Live data from Hacker News

Quora begins making money with the introduction of advertising

techcrunch.com

41–50 of 75 posts

Re: Quora begins making money with the introduction of advertising

#41

Quora has become a collection of loaded and low-effort questions (the answers are still good though) But there wouldn't be much loss if it closed

What, you mean questions like "Was Bill Clinton a cooler president than Obama?" [0], which is currently featured on their homepage? [0] https://www.quora.com/Was-Bill-Clinton-a-cooler-president-th...

That is certainly not one of the worse ones.

Re: Quora begins making money with the introduction of advertising

#42
A while back I wrote an article [1] saying that there was no advertising on Quora because that would mean that the founders would have to accept more realistic valuations for their business, and at that time it seemed they were happy to bring investors on using the "greater fool" theory. However, as Russ Hanneman [1] says: "If you show revenue people will ask how much and it will never be enough". So the question now is: will the introduction of ads harm Quora's valuation?

[1] http://newslines.org/blog/why-quora-joined-y-combinator/ [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BzAdXyPYKQo

Re: Quora begins making money with the introduction of advertising

#43

Quora's problems today are a direct result of what made them popular: celebrity. They made a great big splash when the media genuflected to the idea that "You can ask a question about Facebook, and Mark Zuckerberg could answer! " So regardless of the question or answer there will always be dominance by celebrities and their celebrators gleefully upvoting anything they post regardless of underlying fact. I prefer Stac…

One thing I love about Stack Exchange is the ability to add "This advice is INSECURE! See Beth's answer below for a better way to solve this problem." to accepted answers with really bad suggestions.

These kinds of answers get called out fairly quickly.

Re: Quora begins making money with the introduction of advertising

#44

Quora has become a collection of loaded and low-effort questions (the answers are still good though) But there wouldn't be much loss if it closed

What, you mean questions like "Was Bill Clinton a cooler president than Obama?" [0], which is currently featured on their homepage? [0] https://www.quora.com/Was-Bill-Clinton-a-cooler-president-th...

You should see some of the threads about the relative attractiveness and intelligence of various racial groups.

Re: Quora begins making money with the introduction of advertising

#45
post #20

"[Quora] recently reported that it has 100 million monthly visitors... with 15 percent from India." Interested in knowing the ratio of questions:answers coming from Indian users.

Don't be deceived. The visitors include search traffic, so this isn't representative of the content creators. I expect the percentage of content creators to be higher than the passing observer percentage.

Re: Quora begins making money with the introduction of advertising

#46

Earlier quoted context omitted.

One thing I love about Stack Exchange is the ability to add "This advice is INSECURE! See Beth's answer below for a better way to solve this problem." to accepted answers with really bad suggestions.

These kinds of answers get called out fairly quickly.

Not always.

https://meta.stackoverflow.com/questions/293930/problematic-...

Re: Quora begins making money with the introduction of advertising

#47
Sure there are some spam and useless answers, but there are experienced users as well who contributing with great answers.

Everyone good on Quora is going to get "Church'd" soon enough. The moderators have done everything they can to drive out quality. The ban of Michael O. Church (who was a moderate, thoughtful member of that community, regardless of his divisive presence here) convinced me of that.

I also find it interesting that any Indian or Chinese woman with feminist views that would be considered moderate in the U.S. gets reported as a sock puppet and banned.

Re: Quora begins making money with the introduction of advertising

#48
Some of my employees are ex-Quora employees. The company is a dumpster fire. It has a lot of turnover and huge quality-of-life issues for employees.

I agree that it's over-obsessed with the real-world reputations of its users. It also kills its young. If your reputation gets "too big", you get banned, just like a card counter gets kicked out of casinos.

Re: Quora begins making money with the introduction of advertising

#49
There were four people I considered genuinely worth reading. Only one of them still posts, and sporadically.

One got banned, and Quora lied about why it banned him, damaging his professional reputation.

One left because she got harassing PMs.

The other, I don't know what happened. I think he had a falling out with moderators but I can't get the details. He just stopped posting.

Re: Quora begins making money with the introduction of advertising

#50

There were four people I considered genuinely worth reading. Only one of them still posts, and sporadically. One got banned, and Quora lied about why it banned him, damaging his professional reputation. One left because she got harassing PMs. The other, I don't know what happened. I think he had a falling out with moderators but I can't get the details. He just stopped posting.

> One got banned, and Quora lied about why it banned him, damaging his professional reputation.

While this is quite troubling, I'm puzzled by the idea that Quora has even the remotest influence on one's professional reputation. Is this really a thing? Please pardon my naïveté, I don't move in these circles.

Post reply on HN