Live data from Hacker News

Please tell us what features you'd like in news.ycombinator

news.ycombinator.com

361–370 of 1001 posts

Re: Please tell us what features you'd like in news.ycombinator

#362
An RSS feed which takes me to the comment page of the submission.

Reason being that I like to use live bookmarks in Firefox, and the RSS feed which goes directly to the submitted link means if I want to read the comments left by HN users, I must go to HN's homepage to look for the article, and then click on comments.

Which is a lot of work compared to clicking on the live bookmark entry, then opening up the submitted webpage (in a new tab) from the submission's comment page.

Re: Please tell us what features you'd like in news.ycombinator

#363
Having the footer links found on the main page, especially "guidelines" and "library," be visible when composing a reply to a previous reply would be helpful for sharing those links when composing replies to users who don't know of those helpful resources. In general, it helps me find stuff if the footers are the same regardless of state, whether reading the main page, reading the new submissions page, posting a new submission, or posting a reply to a previous reply.

Re: Please tell us what features you'd like in news.ycombinator

#364
Two feature requests, one question, one comment.

I am aware that occasionally there are great items that don't get a few upvotes quickly, and then get lost in the flurry of other submissions. Submitting something at a popular time is a lottery, and I think many useful items get lost, or go unnoticed.

I'd like to see an alternate ranking system based on votes, replies and page views. Let R be the current score as determined by votes, C be the accumulated votes on the comments, and V be the number of views of the page. Then let the ranking score be something like (R+C)/V. The idea is that pages without views will stay close to the top, encouraging them to be viewed and hence ranked. Pages that elicit no upvotes will then drop quickly, but at least they've been seen.

There probably needs to be a time component in there as well so that items slowly "fade" with time.

I can expand and refine this for anyone interested in seeing waht happens, but I can't produce a mock-up because I don't have access to the "page views" statistic.

Second thing, and much less of a priority, I'd like is the ability to retrieve a single item with its threading information, but not its threading content. My interests aren't entirely aligned with the majority, so I'd like to retrieve every item and then read them in thread for myself. Currently if I pull a given item I get all its sub-comments as well, which I then have to unpick. It's tedious, and I haven't bothered yet, but I can do it. It would be more value to me if I could just pull the text and ID of the parent.

Question: I'm interested to see if this comment gets read. This thread is now 2 1/2 years old. How many people read it, and what path to they take to do so?

Finally, the comment. Thank you for HN. I think it's a fantastic resource, and I look forward to contributing to it for some time to come. I hope I add value.

Re: Please tell us what features you'd like in news.ycombinator

#365
The ability to downmod, or at least retract an upmod on a comment you have upmodded.

Because people are able to edit their comments after you have upmodded them, the comment may change so that you no longer agree with them.

Having this would allow people who edit their comments after gaining attention to be moderated in a more effective manner...

Re: Please tell us what features you'd like in news.ycombinator

#366
Since the only way (from what I can tell) of retrieving your password is to contact pg it would be nice with contact information somewhere. I'd like to have the password reset for my account nop, to the email I put down in the info of that account.

Re: Please tell us what features you'd like in news.ycombinator

#367
Can you link the RSS item to the HN page rather than the submitted story? (e.g. see reddit)

By linking to the story and not the HN post, when following the link one has lost access (like a dangling pointer) to the comments. Currently I must mouse-click the "comments" link in the RSS item instead of using my RSS reader's ability to follow the link, which is a PITA.

Re: Please tell us what features you'd like in news.ycombinator

#368
Simple url filtering:

I know that we have to be careful how much we tax the servers for HN, but I thought of a simplistic and low-processing overhead for allowing users to block certain domains.

1) Allow us to input a list of domains we don't want to see links to.

Ex: csmonitor.com, godaddy.com, codinghorror.com etc.

2) Modify the item listings on the various listing pages to include a class that is the url's domain.

Ex: So if the link's url is http://x.com/asdfasdf the link listing would be class 'x.com'

3) Implement a basic css command generated on page load that adds our domains listed in part 1 and adds a 'display: none;' for them.

4) Win!

Obviously it's imperfect, you'll get less than the max items on a page, and users will notice numbers missing for the hidden links.

Re: Please tell us what features you'd like in news.ycombinator

#369
It would be great if the "# comments" links had a different a:visited color. Many times I can tell by the title of a link that I have no real interest in reading it, but if it has "30 comments" I think "Hm, I bet someone said something worthwhile in there." But if I read 10 comment threads like that and come back later in the day, I have no visual feedback as to which are truly "unread."
Post reply on HN