Live data from Hacker News

Hire people who aren’t proven

leonardofed.io

381–390 of 460 posts

Re: Hire people who aren’t proven

#381
post #25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That's a great way of putting it. "Choose your battles" in other words. I look back and I can remember getting very wound up about some things that just didn't matter . And, today, I shake my head a little bit at people for whom every single little thing is something to man the barricades over.

I remember a job as a junior programmer: typical 90’s era C++ Windows application. Compiling it with compiler defaults would spew out a continuous stream of thousands of warnings. This was before unit tests and static analysis were in vogue, so random crashes and errors everywhere. Major performance problems. I argued for code hygiene, fix all these crashes, figure out what’s behind the compiler warnings, etc. The re…

> I started fantasizing that the company would crash and burn, and I would be standing there among the rubble...

Have you had a part in writing Office Space [0] screenplay? It's Milton's wish.

[0] https://m.imdb.com/title/tt0151804/

Re: Hire people who aren’t proven

#382
post #6

I think hiring has become more difficult now that programming has been discovered as a well paying mainstream career. When I started in the 90s most people I worked with had a passion for the craft but now I find we interview a lot of people who have a CS degree just for the career prospects but not out of interest for the craft. I find it much easier to deal with someone who has no relevant experience but cares vs s…

One popular idea is that programmers should be passionate and spend their spare time working on open source. Another career with a reputation as a stable well-paid job is law.

In law, pro-bono work is at least somewhat similar to open source work for programmers: It doesn’t directly make money, is considered morally good, and possibly a way to widen one’s experience. However in law, lawyers in a firm are typically required to spend a certain amount of time doing pro-bono work (during working hours) whereas the same does not happen with programming.

Re: Hire people who aren’t proven

#383

The problem that has happened at my company is that we take a "chance" on bootcampers or other people who aren't proven, we spend the time and effort to mentor and train them, pay them well, and then they turn around in 9-12 months and leave us for another company with their enhanced experience. It has happened 3 times so far, so we have stopped hiring bootcampers, and fresh grads and instead have started hiring peop…

Conversely, I found it really hard to establish myself as a solid contributor and even a technical leader when I joined a team as a (relatively) newly minted developer. No matter how far I progressed, or how competent (even excellent) I became, I was still perceived as the "kid", even though my colleagues are only a few years older. I think I've mostly overcome this, but TBH I'm still not certain and I've been here f…

What diminoten said

Re: Hire people who aren’t proven

#384

I have run into some of these issues in the past when trying to get into software. I'm a chemical engineer / scientist with some programming experience/skill* but I would suck at modern coding interviews because I don't program regularly in my past 3-4 roles. I would have to get up to speed on the job, with pre-prep before the job started, and I could develop into an awesome programmer. Most job posting are written s…

Job mobility is at an all time low unfortunately, due to the incredibly risk-averse environment.

Re: Hire people who aren’t proven

#385

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I translate this as wanting a candidate that is compliant and can remove his ego to work in a hierarchal management structure. This is fine, of course, but let's not confuse that as "getting along" or "culture fit" when it's really "following orders".

We have taken out any mention of "culture fit" which to me means more of the same. Instead, we measure culture addition. How will this person add to our culture?

I love this. Such a better way of framing the situation. Thank you.

Re: Hire people who aren’t proven

#386
post #359

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What about shadowing a doctor in high school? You literally follow them around all day and get a taste of what they do.

The thing is, the salient bits of being a doctor have to do with the thought process going on in their head, the stresses of responsibility and decision-making, and all the considerations they weigh with each patient. It's just not an "observable" thing. Docs don't really start sharing their internal processes with you until you're in the second half of med school, and even then not commonly. From the outside, it jus…

Thank you for the eye opening insight, my significant other was accepted to med school in the states and she/we are double minded on her pursuing the field of medicine due to the dismal work life balance you mentioned, considering she has a science masters and works a 9-5 in medical research. She didn't have the undergraduate grades and did masters + high MCAT score to finally get in at 30 years old.

Given the current state of medicine in the states, you touched upon the topic of insurance companies. The endless paperwork seems to be a side effect of physicians being beholden to insurance companies to supply a steady stream of patients that afford an income that will offset the steep debt and decades of opportunity cost spent in school. This seems unique to America from what I can tell and is only getting worse, along with what I'm told regarding physicians (MD/DO) competing with nurse practioners and physician assistant, government oversight, etc over area of practice.

Finally, the topic of burnout and physician abuse (lack of sleep, working overtime and being on call), is truly disgusting. This was a tough read, previously posted on HN: https://ericlevi.com/2017/05/13/the-dark-side-of-doctoring/

I sincerely hope you and all overworked physicians take care of mental health and avoid burnout. I think private practice and limited hours for certain lower specialties might be the answer for my significant other if we plan on starting a family anytime soon.

Re: Hire people who aren’t proven

#387
post #272

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> become a doctor for the love of taking care of people that are sick and help them overcome a bad situation That’s the fantasy. And, hey, when it pops up, awesome - it’s a very energizing moment. However, most medicine has absolutely nothing to do with that day to day. The day to day is subject to Pareto’s Law. A surgeon may occasionally get to “take care of the sick,” but 80% of the time they get to do a five minut…

One likely won't get that good at surgery unless they practiced a lot. And if they had no interest towards that profession they likely won't be putting in crazy hours in their prime early career time becoming a surgeon. You can't even become good at flipping burgers without being interested in doing it.

"Interest" is not "love" or "passion". Anyone using the latter terms as synonyms for the former is seriously diluting their meaning.

Re: Hire people who aren’t proven

#388

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You can absolutely become a doctor for the love of taking care of people that are sick and help them overcome a bad situation. Many of my friends displayed a caring side very early on (middle school).

> become a doctor for the love of taking care of people that are sick and help them overcome a bad situation That’s the fantasy. And, hey, when it pops up, awesome - it’s a very energizing moment. However, most medicine has absolutely nothing to do with that day to day. The day to day is subject to Pareto’s Law. A surgeon may occasionally get to “take care of the sick,” but 80% of the time they get to do a five minut…

Im confused. All those small day to day technical things you described are opportunities to help and care about sick people. On the otherside of the chart is someone in pain. Its maybe not House, but it will make a huge difference in their life. If I was hiring a doctor, I'd want the person that understood that.

Re: Hire people who aren’t proven

#389

Lately what I have been trying out is telling people: if you want to come for an interview can you prepare a small presentation of one of the data structures that you know about or like, or ideally hash tables (as they cover wide range of topics). If a person than comes in for the interview in about a week from when he is told this and can’t present that DS to some depth I don’t bother to go on with much longer inter…

I'd love to come into an interview prepared rather than wonder which of a hundred topics they might be focused on this second.

The first situation I can control, the second is losing the lottery.

Post reply on HN