Live data from Hacker News

Chrome is looking to permanently drop MV2 extension

neowin.net

371–380 of 480 posts

Re: Chrome is looking to permanently drop MV2 extension

#371

I expected some kind of fallout from Google nuking uBo. I've heard pretty much nothing so far.

I'm only one person but that was the straw that broke the camels back for me. I no longer use any google software/services other than gmail and even that is just a spam folder at this point.

That change came after Google's changes around MV3 were released. I actively campaign against using Google anything at my job as well.

Re: Chrome is looking to permanently drop MV2 extension

#372

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The author of both appears to disagree.

His opinion is irrelevant. User experience is all that matters. As a developer I've often built "inferior" versions of products for specific user groups. The product worked perfectly for those users, they saw no difference. Yet, when asked, I'd maintain that it's inferior because . And you know what? We are both right.

The author of both extensions stated facts of user experience.[1] This included some users would not notice a difference.

[1] https://github.com/uBlockOrigin/uBOL-home/wiki/Frequently-as...

Re: Chrome is looking to permanently drop MV2 extension

#373

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Most of the extensions for Firefox say that. For some reason even 7TV has that badge.

for good reason. it's a serious security risk.

All arbitrary Javascript is a "serious security risk" if you're reductive enough.

Re: Chrome is looking to permanently drop MV2 extension

#374

uBlock Origin Lite works just as well. I don't see any ads anywhere. My experience has not changed one yota. People just like to rage against Google. https://chromewebstore.google.com/detail/ublock-origin-lite/... It's even available on iOS, I have it running in Safari

uBlock Origin Lite's author disagreed.[1]

[1] https://github.com/uBlockOrigin/uBOL-home/wiki/Frequently-as...

Re: Chrome is looking to permanently drop MV2 extension

#375

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The author of both appears to disagree.

His opinion is irrelevant. User experience is all that matters. As a developer I've often built "inferior" versions of products for specific user groups. The product worked perfectly for those users, they saw no difference. Yet, when asked, I'd maintain that it's inferior because . And you know what? We are both right.

You are saying that the author's opinion doesn't matter your singular experience is the only reasonable benchmark which seems less defensible. For practical quality we should also consider future resistance against anti adblocking something that the author is able to do unlike a user who just notices it hasn't failed yet.

Consider manifest v3 has a fixed block list that can only be updated with the extension and only with permission of the browser.

Re: Chrome is looking to permanently drop MV2 extension

#376
post #208

Good! Give everyone the push they need to break the web homogeny of Chrome everywhere. I'm tired of all the (mostly technical) people whining that they need Chrome, and only Chrome can browse the internet. Then you ask them for a site that doesn't work and conveniently "it was some time back and I don't remember the details". I've been using FF since before it was called Firefox. In the last 10 years I've not come ac…

I now daily drive firefox, there are unfortunately plently of broken sites. Nebula's video player is broken in widescreen for example.

Nope, literally used it last night. No problems.

Re: Chrome is looking to permanently drop MV2 extension

#377
post #281

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Such as?

accuweather.com was the biggest one, though it looks like they fixed it sometime in the last month.

I used accuweather.com in Firefox a bunch a decade ago. Did not have problems.

Re: Chrome is looking to permanently drop MV2 extension

#378

I expected some kind of fallout from Google nuking uBo. I've heard pretty much nothing so far.

I'm only one person but that was the straw that broke the camels back for me. I no longer use any google software/services other than gmail and even that is just a spam folder at this point. That change came after Google's changes around MV3 were released. I actively campaign against using Google anything at my job as well.

Yep the MV3 thing was my ticket out also here. And some benchmarks about firefox better memory usage. All their parlance about they "protecting us" is patronizing.

Re: Chrome is looking to permanently drop MV2 extension

#379

PM of Orion here. Orion ( https://orionbrowser.com ) is a WebKit-based browser for Mac, Linux, iPadOS and iOS that supports both Chrome and Firefox extensions natively ⟩ including uBlock Origin. We have no plans to drop extension support. Content blocking is a feature, not a loophole, and we think users should have full control over what runs in their browser.

Happy Kagi customer here—I wish Orion was available on Android.
Post reply on HN