Live data from Hacker News

Unsafe and Unpredictable: My Volvo EX90 Experience

myvolvoex90.com

361–370 of 436 posts

Re: Unsafe and Unpredictable: My Volvo EX90 Experience

#361
post #348

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The image at the top of the article is obviously AI generated so it indicates that the rest of the article might be as well.

Understood ... thanks for clarifying ... I'm genuinely intrigued. You're right that image is generated by a generative model, however my humble blog content .... I do write myself. "Don't judge a book by its cover!" ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

The dude is being ridiculous. I use AI / Stock Photos for cover images. Plenty of people are fine with it.

Re: Unsafe and Unpredictable: My Volvo EX90 Experience

#362

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The image at the top of the article is obviously AI generated so it indicates that the rest of the article might be as well.

That is ridiculous. Having a hero image being AI (most people are crap with image editing) doesn't meant the rest of it is.

They didn't say "is" they said "might be," which is a reasonable assumption to make given how ubiquitous the use of AI has become. One has to assume all content one encounters online is at best AI assisted and at worst entirely AI generated unless some explicit statement to the contrary is made, and even then, one should doubt.

Re: Unsafe and Unpredictable: My Volvo EX90 Experience

#363

Volvo sadly no longer stands for Swedish quality and safety. What you’re buying is essentially an overpriced Chinese car with Volvo stickers. And I’m saying this as a Swede. Buy German cars, specifically within the Volkswagen auto group (Audi, VW, Skoda etc) if you want reliable quality.

I owned a brand new 2024 Audi A6 and the infotainment system, general software, and driver assist functionality was absolutely atrocious to the point of rendering the car inoperable from time to time. Audi refused to acknowledge there was an issue so I sold it privately.

Avoid like the absolute plague.

Re: Unsafe and Unpredictable: My Volvo EX90 Experience

#364
post #62

The best cars were built between 2000 and 2010. Pretty much the pinnacle of the internal combustion engine without all the millions of lines of buggy code that apparently no longer allow you to open your car freely.

Yep. Many of them are still good and are on the road even with 100,000s of miles on them. Best car I had was a 2007 Vauxhall Astra. Did about 150,000 miles (and I really ragged it). Still on the road apparently. The 2012 Vauxhall Insignia I have isn't great and I regret selling the Astra. Will be selling that car soon.

Re: Unsafe and Unpredictable: My Volvo EX90 Experience

#365

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They understand the importance of software, but they do not understand software, and they don't understand and respect the different way of working that you need for software vs hardware. I've heard somebody describe it as "they are using methods that have been known not to work for 20 years".

>They understand the importance of software, but they do not understand software But they know that. That was the idea behind Cariad. Having a new company, unburdened by what other parts of the company are doing, which is doing just software. Giving them the freedom to do things a different way has always been the intention. What you are describing is not an automotive problem, it is a Europe wide problem. Software E…

> Software Engineers in Europe, in general, are pretty bad

> "German engineering" has not translated into software at all.

Anecdata: in my 10+ years experience, the worst UX, UI, code and SWEs I've seen, are all German. I'm not saying there's absolutely no good ones here and there, but in general it seems the love for a very complex written/spoken language (riddled with rules and exception) and bureaucracy has translated 100% into software. The interfaces, the code and coding style most of the times give me a 1980s vibe if I'm lucky, or just scare me off altogether in most cases. The code tends to be more complex, abstract, hard to read and comprehend, for no good reason.

Re: Unsafe and Unpredictable: My Volvo EX90 Experience

#366

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They understand the importance of software, but they do not understand software, and they don't understand and respect the different way of working that you need for software vs hardware. I've heard somebody describe it as "they are using methods that have been known not to work for 20 years".

>They understand the importance of software, but they do not understand software But they know that. That was the idea behind Cariad. Having a new company, unburdened by what other parts of the company are doing, which is doing just software. Giving them the freedom to do things a different way has always been the intention. What you are describing is not an automotive problem, it is a Europe wide problem. Software E…

I am a German software engineer. I dunno, I see more under-engineering than overengineering. But I don't work in automotive, where they do, or used to, overengineer things pretty badly - and in pretty silly ways, too, i.e. not usually defensible in some reasonable way. Software salaries are actually pretty good for Europe now, as far as I know, especially... in automotive. But that still doesn't fix the culture. The inital Cariad CEO was just some nondescript car industry guy - they may have tried to have a different culture, but why put a guy in charge who represents the old culture? The current Cariad CEO is a mechanical engineer by education and previously worked in production and logistics. It's baffling. They can't be that stupid (right?), so I think it's mechanical engineering resisting a loss of power and importance.

Re: Unsafe and Unpredictable: My Volvo EX90 Experience

#367
post #166

I’m just happier and happier with my ‘dumb’ car. It has physical buttons for the aircon. No wifi = no speakers listening to me and selling my personal data (yep that’s a thing) I have to press a button on the key fob to open it so it can’t be stolen by relaying the signal. It’s pretty cheap to run because I hardly drive anywhere anyway. But when I do I just buy this stuff called ‘petrol’ that’s all around the place a…

It doesn't take much driving for a new EV to balance out the environmental cost of harvesting, shipping, pumping, and burning all that petrol. As I understand it, about 20k km or 15k miles, on average.

It is still less environmental damage to keep an old vehicle on the road and not create a new one. Some cars can literally last forever (these models are well known) if they are looked after.

The scrap yards are btw filling up with modern cars quite quickly because people cannot afford to repair new cars, or the cars are uneconomical to repair even after minor collisions. Whereas a lot of old cars (pre-2010) can be fixed on your driveway with easily affordable tools.

Re: Unsafe and Unpredictable: My Volvo EX90 Experience

#368
post #85
post #64

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What reliable is left?

Toyota, Lexus, Subaru, Honda. Not sure if Hyundai & Kia are quite as reliable, but if not it's on them because they have some of the best warranties in the industry.

From what I’ve read, and what I get in the comments here, these too are plagued by electronics and software issues. I’m not sure this category of issues, especially software ones, are correctly taken into account in reliability scores. Ironically my current car (from 2010) doesn’t score too high in reliability, but not having a screen makes that whole class of problems go away.

I hope my current car makes it so that I can entirely skip the current gen cars to hopefully the future one with these issues sorted out, including physical buttons.

Re: Unsafe and Unpredictable: My Volvo EX90 Experience

#369
post #362

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That is ridiculous. Having a hero image being AI (most people are crap with image editing) doesn't meant the rest of it is.

They didn't say "is" they said "might be," which is a reasonable assumption to make given how ubiquitous the use of AI has become. One has to assume all content one encounters online is at best AI assisted and at worst entirely AI generated unless some explicit statement to the contrary is made, and even then, one should doubt.

They are complaining about the hero image (which is pretty inoffensive). Which is ridiculous. It is no different than using a stock image asset for some decoration, which is what people would have used before the current AI tools. Therefore I consider it unreasonable on the face of it.

I shouldn't really have to explain this, but here we are.

I don't care about how you wish to split hairs because I made a minor mistake, nor do I care about your rationalisations for an obviously ridiculous critique.

Re: Unsafe and Unpredictable: My Volvo EX90 Experience

#370
post #262
post #129

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Mazdas too. I find Toyota's suspensions and driving dynamics terrible. Mazda represents a perfect combination of good Japanese reliability and good handling dynamics. I also like that they still offer a proper automatic transmission in their cars (as opposed to the CVT epidemic in other makes), as well as naturally aspirated engine options (whereas many other makes only offer turbos now). The days of their collaborat…

My 2014 Mazda 3 has fairly regular infotainment issues, audio playing on my phone but no audio from the speakers, resolved by rebooting it. Also had an issue with the backup camera cutting out. Was caused by a loose connector. Dealership was unwilling to help for free so I just cleaned the contacts and reseated the connector myself. Months later I received a recall notice with no fix available, still more months late…

A recall notice with no fix for a backup camera? Did they expect you to just cease use of the car entirely or what?
Post reply on HN