Live data from Hacker News

Canada to order military plane fleet from Sweden in shift from US suppliers

theguardian.com

381–390 of 528 posts

Re: Canada to order military plane fleet from Sweden in shift from US suppliers

#381

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Great, more dead boys for nothing. As a Canadian, I think we've sacrificed enough generations for European brother wars. Given retrospect, wouldn't a land deal have been better than half a million dead? Wouldn't walking away from your house, maybe with a reparations package, be better than it being blown up by drones and your family killed? I don't think we need to go to war. We need to find a way to deal with Russia…

Agree completely. But part of that would be getting Russia to stop attempting to become a cold-war boogeyman, and stop behaving like a cold-war boogeyman. Russia also signed that treaty, and is also blatantly breaking it.

[flagged]

Re: Canada to order military plane fleet from Sweden in shift from US suppliers

#382

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Being a U.S. ally no longer guarantees that you will be protected by the U.S. as Ukraine is seeing. How much more is the US supposed to do in Ukraine beyond the $60-70 billion in weapons and supplies? Do we need to actually go to war with Russia?

New Ukraine aid effectively ended with the current administration, if you were unaware

[flagged]

Re: Canada to order military plane fleet from Sweden in shift from US suppliers

#383

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Do we need to actually go to war with Russia? Yes. That's what everyone signed up to [0] when Ukraine gave up its Soviet-era nukes. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Budapest_Memorandum

Great, more dead boys for nothing. As a Canadian, I think we've sacrificed enough generations for European brother wars. Given retrospect, wouldn't a land deal have been better than half a million dead? Wouldn't walking away from your house, maybe with a reparations package, be better than it being blown up by drones and your family killed? I don't think we need to go to war. We need to find a way to deal with Russia…

> We need to find a way to deal with Russia with humanity instead of treating them like some boomer-era cold war bogeyman.

We tried that in the 90s. Didn't work. Made things worse, really.

Re: Canada to order military plane fleet from Sweden in shift from US suppliers

#384

This is actually more likely a non-political procurement decision that looks like a political one. This is the 'right size' for Canada and other nations - the US doesn't offer a true comparable, and, looks like the US balked at buying the 'kind of comparable' Boeing E7 putting it in jeopardy. With European military renaissance and the SAAB gear proving itself in Ukraine ... well, you see the shift. This is the shift…

In the past countries would buy American equipment even if it wasn’t the best fit because that would make you essentially an American ally. Being part of the U.S. ecosystem was valuable. Unfortunately, over the last 1.5 years, the political value proposition has turned by 180 degrees. - Being a U.S. ally no longer guarantees that you will be protected by the U.S. as Ukraine is seeing. But the U.S. has been tearing ag…

>Being a U.S. ally no longer guarantees that you will be protected by the U.S. as Ukraine is seeing.

The US never promised to protect Ukraine. It's often claimed that the Budapest Memorandum was a promise from the US to protect Ukraine, but this is misinformation. Read the memorandum for yourself if you don't believe me, it's not very long:

https://treaties.un.org/doc/Publication/UNTS/Volume%203007/P...

Re: Canada to order military plane fleet from Sweden in shift from US suppliers

#385
post #375

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Land deal? Russia has never asked for a land deal. They started the war and their goal has always been the total destruction of Ukraine and the enslavement of the people. Where they’ve pulled back from occupied areas they’ve mass civilian graves and bodies with signs of torture.

Stop spreading propaganda. - Ukrainians are the second largest ethnicity in Russia. - The majority of people living on a currently contested territories of Ukraine used to be USSR citizens. - Russia got the majority of Ukrainian refugees since the start of a war if we count per country. - Pretty much all the former Ukraine citizens got Russian passports and a citizens of Russia now. - And yes, if Ukraine is using cit…

> - Ukrainians are the second largest ethnicity in Russia.

No. Never was. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ethnic_groups_in_Russia

> - Russia got the majority of Ukrainian refugees since the start of a war if we count per country.

No. https://www.statista.com/statistics/1312584/ukrainian-refuge...

You might be confusing abductees with refugees.

> - The majority of people living on a currently contested territories of Ukraine used to be USSR citizens.

The majority of people living on contested territories of United States in 1775 used to be British citizens. So?

> - And yes, if Ukraine is using cities as fortresses and do not evacuate civilians from there, high chances are that after weeks and months long battles those civilians end up in graves with nasty wounds on their bodies.

Absolutely vile propaganda.

Re: Canada to order military plane fleet from Sweden in shift from US suppliers

#386

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Being a U.S. ally no longer guarantees that you will be protected by the U.S. as Ukraine is seeing. How much more is the US supposed to do in Ukraine beyond the $60-70 billion in weapons and supplies? Do we need to actually go to war with Russia?

> Do we need to actually go to war with Russia? Yes. That's what everyone signed up to [0] when Ukraine gave up its Soviet-era nukes. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Budapest_Memorandum

If you read the memorandum text, at most the US promised to go to the UN security council if Ukraine's territorial integrity was threatened.

https://treaties.un.org/doc/Publication/UNTS/Volume%203007/P...

There is a lot of misinformation floating around the internet about this memorandum.

Furthermore, even Wikipedia states: "The Budapest Memorandum is not a treaty, and it does not confer any new legal obligations for signatory states. It was written in a way to avoid an impression of legal obligation."

Re: Canada to order military plane fleet from Sweden in shift from US suppliers

#387

This is actually more likely a non-political procurement decision that looks like a political one. This is the 'right size' for Canada and other nations - the US doesn't offer a true comparable, and, looks like the US balked at buying the 'kind of comparable' Boeing E7 putting it in jeopardy. With European military renaissance and the SAAB gear proving itself in Ukraine ... well, you see the shift. This is the shift…

In the past countries would buy American equipment even if it wasn’t the best fit because that would make you essentially an American ally. Being part of the U.S. ecosystem was valuable. Unfortunately, over the last 1.5 years, the political value proposition has turned by 180 degrees. - Being a U.S. ally no longer guarantees that you will be protected by the U.S. as Ukraine is seeing. But the U.S. has been tearing ag…

This is 100% true and I agree with all of it, but I would just add that for fighter jets specifically the calculus is a bit different.

Unless you want to buy Chinese jets your choices are either F35s or a big step down to 4th generation fighters that are materially worse in terms of capability.

Modern 4th gen fighters are still very capable, cheaper, simpler and more reliable, but if you ever do end up facing an adversary who has 5th gen fighters you'll be in trouble, so the trade off of choosing not to buy F35s is very real

Re: Canada to order military plane fleet from Sweden in shift from US suppliers

#388
post #320

Earlier quoted context omitted.

And speech was from 1yr ago. The view has probably not improved since ?

Here's a video from this year from a French General that is more up to date on the current vibes https://www.youtube.com/shorts/XQJ5YEsNQws And for some more data than anecdote, the current polling where the US is now 14 points behind China in net approval. https://news.gallup.com/poll/707945/china-edges-past-global-...

Eh, the US was also hated in Europe as Biden was sending lots of money to Ukraine in the wake of Russia's invasion:

https://www.pewresearch.org/global/2024/06/11/views-of-the-u...

You can see even with Biden as president, around half of Europe's population regarded the US unfavorably. This was at a time when the US was sending more aid per capita than almost all European countries:

https://old.reddit.com/r/europe/comments/1hd7aud/military_ai...

There's no point in trying to please these people. They'll accuse the US of warmongering one year, then demand that the US help them fight a war the next year.

Re: Canada to order military plane fleet from Sweden in shift from US suppliers

#389

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The point is that focusing on a rare us supply chain obscures the bigger picture.

It sounds like you're obscuring the point by muddying the water here.

I don't understand either of your points tbh

Re: Canada to order military plane fleet from Sweden in shift from US suppliers

#390
post #375

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Land deal? Russia has never asked for a land deal. They started the war and their goal has always been the total destruction of Ukraine and the enslavement of the people. Where they’ve pulled back from occupied areas they’ve mass civilian graves and bodies with signs of torture.

Stop spreading propaganda. - Ukrainians are the second largest ethnicity in Russia. - The majority of people living on a currently contested territories of Ukraine used to be USSR citizens. - Russia got the majority of Ukrainian refugees since the start of a war if we count per country. - Pretty much all the former Ukraine citizens got Russian passports and a citizens of Russia now. - And yes, if Ukraine is using cit…

And literally none of this matters and it's a laundry list of loser russian propaganda

Funny how those reasons don't matter in the least when it's time for russian losers to bomb civilians in Kyiv

Post reply on HN