Live data from Hacker News

4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawyer tells BBC

bbc.co.uk

371–380 of 451 posts

Re: 4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawyer tells BBC

#371

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I understand the people might wanna block porn on their kids mobile internet and home WiFi. So why don't they mandate their ISP to implement this as an optional feature ? Why do they instead try to boil the ocean by going after every website on the planet and outside of their jurisdiction?

The ISPs already do this. Most mobile networks are even opt-out, not in, to this feature. The new law is unnecessary overreach. They either don’t know what they are doing technically (alarming) or are just authoritarian (very alarming)

I don't think ISP DNS solution is very effective when all major web browsers implement DoH by default.

Re: 4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawyer tells BBC

#372
post #315

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I heard things about UK arresting people for social media posts but thought it was just a few cases cherry picked. But I recently looked up the scale of arrests and it's really insane. Police are arresting over 12,000 people each year for social media posts and other online communications deemed “grossly offensive,” “indecent,” “obscene,” or “menacing.” This averages to around 33 arrests per day. These arrests are pr…

By the way at that scale it is very counterproductive. If you are gonna end up being arrested for protesting or giving your opinion, it is funnier to do it in the streets than on facebook. And it is probably much easier to be anonymous nowadays in the streets with a mask than on social media. This is probably why the UK went in flame recently, the government cracked down on the Internet and people just went in the st…

Wasn't there some documentary a few years ago about UK citizens protesting in masks? Narrated by that guy from The Matrix?

Re: 4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawyer tells BBC

#373
post #160

Earlier quoted context omitted.

We need a DNS server with a history database, not just a cache, preferably with a distributed history database. Visit a website and it was blocked by the "official" DNS? Declare the IP invalid in the webUI (or the browser plugin) of the local DNS and it will get you the previous IP from the database.

Or teach people how to point to a different DNS server in an area with laws more amenable to their preferences.

Until coutry implement the great firewall and it becomes a play of cat & mouse.

Re: 4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawyer tells BBC

#374

The next step I assume is banning VPN use for anyone under 18 in the UK, followed by only allowing academics or certain roles to use them.

Banning VPNs seems effectively impossible. Any ip address can act as a vpn. There are also zero identity providers like mullvad.

I am pretty sure we are slowly but surely heading towards a point where every country will implement its own great firewall and block every website except those in a whitelist approved by the government.

Re: 4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawyer tells BBC

#375
post #325
post #102

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> See BlueSky just rolled out Terms ToS that the automated UN Safety (censorship) laws they will accept. This is an automated pipeline for the "censorship demand data notice" can be applied in an automated why. I feel like you are missing some words or have some typos because this isn't comprehensible English.

It's an understandable English even for non-native speaker like me. You are probably not very exposed to non-native speakers.

I am non-native speaker and I confirm that the post was gibberish.

Re: 4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawyer tells BBC

#376

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Unfortunately the representatives in Congress gave the tariff power to the Presidency. Now, did they do that with the approval of the voters? Ostensibly, yes, but in reality, it's not that clear-cut. This would be more like if the Thirteen Colonies had MPs and those MPs still voted in favor of the Stamp Act, or they voted to delegate the power to tariff to someone with a severe personality disorder.

There are lawsuits arguing that Congress didn’t give the executive branch this power. They seem pretty persuasive to me and they’re successful so far, but we’ll see how the appeals process turns out.

sigh

There are a lot of lawsuits about the executive branch doing things it supposedly doesn't have the power to do.

Generally the mood seems to be that only a SCOTUS ruling will potentially be taken seriously.

Re: 4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawyer tells BBC

#377

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Everyone also had the choice to vote Green or Liberal Democrat. I believe both promise electoral reform.

They can promise whatever they like knowing there's very little chance they will be put to the test. The last time the Lib Dems got a taste of power in 2010 it was by going into coalition with the Tories at the cost of dumping key election pledges. Next election they were dumped by the public and their leader Nick Clegg was hired by Meta - presumably for his connections as he has no particular talent to sell.

The Lib Dems made a referendum on a fairer voting method a condition of the coalition, and they got their referendum. I see no reason to doubt they'd implement electoral reform if elected.

Re: 4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawyer tells BBC

#378

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They can try. > And how we burned in the camps later, thinking: What would things have been like if every Security operative, when he went out at night to make an arrest, had been uncertain whether he would return alive and had to say good-bye to his family? Or if, during periods of mass arrests, as for example in Leningrad, when they arrested a quarter of the entire city, people had not simply sat there in their lai…

Would have. Should have. Could have. The reality is the authoritarians won for decades.

Yee, but we haven't yet given this fight up. And I plan to never.

Re: 4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawyer tells BBC

#379

Americans complaining about extra-territorial application of laws? As much as I dislike the OSA, if you're not in the UK you can -- and probably should -- just ignore it. Unless you care specifically about interacting with users or businesses in the UK, in which case you probably need to comply. Unlike the USA, we're generally incapable of successfully demanding everyone everywhere go along with whatever overreach we…

I am Canadian and I worry that usually what happens in UK ends up coming to Canada too.

Re: 4chan will refuse to pay daily online safety fines, lawyer tells BBC

#380
post #179

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The goal of the policy is supported by the voters. The polls used to measure this are shifty at best about the implementation details. Who doesn't want to prevent kids from looking at pornography? But plenty of things are popular if you ask people in a way that makes them ignore how it plays out in real life. Laws against tall buildings are a pretty good example. Land reform was extremely popular in many socialist co…

> Land reform was extremely popular in many socialist countries until it actually happened Actually, land reforms were spectacularly popular—and very successful—in many countries like Guatemala or Vietnam (coincidentally, two places that were invaded by the US in an attempt to revert those reforms, one successful and the other not).

That's not really the point. You can always think of another example. I was talking about the Online Safety Act.
Post reply on HN