Live data from Hacker News

New Evidence of Age Bias in Hiring, and a Push to Fight It

nytimes.com

371–380 of 451 posts

Re: New Evidence of Age Bias in Hiring, and a Push to Fight It

#371
post #323
post #227

Earlier quoted context omitted.

As a 50+ chap, I had an instance of a top company, referred by friend, whole team up for it and to not even get an interview as I got `filtered` by HR and the recruitment process. Turns out they rejected me as I was `overqualified`. Equally in my early years pre PC mainstream days, there was an age bias towards older people. With many personal experiences upon that in that time/culture - including, believe it or not…

Dare say starting out today is easier than it was pre internet boom. Hard to say without a time machine, but from talking to juniors & students (I have a lot of friends who teach) it sounds harder to get that first job than it was when I was starting out (I'm 36). My completely unscientific gut feeling was that it was the easiest to get started in tech in the late 90s & right as the industry started recovering from t…

I used to get, can you start Monday? pretty often after an hour interview back in the day. Sure miss that, and considering I’m a much better dev now it’s a travesty.

Re: New Evidence of Age Bias in Hiring, and a Push to Fight It

#372

Earlier quoted context omitted.

As a gen-x'er, I wonder about being caught in the middle. I was too young for boomers (started as weekend tech in 9th grade). Now I sense I'm too old for millennials. Supposedly both demo groups strongly prefer their own. Whereas us x'ers were so few, we just had to get along with everyone.

As a gen-xer, I fucking love where I'm at. I have the perfect combination of knowing how to to fix my toilet and my wifi (was third engineer at Aruba - suck it).

Good attitude, thanks.

Re: New Evidence of Age Bias in Hiring, and a Push to Fight It

#373
post #256

A few years ago I worked at a ~50 person startup, where an informal poll revealed everyone on the engineering team to be in an age range of ~24-30. One day we interviewed an insanely qualified dude in his mid-50s. He’d worked with technologicies up and down our stack, their competitors, and their predecessors, and could speak at length to their relative strengths and weaknesses. Tons of open source contributions, men…

Engineering manager was afraid a more experienced dev could call him out on his bullshit. Not being willing to manage someone older than you is likely a sign of cowardice. The first and second really good developers I worked with were around 35 and 45 when I met them.

This - basically if you are overqualified, and dont jump on the hype-train anymore, and know that all the tech-"trends" are cyclic and have been there at least once - you could wake up the whole team, destroying the cult like atmosphere.

Re: New Evidence of Age Bias in Hiring, and a Push to Fight It

#374

Is this something exclusive to white collar jobs or is it mostly programming? Asking as my day job is in the skilled trade of engine mechanic. If youre over 45 in a machine shop or in any trade (plumbing, electrical, automotive, HVAC, etc...) your biggest barrier to getting any job is picking up the phone when it rings. Johnson Control, Honeywell, heck even people like Nest and Ford are kicking down your door and off…

I suspect its west coast USA, particularly start ups. If you're in your 50's then you probably won't put up with the nonsense startups say. As friend of mine says - I wouldn't work for lottery tickets (shares).

Re: New Evidence of Age Bias in Hiring, and a Push to Fight It

#375
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How many employers do you find yourself needing to exclude because of the “no Leetcode” thing? Do you think you’re sacrificing anything in the way of comp by doing so?

I've got about 20 years of professional coding under my belt including a 5 year stint doing a lot of job hopping/consulting. I'd never even heard of leetcode until this post and won't bother to even visit the website. For most of my career I've been in the group giving interviews. I don't recall having ever seen it mentioned on a resume. It's a complete and total nothing for any employer I've ever worked for/with. Ba…

Believe they are using it as a generic term for gun-to-head coding challenge fashion.

Re: New Evidence of Age Bias in Hiring, and a Push to Fight It

#376
post #61

I’m 45. I didn’t start aggressively job hopping until I was 35, before then I stayed at one job for almost 10 years. I haven’t once had a problem finding a job quickly. I was a generalist when I was 35 and started down the road of specializing in the Microsoft stack in 2008. I start pivoting in 2016 to more architect level roles but still staying hands on but with more cross platform languages (.Net Core, Node, Pytho…

Why not both? Skimming through CtCI only takes a few hours.

My experience is that the questions can be anything from multiple fields.

Re: New Evidence of Age Bias in Hiring, and a Push to Fight It

#377
post #256

A few years ago I worked at a ~50 person startup, where an informal poll revealed everyone on the engineering team to be in an age range of ~24-30. One day we interviewed an insanely qualified dude in his mid-50s. He’d worked with technologicies up and down our stack, their competitors, and their predecessors, and could speak at length to their relative strengths and weaknesses. Tons of open source contributions, men…

Engineering manager was afraid a more experienced dev could call him out on his bullshit. Not being willing to manage someone older than you is likely a sign of cowardice. The first and second really good developers I worked with were around 35 and 45 when I met them.

[deleted]

Re: New Evidence of Age Bias in Hiring, and a Push to Fight It

#378

One thing I'm a bit confused about is why doesn't salary bidding fix this? For example if a 25 yr old coder is $X per year surely, even if you have terrible age discrimination, there must be some salary level, say $0.75*X where having the older worker is preferable? Is it that older workers are much more expensive and are bidding themselves out the market? Is it that people value youth so much they will pay a 3x mark…

I know this is just personnel experience so don't take it for much but I had to share an office with a 70 year old "programmer" who made three times my salary. I know this because my supervisor got drunk on a business trip and told me the day after he fired the guy. He was constantly asking everyone how to do the simplest of tasks and complaining about being under payed and discriminated against because of his age an…

I’ve seen many younger folks who couldn’t code their way out of a paper bag. Both anecdotes useless.

Re: New Evidence of Age Bias in Hiring, and a Push to Fight It

#379

One thing I'm a bit confused about is why doesn't salary bidding fix this? For example if a 25 yr old coder is $X per year surely, even if you have terrible age discrimination, there must be some salary level, say $0.75*X where having the older worker is preferable? Is it that older workers are much more expensive and are bidding themselves out the market? Is it that people value youth so much they will pay a 3x mark…

Once you’re old, you typically don’t get to the negotiating salary stage.

Re: New Evidence of Age Bias in Hiring, and a Push to Fight It

#380

Earlier quoted context omitted.

other HN threads have debated heavily about why the startup industry is centered in SV, given its ultra high cost of living and labor. and yet, despite everything, SV remains at the center. and that's why i think your explanation is closer to the truth. higher salaries for older workers wouldn't matter. what does matter is that management thinks older workers will bring the wrong sauce to the product, exhibit reasona…

The startup sector is centered here because the money (VC firms) is here. The reason for that is largely historical accident.

Money can easily move. Money chooses to be there due to wanting to be there, good weather, terrain, politics, etc. There is some due to historical effects, but more people than not consider CA coast weather to be pretty ideal, hence the higher cost of living.
Post reply on HN