Live data from Hacker News

Why our website looks like an operating system

posthog.com

381–390 of 504 posts

Re: Why our website looks like an operating system

#381
I vaguely recall the posthog website in the past. I remember thinking it looked really cool. Disappointed by this change.

EDIT: Oh, I see. They just released it. It was the older version 2 days ago (September 10) https://web.archive.org/web/20250910142406/https://posthog.c...

Re: Why our website looks like an operating system

#383

Oh god. It has a pleasant color scheme, but this is an awful idea. By trying to recreate windows and bookmarks in the web app you're at best just implementing redundant features and getting in the way of the native browser features by trying to showcase yours, at worst breaking regular web usage entirely. Take their right click menu for items to select whether you want an in-app tab or real browser tab. Congrats, you…

I find it incredibly funny that this company has re-invented the horrid "nested window" UX of Windows 3.1, 30-something years after the fact.

Re: Why our website looks like an operating system

#384
post #149

Why this feels so incredibly appealing compared to prevailing designs is probably something for a psychologist / cognitive scientist / neurologist (?) to answer -- there is certainly something here that warrants better study than what we in the software industry do in rushed blog posts. But I can personally speak to at least one aspect, having worked for a company that does high end web sites and strategy for large S…

>probably something for a psychologist / cognitive scientist / neurologist (?) to answer -- there is certainly something here that warrants better study than what we in the software industry do in rushed blog posts Very little here that isn't explained by age-old HCI concepts on design. >And one of the conclusions may be that our current UI/UX philosophy has inadvertantly become user-hostile Nope. You see the "X" sta…

I don't think Don Norman would like this at all based on his rules for good web design. (someone should ask him fhough)

The top level comment is confusing marketing success with UI/UX success: it tickles their brain because they're the target audience. To everyone else this is weird and overwhelming if you're looking for something and suddenly run into it.

Might still be fun/whimsical if you're not looking for something and just stumble upon it, or get shown that

Re: Why our website looks like an operating system

#386

Usability and perf experience for me: - I'm getting about 5 FPS scrolling on a M4 Pro - Moving a "window" around takes 29% of my CPU, and renders at about 2 fps - I'm losing about 40% of my screen height for reading (14" laptop screen). So much so none of the article is visible above the fold, just the title and by-line. - My browser's CMD-F finds things on layers hidden under the current window - Changing window siz…

The blog post mentions some things use a spreadsheet. So I clicked the link.

It opened a change log. It took about 5 seconds to get to 94%. Then about 20 seconds to load.

There are about 40 items.

Re: Why our website looks like an operating system

#387
post #219

Almost perfect. Inspirational. It just needed to create a little box you can drag around when you click on nothing, like OS desktops have. So here's the snippet to do that, toss this in the console and live the dream: (() => { let startX, startY, box, dragging = false; const style = document.createElement('style'); style.textContent = ` .___selection-box { position: absolute; pointer-events: none; border: 1px dashed…

Did you write this yourself?

Re: Why our website looks like an operating system

#388

Oh god. It has a pleasant color scheme, but this is an awful idea. By trying to recreate windows and bookmarks in the web app you're at best just implementing redundant features and getting in the way of the native browser features by trying to showcase yours, at worst breaking regular web usage entirely. Take their right click menu for items to select whether you want an in-app tab or real browser tab. Congrats, you…

I really admire Posthog as a company and how they run things there. Big fan. But let's be honest. This website redesign, even though cool and unique, wouldn't work if they were an unknown brand. I think they have done a great job building a solid brand over the years and now have the freedom to update their website however they want.

If you are a no name startup, doing something like this will be a bad idea. My 2 cents.

Re: Why our website looks like an operating system

#389

Usability and perf experience for me: - I'm getting about 5 FPS scrolling on a M4 Pro - Moving a "window" around takes 29% of my CPU, and renders at about 2 fps - I'm losing about 40% of my screen height for reading (14" laptop screen). So much so none of the article is visible above the fold, just the title and by-line. - My browser's CMD-F finds things on layers hidden under the current window - Changing window siz…

No FPS or CPU issues on my M3, it's all very smooth.

Same slow spreadsheet load as sibling, but that seems like a backend issue.

Post reply on HN