Live data from Hacker News

“Stop reverse engineering our code”

blogs.oracle.com

41–50 of 358 posts

Re: “Stop reverse engineering our code”

#41
In the first paragraph the writer insinuates that she'd like to kill people who drive too close behind her.

Any subsequent valid points she makes - and there aren't many - are undermined by this bitterness.

Heightened emotion so often enables effective communication, but it doesn't do any favors in this post.

Re: “Stop reverse engineering our code”

#42

> Q. If you don’t let customers reverse engineer code, they won’t buy anything else from you. > A. I actually heard this from a customer. It was ironic because in order for them to buy more products from us (or use a cloud service offering), they’d have to sign – a license agreement! With the same terms that the customer had already admitted violating. “Honey, if you won’t let me cheat on you again, our marriage is t…

The scorn for customers in general is palpable. Why is Oracle even allowing this person to be a voice for their brand?

Re: “Stop reverse engineering our code”

#43
post #25

I laughed at this line where she tries to prove her point by touting that Oracle already found a bug that a security researcher reported to them (but wasn't fixed yet): "(Small digression: I was busting my buttons today when I found out that a well-known security researcher in a particular area of technology reported a bunch of alleged security issues to us except – we had already found all of them and we were alread…

heh, 'alleged'...

Re: “Stop reverse engineering our code”

#44
post #25

I laughed at this line where she tries to prove her point by touting that Oracle already found a bug that a security researcher reported to them (but wasn't fixed yet): "(Small digression: I was busting my buttons today when I found out that a well-known security researcher in a particular area of technology reported a bunch of alleged security issues to us except – we had already found all of them and we were alread…

heh, 'alleged'...

Re: “Stop reverse engineering our code”

#46
I like it that Oracle openly publishes this kind of blogs. I would personally never work for a company which expects me to develop anything using Oracle gear. It's simple. I can always find another company that doesn't and that pays the same or better. That is also why I suspect that someone who works in those circumstances really has to, because he has no other options.

Re: “Stop reverse engineering our code”

#47
post #16
post #2

Is it just me, or is the childish, mocking tone in the OP simultaneously baffling and totally befitting of the point they're trying to make? I understand that they're frustrated by the repeated submission of automated security vulnerability reports, but blanketing it entirely as "reverse engineering" and responding to it like this is... a strange approach. Did someone at Oracle actually think that this was the best w…

Yeah, it's very poorly written. I always cringe when some exec thinks "oh, it's just a blog so I don't have to write with the same professionalism and attention to detail that I would in other corporate communications".

Well, it's not even 'just a blog', it's a blog hosted by oracle.com about the author's employment at same. The standard of professionalism should be higher given the direct link, methinks. If it were a personal blog on a personal topic, it wouldn't matter as much.

Re: “Stop reverse engineering our code”

#48
post #33

Reverse engineering is legal in France for research and computer security ( http://www.legifrance.gouv.fr/affichTexte.do?cidTexte=JORFTE... ).

Sure, but this is a contract matter between two private entities. Oracle can still revoke your license for doing it.

Re: “Stop reverse engineering our code”

#50
post #10

Wow. Someone's been hitting the Kool-Aid pretty hard. I've seen this institutional hubris first-hand. The unshakable belief (typically by nontechnical management) that all of the smartest people in the world are employed here , working for me . It always ends badly.

I actually understand how it gets to be this way though.

I literally can't touch a Government project without an Oracle license. When I talk to a salesman, the attitude is "I know you can't do this without me", contrary to salesmen for any other product in any other industry.

When I talk to a project manager, they don't ask how it will be hosted, or what the platform will be, or anything else obvious. The first question, often before a project is fined, is "how many Oracle licenses can I buy?".

Post reply on HN