests (profit above all else) the friction is going to build like the rising waters. Edit: cliche, but history has…

> The fall of the Roman Republic is one such historical occurrence where the military became more aligned with the common citizen than their own republic government.

Really? Some references would be good.

Re: Flooding of US Coast, Caused by Global Warming, Has Begun

#48
post #16
post #14

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That book is unrelated to the environment. It's about developing the skill of changing mental models in general through an exercise of writing them out and seeing how they work. I have deep passions for teaching leadership and for reducing pollution. Professionally, I have decided to focus on teaching leadership for now so I write a lot less on pollution, though I continue to refine my personal behavior, for example…

Thanks, I'll take a look. I live in a region of the Middle East that is more part of the problem than the solution I recycle, because we are in a city upon a hill type project, but others laugh at me and see it as pointless. I drive, sadly, but try to minimize it and do multiple errands in one circuit of a trip. Public transportation here is almost non-existent, and the average temp in the summer is over 40 degrees C…

You are at KAUST?

Re: Flooding of US Coast, Caused by Global Warming, Has Begun

#49

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I know this sounds a bit Ayn Rand, but almost all scientists, engineers, and computer scientists know that global warming is real and is happening. Can we not just all go on strike until the dumb or greedy people get shoved aside? Like, granted, there was some pretty effective misinformation back in 2008, but the science is completely settled now. The public benefits from our medicines and software and infrastructure…

I've thought about the strike thing for sometime also, why do we keep propping these people up? The kind of action you're describing is inevitable IMO. Humans may have to go on mass strike until we get the correct Government action on climate change. Sadly, strikes might not even be required/optional soon due to impacted health from rising temperatures, air pollution and difficulty commuting. I'm currently living in…

Why do you mention the heatwaves? Do you have evidence they are related to climate change? I think it only changes temperatures by a few Celsius.

Re: Flooding of US Coast, Caused by Global Warming, Has Begun

#50
post #30

This problem can't be solved. No politician who advocates the sort of changes required will be reelected. There is no way to enforce international agreements. Probably the best idea is to start thinking about risky geoengineering remediation techniques.

If U.S. leads the way, EU, Canada and Japan will follow. Then you have over 50% of world GDP behind ecological embargo. So the rest are not too much of a problem.

If U.S. does nothing, then each individual EU country and Japan and Canada will all be individually too small to do it. EU won't take orders from non-NATO countries. And EU can't risk it's credibility on something that expensive that's not backed by USA. It would fuel exit-populist propaganda too much. Meanwhile USA is not breaking apart in similar fashion.

Looking from a Nordic country, this is the only reason why electing Trump would be a sad mistake. Otherwise Trump is just funny.

Post reply on HN