Live data from Hacker News

Affinity Studio now free

affinity.studio

361–370 of 825 posts

Re: Affinity Studio now free

#361
post #248

Why did they force the use of Safari to sign into the app? What's the disrespect with the user's browser of choice (and one that already has the valid token)?

There is no code in Canva that specifically opens Safari, it would be a `ASWebAuthenticationSession` from macOS.

Safari is used by default, other browsers have to support this feature to use it and do not, so you just get Safari.

Re: Affinity Studio now free

#362

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Raw formats arent going away but new cameras and lenses do keep coming out which at minimum need correction profiles. Also the DNG spec does continue to be iterated on, not that users will be forced into the latest features like jpeg-xl compression, but some of the changes can be very breaking to older apps.

I haven't checked, do they use Apple's RAW library on macOS? If so, at least support might evolve with macOS updates for the time being.

Serif (I guess Canva now) maintains their own which uses the Lensfun database.

Re: Affinity Studio now free

#363
post #156

Yet after decades, Gimp still can't compete even with programs built from scratch :D

GIMP is open source if you want to go help improve it ;)

I tried ;) GIMP developers aren't very open to external contributions. I don't consider my attempts to be of low quality either, but the bike shedding resulted in them never being accepted. "It's best to wait until X lands" or "I think this will be part of Y".

Meanwhile, 10 years later, the functional features I've tried to contribute are still not possible in GIMP ;)

Re: Affinity Studio now free

#364

I'm feeling some real hurt seeing this announcement. I bought the Affinity v1 apps, buying into the vision for a no-BS forever app. I was surprised to see a v2 app show up a year after I bought into v1 with what I remember was something like a 25% discount. But this was going to be the new forever app, and I understand wanting to get things right on a second pass. Reading about how v2 will no longer get updates just…

Well this puts them on my blacklist. And I am an educator in precisely the artschool they would profit off catering to.

I refuse to teach my student tools that change the contract once you bought into them.

Adobe is on that list too.

The only major non-open source software that isn't is anything by Black Magic or Steam, both companies that have found healthy sustainable business models and jave acted reliable towards creaters and the open source community they relied on in their humbe beginnings.

Re: Affinity Studio now free

#365

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Unfortunately there is no realistic vector drawing open source app for MacOS. Inkscape is still basically unusable with extreme lag. LibreDraw is ok for very basic things. But that's about it.

> Inkscape is still basically unusable with extreme lag. ?? I use Inkscape every day on macOS and it runs just fine, equivalent to on Windows/Linux. It was pretty bad a few years back but has caught up.

Same here.. I don't use it often, but it is fairly quick on my M2. It did have some mouse focus issues, you have to click around a bit more but that's okay-ish.

Re: Affinity Studio now free

#366

It's a smart approach imo. They had to get a subscription somehow to support AI features which they need to compete (just usage cost wise you can't do that on a one time fee license). But since they promised not to go subscription when they got acquired by Canva, making it free with AI as the subscription is a clever solution to not break their promise while still introducing a subscription model. I think their bet i…

I have a free subscription to Adobe Creative Cloud (I was a long-time, early employee and negotiated this as a perk). One reason I paid for and use Affinity is that it DOESN'T have AI. I want to be completely sure the photos I edit don't go up to a "cloud" somewhere, etc.

Re: Affinity Studio now free

#367

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Would you prefer they just kept charging you for the product? Yes, exactly. Knowing that my interests, my consumer spending choices, are the direct feedback path to their profitability is one of the only ways to provide some concrete assurances that they'll be building for the customer's needs and not for data collection, AI shovelware, or some other play.

Did that stop Adobe moving towards a subscription model?

People complain about Adobe's subscription model but it's superior to free-to-play consumer software because it still keeps an alignment between the consumer interest and the company's income. Despite its other faults, you could even argue that a consumer subscription model can be better aligned than single purchase software because the customer needs to continually choose to pay the company for its use and it incentivizes continually improvement and competition.

Re: Affinity Studio now free

#368
post #202

Well, I downloaded the Mac app, and here's what I don't like: - Goodness gracious, that icon. And 3.5GB????? - Requires a login (so I suppose no disconnected operation) - Seems to jumble together the vector, bitmap and publishing apps (which I very much prefer to have as separate things) Mostly everything I've been able to try in 30 minutes seems to work, but a 3.5GB app is a sad sign of the times. Will most likely k…

> so I suppose no disconnected operation)

You're wrong about that point, it works offline just fine after activation. It's even stated in their FAQ. Of course it's possible for them to change that at any time.

Re: Affinity Studio now free

#369

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That sounds like ongoing work that you should pay for if you want to benefit.

Yeah, but Lensfun (the library they use for this) doesn't have anywhere to donate.

That does make things a bit more complicated.

Re: Affinity Studio now free

#370
post #238

This is a deletion. - they're completely stopping all updates to v2; even image trace won't be coming to it. You might have paid for perpetual access to it 2 months ago, but it has completely stopped. As the world moves on (new chips, new OS features, just general software movement) this will increasingly feel like a second-class experience. - the new "free" software is a sales funnel into the paid subscription, and…

I did pay for perpetual access to it 2 months ago! :)

As a windows PC user I am hoping the compatibility issues wont effect me and I can enjoy the product offline.

Post reply on HN