Live data from Hacker News

OpenClaw is changing my life

reorx.com

371–380 of 537 posts

Re: OpenClaw is changing my life

#371

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Maybe it is language specific? Maybe LLMs have a lot of good JavaScript/TypeScript samples for training and it works for those devs (e.g. me). I heard that Scala devs have problems with LLMs writing code too. I am puzzled by good devs not managing to get LLM work for them.

I think LLMs have a hard time with large code bases (obviously so do devs). A giant monorepo would be a bad fit for an LLM IMO.

With agentic search, they actually do pretty well with monorepos.

Re: OpenClaw is changing my life

#372
It is a really impressive tool, but I just can’t trust it to oversee production code.

Regardless of how you isolate the OpenClaw instance (Mac Mini, VPS, whatever) - if it’s allowed to browse the web for answers then there’s the very real risk of prompt injection inserting malicious code into the project.

If you are personally reviewing every line of code that it generates you can mitigate that, but I’d wager none of these “super manager” users are doing that.

Re: OpenClaw is changing my life

#373
post #9

This is quite a low quality post. There is nothing of substance here. Just hot air. The only software I've seen designed and implemented by OpenClaw is moltbook. And I think it is hard to come up with a bigger pile of crap than Moltbook. If somebody can build something decent with OpenClaw, that would help add some credibility to the OpenClaw story.

Given that the authors previous post was about how the Rabbit R1 has “the potential to change the world”, I don’t expect much in the way of critical assessment here.

Oh, wow, totally forgot about that. I kind of miss the brief period when there was a new absurd LLM-based gadget every week or so (actually, I think they are still coming out; there were some at CES. But everyone has largely lost interest).

Re: OpenClaw is changing my life

#375
post #153

Besides that blog post obviously being written by AI, can someone here confirm how credible the hype about openclaw is? I'm already very proficient at using Claude Code anywhere, so what would i gain really with openclaw?

I played with it extensively for three days. I think there are a few things it does that people are finding interesting: 1. It has a lot of files that it loads into it's context for each conversation, and it consistently updates them. Plus it stores and can reference each conversation. So there's a sense of continuity over time. 2. It connects to messaging services and other accounts of yours, so again it feels conti…

> You could send it a voice message over discord and say "hey remember that conversation about birds? Send an email to Steve and ask him what he thinks about it"

Ah, so it's a device for irritating Steve, got it.

Re: OpenClaw is changing my life

#376

There's an odd trend with these sorts of posts where the author claims to have had some transformative change in their workflow brought upon by LLM coding tools, but also seemingly has nothing to show for it. To me, using the most recent ChatGPT Codex (5.3 on "Extra High" reasoning), it's incredibly obvious that while these tools are surprisingly good at doing repetitive or locally-scoped tasks, they immediately fall…

Completely agree. However I do get some productivity boost by using ChatGPT as an improved Google search able to customize the answer to what I need.

Re: OpenClaw is changing my life

#377

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Quite literally, the previous post on this blog is from 2024 talking about what a revolution the Rabbit R1 is. We all know how that turned out. This is why I give every new trendy developer tool a few months to see if it’s really a good thing or just hype.

The jokes write themselves. Now you can have both, Openclaw comes preloaded on the R1. https://www.rabbit.tech/rabbit-r1

Wait, the R1 still exists? Frankly, I had assumed they'd gone under.

Re: OpenClaw is changing my life

#378

Since many posts mention lack of substance, providing a link to the All-In Podcast from last week in which they discuss Clawdbot (prior to re-brand). https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gXY1kx7zlkk&t=2754s For the impatient, here's a transcript summary (from Gemini): The speaker describes creating a "virtual employee" (dubbed a "replicant") running on a local server with unrestricted, authenticated access to a real produ…

I mean... If Jason Calacanis told me the sky was blue, I would be _checking_.

(At some point he seems to have gone from professionally-wrong-about-everything blogger to magical-podcast-thought-leader. I have no idea how this happened.)

Re: OpenClaw is changing my life

#379

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There's got to be some quantity of astroturfing going on, given the players and the dollar amounts at stake.

Some ? I'd be shocked if it's less than 70% of everything AI-related in here. For example a lot of pro-OpenAI astroturfing really wanted you to know that 5.3 scored better than opus on terminal-bench 2.0 this week, and a lot of Anthropic astroturfing likes to claim that all your issues with it will simply go away as soon as you switch to a $200/month plan (like you can't try Opus in the cheaper one and realise it's d…

You can try opus in the cheaper one if you enable extra usage, though.

Re: OpenClaw is changing my life

#380

There's an odd trend with these sorts of posts where the author claims to have had some transformative change in their workflow brought upon by LLM coding tools, but also seemingly has nothing to show for it. To me, using the most recent ChatGPT Codex (5.3 on "Extra High" reasoning), it's incredibly obvious that while these tools are surprisingly good at doing repetitive or locally-scoped tasks, they immediately fall…

I can’t speak for anyone else, but Claude Code has been transformative for me.

I can’t say it’s led to shipping “high quality projects”, but it has let me accomplish things I just wouldn’t have had time for previously.

I’ve been wanting to develop a plastic -> silicone -> plaster -> clay mold making process for years, but it’s complex and mold making is both art and science. It would have been hundreds of hours before, with maybe 12 hours of Claude code I’m almost there (some nagging issues… maybe another hour).

And I had written some home automation stuff back with Python 2.x a decade ago; it was never worth the time to refamiliarize myself with in order to update, which led to periodic annoyances. 20 minutes, and it’s updated to all the latest Python 3.x and modern modules.

For me at least, the difference between weeks and days, days and hours, and hours and minutes has allowed me to do things I just couldn’t justify investing time in before. Which makes me happy!

So maybe some folks are “pretending”, or maybe the benefits just aren’t where you’re expecting to see them?

Post reply on HN