Live data from Hacker News

World's first no-kill eggs go on sale in Berlin (2018)

theguardian.com

361–370 of 427 posts

Re: World's first no-kill eggs go on sale in Berlin (2018)

#361

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I value ethics and empathy deeply but, I don't understand vegans and vegetarians. Their biggest line of defense is "animals are alive and they have feelings and senses, we abuse them for food". That's sadly right. And they implicitly say that "eating plants are OK because, plants are not animals and they're just happen to grow. They don't feel, they don't understand". On the contrary, there's a growing mountain of re…

As a real vegan (not a meme about vegans that you saw from meat eaters) I can confidently tell you that "animals are alive and they have feelings and senses, we abuse them for food" is not my biggest line of defense. My biggest lines of defense are: * Dr. Kim Williams, former president of the American College of Cardiology, said "there are two kinds of cardiologists, vegans, and those who haven't read the data" * Ani…

For an alternative perspective that refutes a bit of this, maybe meat is actually the more environmentally healthy and human healthy way of going about things?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MxW-JKLeu1k

Blog version w/ reference links: https://www.sapien.org/blog/why-we-should-be-eating-more-mea...

Re: World's first no-kill eggs go on sale in Berlin (2018)

#363

I wonder where anti-abortion people come down on this. In their view, isn’t destroying the male egg the same as culling the male chick?

For anti-abortion vegans/vegetarians, quite possibly. If you're already eating meat, you're already demonstrably OK with the killing of an animal.

> anti-abortion vegans/vegetarians

Probably not many out there. Which is funny since it would seem at a distance to come from the same instinct. My best guess is that it's political tribalism that creates the split.

Re: World's first no-kill eggs go on sale in Berlin (2018)

#364
I had no idea male chicks were disposed. As a vegetarian, I understand humans killing animals for food(people have done this for generations). At the end of the day we share a huge amount of DNA with other animals (so we're a lot like other animals that eat other animals to stay alive).

It's nice that someone figured out a way to optimize this and reduce unnecessary death. Massive kudos to them.

I've been raised to think: "what if there was a higher species of Aliens that farmed humans for their meat?" Yeah I definitely wouldn't want those aliens to kill me just because I'm male.

Re: World's first no-kill eggs go on sale in Berlin (2018)

#365

I suppose it's slightly more animal friendly. On the other hand it just seems like another step into the direction of turning the chickens into optimized food machines. Would be more interested in seeing more means of producing tasty food without using animals and at reduced costs to the environment. Working towards one final giant culling of all unnaturally engineered animals and just continuing on with a small numb…

There’s a moral difficulty here where western societies care a lot about the beginnings of things and can’t stomach things ending, as if the only desirable world is one in which we all experience immortal bliss until the heat death of the universe. Every living thing exists by consuming other living things in some way or another. Every living thing has a beginning, a middle, and an end. Most animals are at least in s…

indeed this is why it's not conflicting for a vegan to be an organ donor.

the problem is that we create beginnings for unnatural endings.

Re: World's first no-kill eggs go on sale in Berlin (2018)

#366
post #355

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If you make people be involved in the killing of millions of baby chicks, they'll suddenly care very, very much. For a few days, then they'll get used to like the 1000 previous generations of humans that had to kill animals to survive.

> like the 1000 previous generations of humans that had to kill animals to survive Just a couple of hundred years ago there wouldn't have been many people killing more animals than they could eat.

https://www.businessinsider.com/giant-ancient-animal-traps-2...

Re: World's first no-kill eggs go on sale in Berlin (2018)

#368

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't have a problem with someone who raises a chicken, uses the chicken's natural existence to improve the local environment (fertilizer, etc.), lets that chicken have a life similar to its life in nature, and gives it a lifespan that isn't dramatically shorter than what it experiences in nature. Eating that chicken and its eggs seems fine to me because that seems like a mutualistic relationship. Asking me to endo…

> I suggest listening more to what vegans have to say about veganism rather than what meateaters have to say about it. That is precisely what brought me to my conclusion. > As I said before, I think you're prejudiced towards vegans and don't really understand what we're about. To the extent that I see the vocal base as having an absolutist view compared to yours, yes. If you're insinuating more connotations associate…

> I'll rescind it the day I see a vegan suggest there is such a thing as ethical meat/egg consumption. It will never happen.

your statement is a "there exists"

one just presented themselves.

will you rescind, or just continue to move the goalposts?

Re: World's first no-kill eggs go on sale in Berlin (2018)

#369
post #347
post #339

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think this just depends on your values and moral code, and there's no clear right or wrong here. I personally do not see a problem with using animals as food. If that's good enough for all the other omnivores and carnivores in the food chain, it's good enough for humans. There are certainly a lot of problems with the sustainability and humane-ness of our livestock farming, but I don't see "become vegetarian/vegan"…

> But I also recognize that a lot of people just don't have any kind of emotional response to this sort of thing, and that's ok too I will guarantee that a massive percentage of people do in fact have a very strong emotional response to this kind of thing, but it's all just "out of sight, out of mind". If you make people be involved in the killing of millions of baby chicks, they'll suddenly care very, very much. Our…

> I will guarantee that a massive percentage of people do in fact have a very strong emotional response to this kind of thing, but it's all just "out of sight, out of mind".

Interesting you hold such expectations. Based on my dealings with people I don't think a lasting response would be that great. Empathy and morals seem to suffice while it is convenient, but when necessary people always take the path of least resistance.

Re: World's first no-kill eggs go on sale in Berlin (2018)

#370

Earlier quoted context omitted.

At the very least it's still less-kill.

How is it less kill if all the male chicks are raised then used for meat? Same number of chickens being killed either way, some just get slightly longer to live.

I was specifically talking about the method from the OP, where male chicks aren't killed (unless you count destroying the egg as killing them).
Post reply on HN