Live data from Hacker News

Why Google+ Failed

onezero.medium.com

371–375 of 375 posts

Re: Why Google+ Failed

#371

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Sounds like they were trying to emulate the early days of FB some people pine for where you had to have a .edu email address to sign up. I know a few friend were hopeful that Google+ meant they would no longer see posts from their racist uncle or gullible aunt. Start out with that same kind of exclusivity and hopefully it builds this exclusive mystique so when you open it up to everybody you get a flood. Perhaps the…

Facebook had what turned out to be an accidentally brilliant way of bootstrapping networks and trust. Fundamental problem: social networks with no-one on them are not fun and not sticky. Fundamental problem 2: if anyone can read what you're writing, it's not a social network, it's a blog. So you can't just let anyone see what people are writing. The way FB handled that in the early days was that by default, people in…

In the early days, you could only friend people at your school because that's who was colocated on your MySQL shard. Fully general addressing of sharded objects was added quite a bit later, about when they opened to non-.edu addresses.

Re: Why Google+ Failed

#372
post #117

I think a lot of it came down to their "invite-only" launch. I remember a lot of my friends were excited to try it. Some of us were able to get invites, some weren't. Eventually the people who couldn't get on right away just said "screw it" and went back to Facebook. The rest of us followed because that's where we could interact with everyone and not just the people who happened to get on Google+. By the time it open…

I think they did that because of how well it worked for GMail. And Facebook was restricted too in the beginning. Obviously, Google+ didn't benefit from following the precedents set by other successful launches.

[deleted]

Re: Why Google+ Failed

#373
The killer for me was that I thought the "circles" I created were mine. I didn't realize, and assume Google wanted me not to realize, that the people I put in circles could see each other.

Once I did know I then put everyone in their own circle, probably not what Google+ was hoping for but by then I distrusted the entire system.

Re: Why Google+ Failed

#375
post #337
post #185

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think it was way less than that. Wasn't it like ... 2MB?

No. It was 1 GB: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_Gmail "after considering alternatives such as 100 MB, the company finally settled upon 1 GB of space, a figure that was preposterous compared to the 2 to 4 MB that was the standard at the time.[3]" "On 1 April 2005, exactly one year after the initial release, Gmail increased the mailbox size to 2 GB, advertising it as 2GB plus" The sample of the news from thes…

I referred to what Hotmail had at the time.
Post reply on HN