Live data from Hacker News

Network handover in Google Fi

nicholasarmstrong.com

41–50 of 54 posts

Re: Network handover in Google Fi

#41

"but that doesn’t change the fact that Google has produced a service that works, is easy to use, switches quickly between networks," I've had what can only be described as a hellish experience with Google's Fi service since I got it. My bugs include but are not limited to: - SIM cards randomly not being associate with both networks, the fix for which is clearing the Fi app data, restarting the phone, and then re-runn…

I am happy so far.

Re: Network handover in Google Fi

#42

"but that doesn’t change the fact that Google has produced a service that works, is easy to use, switches quickly between networks," I've had what can only be described as a hellish experience with Google's Fi service since I got it. My bugs include but are not limited to: - SIM cards randomly not being associate with both networks, the fix for which is clearing the Fi app data, restarting the phone, and then re-runn…

This does not match my experience. I've had Fi for a few months now and I have 0 complaints. I'm in NYC and switched from AT&T, but even when visiting New Hampshire I haven't been affected by dropped calls or bad service.

Did you have a pre-existing device, or did you buy a new one.

Most people I've talked to with pre-existing devices have had varying degrees of problems.

Re: Network handover in Google Fi

#43
post #37
post #36

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's not pre-approved APs as far as I'm aware, it's any public AP that has no password or landing page, and isn't manually set by you. If you have wifi assistant enabled, it will automatically try to connect to anything that's open from what I've seen.

That's not what Google Fi support told me: > Thank you for contacting Project Fi Support! My name is Sydney and I will be glad to assist with your issue regarding WiFi services today. First, your phone should connect automatically to open WiFi networks. They have to be Google verified networks to automatically connect. Here is an article regarding our feature known as WiFi assistant and how it works. And I did try co…

The assistant has to make the connection, not the user. I've seen it work against quite a few different APs including some obscure ones, so I'm not sure there's a list or not. The online docs suggest that it does some performance testing before connecting.

Re: Network handover in Google Fi

#44

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This does not match my experience. I've had Fi for a few months now and I have 0 complaints. I'm in NYC and switched from AT&T, but even when visiting New Hampshire I haven't been affected by dropped calls or bad service.

Did you have a pre-existing device, or did you buy a new one. Most people I've talked to with pre-existing devices have had varying degrees of problems.

Yea I bought a Nexus 6 when I signed up. I thought that was the only supported device though.

edit: I also had no previous Google Voice account to transfer FWIW

Re: Network handover in Google Fi

#45

"but that doesn’t change the fact that Google has produced a service that works, is easy to use, switches quickly between networks," I've had what can only be described as a hellish experience with Google's Fi service since I got it. My bugs include but are not limited to: - SIM cards randomly not being associate with both networks, the fix for which is clearing the Fi app data, restarting the phone, and then re-runn…

Works great for me, I got the N6 with the service.

Re: Network handover in Google Fi

#46

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Did you have a pre-existing device, or did you buy a new one. Most people I've talked to with pre-existing devices have had varying degrees of problems.

Yea I bought a Nexus 6 when I signed up. I thought that was the only supported device though. edit: I also had no previous Google Voice account to transfer FWIW

I have no doubts that if you greenfield it, Google has that flow tested.

Many of us had pre-existing 6's and I think most people with troubles are there. Be thankful you haven't had to interact with support. Individually they're all nice and want to help, but collectively they have no agency and minimal education.

Re: Network handover in Google Fi

#47
post #15

https://republicwireless.com provides seamless wifi->cell and cell->wifi handover of calls.

There is a connection between Google (or is it Alphabet) and Bandwidth.com (the Republic Wireless parent company) that I can't quite figure out. Google Voice is mostly based on Bandwidth.com technology, and Republic Wireless and Google Fi are very similar products. Republic Wireless even claims they are about to release a dual-carrier option like Project Fi which they call Tempo. It is possible that they are just com…

Republic Wireless is sticking to Motorola phones, there is that connection.

Re: Network handover in Google Fi

#48

"but that doesn’t change the fact that Google has produced a service that works, is easy to use, switches quickly between networks," I've had what can only be described as a hellish experience with Google's Fi service since I got it. My bugs include but are not limited to: - SIM cards randomly not being associate with both networks, the fix for which is clearing the Fi app data, restarting the phone, and then re-runn…

I've been saying google declares victory at 80/20 for years now, and haven't fought with them for about 6 months. I wait until they fix it, or someone writes an Xposed app, or I just don't take the update. I'm still on KK4.4. After seeing many of my 'feedback' suggestions get implemented within 2 weeks/the next update, I don't do testing for them anymore. They can pay me to be a Consistency Czar, otherwise my efforts are better spent raising children and in relationships with people.

Re: Network handover in Google Fi

#49
post #21
post #4

When Fi was announced they mentioned that public wifi traffic would go through a VPN to google's datacenters. At the time I assumed that they'd just run ALL traffic through the VPN, since that'd make for some very seamless switching. As bad as that would be from a privacy perspective, I trust Google more than T-Mobile or Sprint. By running everything through the VPN, you'd be able to have TCP connections that didn't…

"from a privacy perspective, I trust Google more than T-Mobile or Sprint" From a privacy perspective, I would not trust an advertising company (Google) more than a telecom. Google is perhaps better about disclosure to a Government entity, but they would be worse about exploiting your data for their own ends.

Seems many here do trust Google with their personal data. So, I suppose that implies they are not only a marketing company, but a good one :)

Re: Network handover in Google Fi

#50

"but that doesn’t change the fact that Google has produced a service that works, is easy to use, switches quickly between networks," I've had what can only be described as a hellish experience with Google's Fi service since I got it. My bugs include but are not limited to: - SIM cards randomly not being associate with both networks, the fix for which is clearing the Fi app data, restarting the phone, and then re-runn…

I haven't had any issues, it works really well for me. I got a new device and didn't switch an existing device.
Post reply on HN