Live data from Hacker News

Nvidia announces next-gen RTX 5090 and RTX 5080 GPUs

theverge.com

391–400 of 776 posts

Re: Nvidia announces next-gen RTX 5090 and RTX 5080 GPUs

#391

> will be two times faster [...] thanks to DLSS 4 Translation: No significant actual upgrade. Sounds like we're continuing the trend of newer generations being beaten on fps/$ by the previous generations while hardly pushing the envelope at the top end. A 3090 is $1000 right now.

>A 3090 is $1000 right now.

Not really worth it if you can get a 5090 for $1,999

Re: Nvidia announces next-gen RTX 5090 and RTX 5080 GPUs

#392

The increasing TDP trend is going crazy for the top-tier consumer cards: 3090 - 350W 3090 Ti - 450W 4090 - 450W 5090 - 575W 3x3090 (1050W) is less than 2x5090 (1150W), plus you get 72GB of VRAM instead of 64GB, if you can find a motherboard that supports 3 massive cards or good enough risers (apparently near impossible?).

This is the #1 reason why I haven’t upgraded my 2080 Ti. Using my laser printer while my computer is on (even if it’s idle) already makes my UPS freak out. But NVIDIA is claiming that the 5070 is equivalent to the 4090, so maybe they’re expecting you to wait a generation and get the lower card if you care about TDP? Although I suspect that equivalence only applies to gaming; probably for ML you’d still need the highe…

That’s because you have a Brother laser printer which charges its capacitors in the least graceful way possible.

Re: Nvidia announces next-gen RTX 5090 and RTX 5080 GPUs

#393

Ooo, that means its probably time for me to get a used 2080, or maybe even a 3080 if I'm feeling special

Why not go for AMD? I just got a 7900XTX for 850 euros, it runs ollama or comfyUI via WSl2 quite nicely.

AMD is an excellent choice. NVidia UI has been horrible and AMD adrenaline has been better than NVidia for several years now. With NVidia, you are paying A LOT of extra money for trickery and fake pixels, fake frames, fake (ai) rendeering. All fakeness. All hype. When you get down to the raw performance of these new cards, it must be a huge disappointment, otherwise, why would Jensen completely forget to mention anything REAL about the performance of these cards? These are cut-down cards designed to sell at cut-down prices with lots of fluff and whipped cream added on top ...

Re: Nvidia announces next-gen RTX 5090 and RTX 5080 GPUs

#394
post #209

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Nvidia (and AMD) make the "core", but they don't make a "full" graphics card. Or at least they don't mass produce them, I think Nvidia tried it with their "founders edition". It's just not their main business model, it's been that way for many many years at this point. I'm guessing business people have decided that it's not worth it. Saying that they are "resellers" isn't technically accurate. The 5080 you buy from A…

The founders edition ones that I had were not great gpus. They were both under cooled and over cooled. They had one squirrel cage style blower that was quite loud and powerful and ran bascially at no speed or full blast. But being that it only had the one airpath and one fan it got overwhelmed by dust or if that blower fan had issues the gpu over heated. The consumer / 3rd party made ones usually have multiple fans a…

Founders cards being worse than board partner models hasn't been true in like 8 years. They switched to dual axial rather than a single blower fan with the 20 series, which made the value of board partner models hard to justify.

Since then, Nvidia is locked in a very strange card war with their board partners, because Nvidia has all the juicy inside details on their own chips which they can just not give the same treatment to their partners, stacking the deck for themselves.

Also, the reason why blowers are bad is because the design can't really take advantage of a whole lot of surface area offered by the fins. There's often zero heat pipes spreading the heat evenly in all directions, allowing a hot spot to form.

Re: Nvidia announces next-gen RTX 5090 and RTX 5080 GPUs

#395
post #151

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why do you need one of those as a gamer? 1080ti was 120+ fps in heavy realistic looking games. 20xx RT slashed that back to 15 fps, but is RT really necessary to play games? Who cares about real-world reflections? And reviews showed that RT+DLSS introduced so many artefacts sometimes that the realism argument seemed absurd. Any modern card under $1000 is more than enough for graphics in virtually all games. The gamin…

Many people are running 4k resolution now, and a 4080 struggles to to break 100 frames in many current games maxed (never-mind future titles) - therefore there's plenty of a market with gamers and the 5x series (myself included) who are looking for closer to 4090 performance at a non obscene price.

This is just absolutely false, Steam says that 4.21% of users play at 4K. The number of users that play at higher than 1440p is only 10.61%. So you are wrong, simply wrong.

Re: Nvidia announces next-gen RTX 5090 and RTX 5080 GPUs

#396

The increasing TDP trend is going crazy for the top-tier consumer cards: 3090 - 350W 3090 Ti - 450W 4090 - 450W 5090 - 575W 3x3090 (1050W) is less than 2x5090 (1150W), plus you get 72GB of VRAM instead of 64GB, if you can find a motherboard that supports 3 massive cards or good enough risers (apparently near impossible?).

most household circuits can only support 15-20 amps at the plug. there will be an upper limit to this and i suspect this is nvidia compromising on TDP in the short term to move faster on compute

So you are saying that Nvidia will finally force USA to the 220V standard? :)

Re: Nvidia announces next-gen RTX 5090 and RTX 5080 GPUs

#397
post #391

> will be two times faster [...] thanks to DLSS 4 Translation: No significant actual upgrade. Sounds like we're continuing the trend of newer generations being beaten on fps/$ by the previous generations while hardly pushing the envelope at the top end. A 3090 is $1000 right now.

>A 3090 is $1000 right now. Not really worth it if you can get a 5090 for $1,999

If you can get a 5090 for that price, I'll eat my hat. scalpers with their armies of bots will buy them all before you get a chance.

Re: Nvidia announces next-gen RTX 5090 and RTX 5080 GPUs

#398

The increasing TDP trend is going crazy for the top-tier consumer cards: 3090 - 350W 3090 Ti - 450W 4090 - 450W 5090 - 575W 3x3090 (1050W) is less than 2x5090 (1150W), plus you get 72GB of VRAM instead of 64GB, if you can find a motherboard that supports 3 massive cards or good enough risers (apparently near impossible?).

I got into desktop gaming at the 970 and the common wisdom (to me at least, maybe I was silly) was I could get away with a lower wattage power supply and use it in future generations cause everything would keep getting more efficient. Hah...

I went from 970 to 3070 and it now draws less power on average. I can even lower the max power to 50% and not notice a difference for most games that I play.

Re: Nvidia announces next-gen RTX 5090 and RTX 5080 GPUs

#399
post #242
post #151

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why do you need one of those as a gamer? 1080ti was 120+ fps in heavy realistic looking games. 20xx RT slashed that back to 15 fps, but is RT really necessary to play games? Who cares about real-world reflections? And reviews showed that RT+DLSS introduced so many artefacts sometimes that the realism argument seemed absurd. Any modern card under $1000 is more than enough for graphics in virtually all games. The gamin…

I get under 50fps in certain places in FF14. I run a 5900x with 32GB of ram and a 3090.

The 3090 + 5900x is a mistake. The 5900x is 2 x 5600x CPUs. So therefore, when the games asks for 8 cores, it will get 6 good cores and 2 very slow cores across the infinity switching fabric. What's more, NVidia GPUs take MUCH MORE CPU than AMD GPUs. You should either buy an AMD GPU or upgrade/downgrade to ANYTHING OTHER THAN 5900x with 8+ cores (5800x, 5800, 5700, 5700x3d, 5950x, 5900xt, anything really ...)

Re: Nvidia announces next-gen RTX 5090 and RTX 5080 GPUs

#400

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This - latest Call of Duty game on my (albeit water cooled) 3080TI founders edition saw frame rates in the 90-100fps running natively at 4k (no DLSS).

Honestly my water cooled 3080TI FE has been great. Wish it had more VRAM for VR (DCS, MSFS) but otherwise it’s been great.

Which block did you go with? I went with the EK Vector special edition which has been great, but need to look for something else if I upgrade to 5080 with their recent woes.
Post reply on HN