Live data from Hacker News

Denmark close to wiping out cancer-causing HPV strains after vaccine roll-out

gavi.org

361–370 of 393 posts

Re: Denmark close to wiping out cancer-causing HPV strains after vaccine roll-out

#361

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The Walgreens pharmacist scolded my 35 year old girlfriend for getting it, saying that it was useless at her age. She insisted and he reluctantly administered the first dose (and later got the rest at another location). He even questioned her motives for getting it once she was in the room. I was appalled by the whole interaction. Maybe I could have understood if I had said she was my wife. But it is still stupid to…

Gotta love the logic of telling adults not to get the vaccine because its probably too late and you're already infected, while also telling parents not to give it to their kids because it's only for "prostitutes and promiscuous gay men" (per RFK)

> it's only for "prostitutes and promiscuous gay men" (per RFK)

It’s almost as though he has had a brain injury.

Re: Denmark close to wiping out cancer-causing HPV strains after vaccine roll-out

#363

Earlier quoted context omitted.

In Denmark its not recommended for women over a certain age. So please don’t get it regardless of age. Its not really considered effective for women who have been sexually active for some time. Which is why its only recommended for girls, not women. https://www.ssi.dk/vaccinationer/boernevaccination/vaccinati... . Tldr; Dont rush to get a vaccine that is probably not effective for you. Make an appointment with your d…

Even if there's a small chance that it would make a difference, wouldn't it be worth it if you have the money and you feel like it's your duty to protect others ? At worst, it's useless and you have contributed to make a vaccine more profitable (which, IIUC is a problem for vaccines ?)

At worst, it's harmful!

From top of my layperson head: bruised insertion sites, tainted needles, tainted vaccine supply, customer capacity crowding for the pharmacy, squeezing supply capacity for actual target demographics, etc etc etc.

Things have tradeoffs, even if they are subtle. Relentless follow-through on marginal protocols should generally be treated with suspicion.

Stranger danger advocates brush off the criticism that most abductions occur among family with the "if there's a small chance it would make a difference" argument, but this ignores the real harms of teaching children to fear everyone by default.

Re: Denmark close to wiping out cancer-causing HPV strains after vaccine roll-out

#365

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is mostly guesswork but I think you need to get the vaccine before you catch it and lots of people have it as they get older. If you have a limited supply the greater bang per buck would be to start with the young people who almost certainly haven't caught it yet and then work your way up.

It's less that and more "we just haven't tested it in older populations yet". Sure you are more likely to have it the older you are but even then you are unlikely to have all the strains. The vaccine covers like 9 or 10 different strains so it can protect you from the other strains even if you already have one of them. It's generally only when you get into the 60s and up that the justification for not recommending th…

> you are recommended to get the shingles vaccine instead of the chickenpox vaccine since the way the disease presents and how the body reacts to it changes with age (technically shingles can happen at any age but generally herpes zoster presents as shingles instead of chickenpox the older you get).

If the underlying virus is the same, what is different between the vaccines? How it presents shouldn't matter as much?

Re: Denmark close to wiping out cancer-causing HPV strains after vaccine roll-out

#366
post #319

Earlier quoted context omitted.

My Dr doesn't give me stuff. But that's only because I'm one of the millions of Americans who has no healthcare beyond what can paid out of my pocket. Not his fault.

Surely he can give you a prescription.

He could but then I'd still need to pay for the vaccine - which is the issue. Specifically, I would be adding the vaccine onto the long, long list of medical stuff (vaccines, tests, procedures) that I need to buy if the funds ever come available.

Re: Denmark close to wiping out cancer-causing HPV strains after vaccine roll-out

#367

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Which vaccines that are widely used today do you believe are unsafe? And why do you believe they’re unsafe? > “anti-vax" is a term used to dismiss [dissent] No, it’s a term used to dismiss people who keep bringing up the same arguments that have been refuted over and over.

All the brand new vaccines with no sufficient testing can be considered unsafe. I like vaccines in general (I am European, we have lots of free and mandatory vaccines as kids), but I don't like to be a test subject for brand new ones. Yes, someone needs to test new vaccines to gather data about safety, but some people are more risk adverse. I am a "take it later" guy.

I specified "widely used", which effectively excludes brand-new vaccines.

I don't have any issue with what you're describing. The J&J COVID vaccine would be an example of caution being advisable, since you never know what unusual interactions (e.g. with blood clotting) might occur in a larger population than the safety studies looked at.

But that's not the usual definition of an anti-vaxxer.

Anti-vaxxers carry on about things like thimerasol which (1) were removed from most vaccines 25 years ago and (2) give you an exposure to mercury equivalent to eating something like a single can of tuna.

Re: Denmark close to wiping out cancer-causing HPV strains after vaccine roll-out

#368

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Gotta love the logic of telling adults not to get the vaccine because its probably too late and you're already infected, while also telling parents not to give it to their kids because it's only for "prostitutes and promiscuous gay men" (per RFK)

[flagged]

I'm so sorry you and your family are going through that. My condolences, from an internet stranger with family members with cancer as well.

I don't condone violence or wish ill upon anyone... But there are certainly some people that I'm just like, fuck that guy. And yeah, fuck RFK.

Re: Denmark close to wiping out cancer-causing HPV strains after vaccine roll-out

#369
post #363

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Even if there's a small chance that it would make a difference, wouldn't it be worth it if you have the money and you feel like it's your duty to protect others ? At worst, it's useless and you have contributed to make a vaccine more profitable (which, IIUC is a problem for vaccines ?)

At worst, it's harmful! From top of my layperson head: bruised insertion sites, tainted needles, tainted vaccine supply, customer capacity crowding for the pharmacy, squeezing supply capacity for actual target demographics, etc etc etc. Things have tradeoffs, even if they are subtle. Relentless follow-through on marginal protocols should generally be treated with suspicion. Stranger danger advocates brush off the cri…

Thank you for a sane comment in this discussion.

Re: Denmark close to wiping out cancer-causing HPV strains after vaccine roll-out

#370

Earlier quoted context omitted.

RFK Jr wasn't doing anything worth talking about during the multiple times in the past 15 years my doctors have told me it wasn't recommended. Please do not turn mainstream medical advice into a fringe position.

I got 3 doses of gardasil at 37 in Norway. I do not want to expose women to a potentially deadly virus (plus I’d also like to avoid having penile cancer and mouth/throat cancer myself). If your doctor is seriously advising you against taking the vaccine, you should consult another doctor for a second opinion.

I trust my doctor ... he's not some quack. I've looked online (multiple times over the years) and he's simply applying federal guidelines.

Family members have died from cervical cancer so I get it. I also made sure my younger children received this vaccine.

There a ton of vaccines I could seek out. Why HPV specifically?

Post reply on HN