Live data from Hacker News

Cloudflare Email Service: private beta

blog.cloudflare.com

381–390 of 578 posts

Re: Cloudflare Email Service: private beta

#381

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>> Currently it's up to Cloudflare to decide whether you will read that article or not. How is Cloudflare gatekeeping things? I believe you but don't understand the mechanism.

Cloudflare sends certain users they think are bots into infinite captcha loops - the wrong user agent or tor endpoint can do it

I assume this is only on sites that are on Cloudflare though. Or, no?

Re: Cloudflare Email Service: private beta

#382

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Cloudflare sends certain users they think are bots into infinite captcha loops - the wrong user agent or tor endpoint can do it

I assume this is only on sites that are on Cloudflare though. Or, no?

True, but a lot of sites use Cloudflare. It's sometimes very unexpected sites as well, both very large ones and very small ones.

Re: Cloudflare Email Service: private beta

#383

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I’ve never understood the evil MITM endgame here. Cloudflare’s ToS and contracts prevent them from doing nastiness with your data without breach, and approximately all their revenue comes from large enterprises that will leave in droves (and some will actually sue them) if they started exploiting it. The thing where they let DDoSers use them to protect their public sites from rival DDoSers is sketchy as hell, but doe…

> Cloudflare's ToS and contracts prevent them from doing nastiness with your data without breach ... Contracts can be and regularly are changed. Ebay, PayPal, Etsy, Google, Microsoft, ad nauseum all have done this many times. Contract-based protections mean very little if those clauses are non-perpetual and revokable.

Changed by informing in advance. If they change it to scrape your data to sell it to advertisers or someone, drop their service.

Re: Cloudflare Email Service: private beta

#384
post #265

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How is this not a problem with the law rather than a problem with Cloudflare?

Because human nature is what it is. The best way to eat better isn't to be a better person, it's to not keep junk food at the house. It's not Cloudflare's fault that they're successful, but it's now everyone's problem that they're an easy throat for governments to choke.

It is their fault they are successful. They worked hard to get there.

Re: Cloudflare Email Service: private beta

#385

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Cloudflare's ToS and contracts prevent them from doing nastiness with your data without breach ... Contracts can be and regularly are changed. Ebay, PayPal, Etsy, Google, Microsoft, ad nauseum all have done this many times. Contract-based protections mean very little if those clauses are non-perpetual and revokable.

Changed by informing in advance. If they change it to scrape your data to sell it to advertisers or someone, drop their service.

Easier said than done, vendor lock-in is costly to move from.

Re: Cloudflare Email Service: private beta

#386
post #337

Earlier quoted context omitted.

wget isn't supposed to work on these sites. They've chosen Cloudflare and asked them to do this.

That’s exactly the part that people forget: all these policies are decided to be applied by the website owners. It started with DDoS blocking and they just extended it to more things. I feel like people here are forgetting the fact just how hostile bad actors on the internet are / can be.

That brings up opt-in vs opt-out tho, and last time I looked, Cloudflare defaulted to automatically signing website owners for it. That is to say, if you just mash next, Cloudflare blocks "AI", whatever that means.

Re: Cloudflare Email Service: private beta

#387

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> the internet was worse without Cloudflare It had much more freedom. Currently it's up to Cloudflare to decide whether you will read that article or not. Tomorrow some stupid law will mandate certain ideas to be hidden from children[1] and Cloudflare will happily comply. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Think_of_the_children

How is this not a problem with the law rather than a problem with Cloudflare?

Also, remember that time that Cloudflare didn't take down a Nazi website because they didn't want to be arbiters of the internet but then everyone accused Cloudflare of supporting Neo Nazis. That this led to boycotts so they ended up taking down the site and wrote a blog post being like "fine, but this is dumb"

That didn't really have to do with the law. You could segue it was a free market action. Though there were definitely legal threats as well. (There's even people here in this thread making similar claims of Cloudflare supporting specific groups/content)

https://blog.cloudflare.com/why-we-terminated-daily-stormer/

Re: Cloudflare Email Service: private beta

#388

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Cloudflare's ToS and contracts prevent them from doing nastiness with your data without breach ... Contracts can be and regularly are changed. Ebay, PayPal, Etsy, Google, Microsoft, ad nauseum all have done this many times. Contract-based protections mean very little if those clauses are non-perpetual and revokable.

Changed by informing in advance. If they change it to scrape your data to sell it to advertisers or someone, drop their service.

As rumbefrog said, not exactly an option if they're the biggest/only game in town or if no one else has a feature you absolutely rely on.

Re: Cloudflare Email Service: private beta

#389
post #4

Eventually all Internet protocols will be MITMed by cloudflare. Your single point of interception!

Yes, but also you can't send an email in any meaningful way on the internet without going through a middleman anyways so while philosophically you're correct, in reality it's already the case.

I don't think that is true for email or xmpp. Could you please explain?

Re: Cloudflare Email Service: private beta

#390

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> However, I guess they have become the major player now and certainly try to optimize the world towards their business model. I don't think that's it, and I think the explanation is much more simple and straight-forward. Cloudflare established a very successful business model around a straight-forward, very transparent, no-bullshit CDN. Now, they started offering other cloud services build around their CDN. Cloudfla…

Much of their model and success was by giving away a lot of service for free. I'm not discounting their innovations but had they not been VC funded and given away free service I suspect many would still never have heard of them.

> had they not been VC funded and given away free service I suspect many would still never have heard of them.

What does this purity test accomplish? that's just how things work in this industry. Can you name a company that has innovated on their scale that hasn't taken VC?

Post reply on HN