Live data from Hacker News

PC Gamer recommends RSS readers in a 37mb article that just keeps downloading

stuartbreckenridge.net

381–390 of 417 posts

Re: PC Gamer recommends RSS readers in a 37mb article that just keeps downloading

#381

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is an easy fix: Just cut off their data after it runs out instead of falling back to 2G speeds. Sounds like a win-win for both the data provider and the user.

I hope you're joking. The obvious easy fix is to give them unlimited data. If the intent is to give them internet, they should give them internet that functions for the modern web.

Publicly provided wifi would also help them and everyone. But of course, guess who's fighting real hard against that...

Re: PC Gamer recommends RSS readers in a 37mb article that just keeps downloading

#382

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Nobody is turning off ad blockers.

Exactly we don't, and what's worse is that the "content" is getting to the point where we need _content_ blockers. I recently got hit by an "article" that promised to tell me which three AAA games would be released with PS Plus soon. A three point bullet list was all I wanted. Instead I got pages after pages of word-manure about nothing at all for reasons I don't even understand. At the end of it I still couldn't tel…

The PS Plus One is a gaming console or something to that effect. “But Henriette,” my grandmother asked, “which AAA titles will be released for Xbox”?

My grandmother is a gamer. But a bit senile. She had her formative gaming years on the XBox, you see. What she actually meant to ask was: which titles for the PS Plus One?

My dad too has been asking me that question. Or he did until he tragically died in a car accident last week.

So which AAA games will be released for PS Plus One soon or soon-ish?

I really had to ponder that question while driving my Tesla Cybertruck to the gas station. Indeed, which games are that? It’s on everyone’s lips or mouth.

Which brings us to this article. You have been wondering the same thing, haven’t you? If so you are in good company, like that of my beloved grandmother and dear departed father.

Sony says that they will reveal which three AAA titles will be released for PS Plus One in the fourth quarter of 2027.

Re: PC Gamer recommends RSS readers in a 37mb article that just keeps downloading

#383

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I hope you're joking. The obvious easy fix is to give them unlimited data. If the intent is to give them internet, they should give them internet that functions for the modern web.

Publicly provided wifi would also help them and everyone. But of course, guess who's fighting real hard against that...

[flagged]

Re: PC Gamer recommends RSS readers in a 37mb article that just keeps downloading

#386
I tried subscribing to pcgamer ( as in, I literally paid for it ) two years ago but this didn’t seem to change structurally the amount of ads i was getting. I also tried to contact them directly but couldn’t find a relevant email address to reach out to.

I now use an ad blocker instead. I’m not proud of it, but being actively hostile to me is something I don’t quite understand especially when I’m trying hard to give them money.

Re: PC Gamer recommends RSS readers in a 37mb article that just keeps downloading

#387
post #360

Earlier quoted context omitted.

[flagged]

> Who are you to decide which are the most important? The customer.

Um, no. You are one customer, out of thousands (or tens of thousands). You do not get to speak for anyone except yourself.

Re: PC Gamer recommends RSS readers in a 37mb article that just keeps downloading

#388

Earlier quoted context omitted.

[flagged]

>The actual reason why companies (and even personal and open-source software projects) make these "wasteful" design decisions is because normal users have clearly indicated their priorities. You really think it's the users asking for bloated webpages? Reddit has been pushing their reddit redesign forever now. No users ever asked for it. There is a large community of users that insist on using the old.reddit interface…

> You really think it's the users asking for bloated webpages?

> It's not users clamoring for more bloated websites, it's marketing folks.

You clearly didn't read my comment before responding, because I very clearly made the point that it's not about users wanting worse performance, but a matter of relative priority. Suggest reading before responding.

> Reddit has been pushing their reddit redesign forever now. No users ever asked for it. There is a large community of users that insist on using the old.reddit interface, and reddit has been chipping away by slowly breaking more and more things (most recently, the mod page).

And yet, clearly enough people are getting enough value from the site that it's worth the bloat to them, otherwise Reddit would have reversed the redesign years ago. I also know multiple people who voluntarily use the redesign while being aware of the classic interface.

So, you're literally proving my point.

Re: PC Gamer recommends RSS readers in a 37mb article that just keeps downloading

#389

Earlier quoted context omitted.

[flagged]

>would be able to make a lot of money doing so. That’s precisely the elephant in the room. Money is a distortion and filtering lense that makes obvious things look inexistent until the wall it renders invisible is hit — at high the highest speed it could reach before that. Reality is extremely poorly summarized within the frame of a single scalar value. >And if you think that "they don't know what's best for them, bu…

> That’s precisely the elephant in the room. Money is a distortion and filtering lense

No, money is the most accurate way of measuring value to people that has ever been invented. It quite literally is the least distorted lens you can possibly get. Every single other metric is worse. Aren't you aware of the well-known scientific truism that it's impossible to directly perceive reality, and that all of the indirect methods that we have are imperfect? This is the economic corollary to that.

> Reality is extremely poorly summarized within the frame of a single scalar value.

Correct. Yet, every sane and reasonably well-educated person knows that money is the least bad single scalar value (that also happens to strongly correlate with businesses remaining solvent and individuals remaining off the streets) that can be used to measure value delivered to individuals, and that there's no alternative scalar value or combination of values that's anywhere close to as well agreed-upon as money.

Everything else in your comment is incoherent. "First of all, there no necessity to go into a you/I or them/us mindset." doesn't mean anything.

Re: PC Gamer recommends RSS readers in a 37mb article that just keeps downloading

#390

Earlier quoted context omitted.

[flagged]

How are users choosing this stuff? Do you have an example of two competing services offering the same features, one bloated and one not, and users locked to the bloated one? To my mind users are simply using what’s put in front of them. They lack the technical knowledge to know better things are possible and even if they did they don’t have any way to advocate for it. Over half of US users use an ad blocker: https://…

> How are users choosing this stuff?

Through the platforms they choose to use. Coarse and inefficient and frustrating? Yes. Effective at demonstrating mass preferences and thereby imposing those preferences on platforms? Also yes.

> That alone suggests to me that when given a choice users actually do care.

Using an ad-blocker is obviously extremely different than what I'm describing here.

An ad-blocker is a composable feature that you can graft onto any particular market.

What I'm describing is a relative prioritization among different features, where one has to rank what they truly value, and sacrifice some of the lower-ranked things for the higher-ranked ones. That's categorically different than just being able to flip a switch and turn off ads and save bandwidth with negligible downside.

> Do you have an example of two competing services offering the same features, one bloated and one not, and users locked to the bloated one?

This is irrelevant - see above comment about relative prioritization. Features are one of the "dozens of things to optimize for in software development" that I mentioned above. I can point to many platforms where the bloated ones are winning - because they have the features that users want, and they value those more highly. That's my whole point.

Post reply on HN