Live data from Hacker News

A worker fell into a nuclear reactor pool

nrc.gov

391–400 of 545 posts

Re: A worker fell into a nuclear reactor pool

#391
post #283

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I get the feeling that you don't know how complicated calculating radiation exposure is. There are plenty of interest in fear mongering against nuclear. Almost all the people talking about how much radiation 300 CPM is have absolutely no idea what they are talking about. Some confuse total measurement units for rates; others are using just the wrong units; still others are talking about levels that are 1000x or 10000…

CPM doesn't mean anything, it's useless to compare it to anything without more information. For his job, depends on the dose he took. In my country he would have been on benefits until the dose was calculated, then if possible, reintegrated in the team, or directed towards a new job if not (paid formation and everything). I've studied with a diver who couldn't work with radioactive trash anymore, he wasn't meant to b…

In a way you are right, but in another way you are wrong. Background radiation is mostly gamma which is generally the most dangerous kind. Radiation at a nuclear plant is mostly alpha and beta which are less dangerous at the same CPM rates. So technically you are right, you have to calculate the absorption, but in practice you are wrong because at that rate, there is no way he absorbed enough radiation to be dangerous.

Re: A worker fell into a nuclear reactor pool

#392
post #236

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Because of all the other physiological and mental benefits that come from the exercise that the pill won’t give you?

It might be empirically sound, but it does not make a priori sense that exercising a body will improve it. If I use almost any object in the universe frequently, it typically degrades rather than improves. The health benefits of exercise are most likely due to improved blood flow and related physiological effects. In principle, pills could theoretically achieve similar outcomes by enhancing circulation or other under…

Excessive exercise might not be healthy? No shit?

Re: A worker fell into a nuclear reactor pool

#393
post #246

Earlier quoted context omitted.

My understanding is that reactor and waste pools are some of the least radioactive environments as they are constantly monitored for leakage.

There was a video about this I saw recently. Indeed, the person said the most dangerous risk is drowning.

Hence the life vest.

Re: A worker fell into a nuclear reactor pool

#398
post #296

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What makes one qualified to make a statement? Are you qualified to make the statement I'm replying to?

In technical fields: Accredited formal education, professional certification(s), and/or recognition from other experts in the field who have the same.

How do I know you're qualified to make that statement?

Re: A worker fell into a nuclear reactor pool

#400
post #229

Earlier quoted context omitted.

dunno if the life vest bit comment of yours was sarcastic, but it is a funny remark for sure :-) it sounds like "guy felt down in a volcano, but fortunately, he had a life vest"

Wow, people are really clueless about how nuclear power plants really work. It's really not that dangerous to fall into the water.

[deleted]
Post reply on HN